Textar Pads/Zimmerman or Porsche Rotors
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Sandy, UT/Fish Haven, ID
Posts: 3,033
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Textar Pads/Zimmerman or Porsche Rotors
Its brake time all the way around. No track, only street driving.
Is Textar for pads a good choice or stick with Genuine Porsche?
What about Zimmerman rotors vs. Genuine Porsche?
Here is my list I have put together and will get them from Pelican. Im getting a little front end vibration so going replace the bearings. I have 53k miles on the car. Am I missing anything for this brake pad and rotor upgrade?
1 crossed drilled Genuine Porsche rotors
2. Textar pads
3. replace rear and front sensors,
4. anti-squeel pad inserts ?????????
5. front and rear wheel bearings
Is Textar for pads a good choice or stick with Genuine Porsche?
What about Zimmerman rotors vs. Genuine Porsche?
Here is my list I have put together and will get them from Pelican. Im getting a little front end vibration so going replace the bearings. I have 53k miles on the car. Am I missing anything for this brake pad and rotor upgrade?
1 crossed drilled Genuine Porsche rotors
2. Textar pads
3. replace rear and front sensors,
4. anti-squeel pad inserts ?????????
5. front and rear wheel bearings
#3
Rennlist Member
Unsure about the rotors, but OEM pads are Textar ( I would definately go OEM). I wouldn't worry about replacing the sensors. Re-use the old if not broken. As far as the spider anti-squeel junk, pry them off of your new pads, and throw them away. Just my $.02.
#4
Passed On
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Agree that OE pads are Textar - and are great for the street.
Can't remember thoughts on Zimmerman rotors. Did try one set of el-cheapo aftermarket rotors; warped them badly in 10 minutes on the track. Aways went with Porsche rotors after that.
RE sensors and anti-squeal garbage; you don't need them. Pad thickness is easily checked just by looking in at the calipers and pads thru the wheel cutouts around the spokes, and Textar pads don't cause squealing (or if you're scared, spray them with some anti-squeal stickie spray available at any auto parts store before you install them).
Can't remember thoughts on Zimmerman rotors. Did try one set of el-cheapo aftermarket rotors; warped them badly in 10 minutes on the track. Aways went with Porsche rotors after that.
RE sensors and anti-squeal garbage; you don't need them. Pad thickness is easily checked just by looking in at the calipers and pads thru the wheel cutouts around the spokes, and Textar pads don't cause squealing (or if you're scared, spray them with some anti-squeal stickie spray available at any auto parts store before you install them).
#5
Rennlist Member
I thought Zimmermans were disparaged for track driving. Not sure how they fare for street stuff.
Textars and Jurids are OEM pads, the former being the better pad, as well as a fine, novice track pad.
Textars and Jurids are OEM pads, the former being the better pad, as well as a fine, novice track pad.
#7
Technical Guru
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by 95 C4 993
No track, only street driving.
Is Textar for pads a good choice or stick with Genuine Porsche?
What about Zimmerman rotors vs. Genuine Porsche?
Is Textar for pads a good choice or stick with Genuine Porsche?
What about Zimmerman rotors vs. Genuine Porsche?
Trending Topics
#8
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Austin
Posts: 388
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm told that Porsche OEMs several brands of pads...not all are Textar.
I went with Textar brand (not in a Porsche box) and OEM rotors...everything is working great, despite a local shops insistence that ALL pads (including Textar) will squeal. Conversely. I have yet to see a Rennlist post that says the Textars squeal...seems like more shops should spend time reading these posts...
These were assembled sans sensors and spiders.
I went with Textar brand (not in a Porsche box) and OEM rotors...everything is working great, despite a local shops insistence that ALL pads (including Textar) will squeal. Conversely. I have yet to see a Rennlist post that says the Textars squeal...seems like more shops should spend time reading these posts...
These were assembled sans sensors and spiders.
#10
Drifting
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Rockville, MD
Posts: 2,483
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I did all round switch last Octoberish....Textar plus OEM rotors, plus spiders and sensors ..... I got the lot from Sunset Porsche...best price going at the time and very helpful......Why did I not go for the Zimmerman.....1. - the hats rust making the sight through the rims less than desirable, so you either need to spray or get something else, 2. - I have heard, but have no personal experience, that they are more prone to cracking 3. - when I had them on my 951 they squeeeeeelllllllleeeeedddd so much I replaced them and the noise went with them....I did nothing else but replace rotors and the noise went.......so my two cents is textars plus OEM rotors......up to you if you want the spiders and sensors....I did just cos I wanted to.
#11
Textar, Jurid and Pagid are all oem suppliers of pads, the ones that you get through the dealer network are not necessarily the exact same compound as those purchased through the aftermarket.
The same is true of rotors, the Porsche and aftermarket are from the same manufacturerer(s) but the Porsche ones will have corrosion resistatant paint in the hub area, aftermarket will not, there are anecdotal reports of different metalurgy as well, it's hard to imagine that being true, from a production point of view it makes no sense, but who knows?
To me the easiest to clean are the Pagids, the Textars leave a reddish dust that is a PIA to keep clean
All 3 make for fine street pads, except for the dust, of the 3, I liked the aftermarket Pagid Blue best, but have heard good things about Ferodo as well, I think Steve Weiner likes the Ferodos
The same is true of rotors, the Porsche and aftermarket are from the same manufacturerer(s) but the Porsche ones will have corrosion resistatant paint in the hub area, aftermarket will not, there are anecdotal reports of different metalurgy as well, it's hard to imagine that being true, from a production point of view it makes no sense, but who knows?
To me the easiest to clean are the Pagids, the Textars leave a reddish dust that is a PIA to keep clean
All 3 make for fine street pads, except for the dust, of the 3, I liked the aftermarket Pagid Blue best, but have heard good things about Ferodo as well, I think Steve Weiner likes the Ferodos
#12
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Sandy, UT/Fish Haven, ID
Posts: 3,033
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Although Im not a expert by any means with my 993 from a mechanical standpoint , I do my share of research and get opinions on everything I have upgraded over the past 3 years.
I ping Steve W. on occassion (including this exact topic yesterday). Usually when I ping him and get an answer I will still come to a forum and get opinions and not to my suprise, Steve W. is always on the money!! Steve did my ECU upgrade and has helped on other things.
Senors and spiders are probably not that important and looks like Im ready to get the ball rolling in the next few months with my rotors and pads.
Thanks for the feedback!!
I ping Steve W. on occassion (including this exact topic yesterday). Usually when I ping him and get an answer I will still come to a forum and get opinions and not to my suprise, Steve W. is always on the money!! Steve did my ECU upgrade and has helped on other things.
Senors and spiders are probably not that important and looks like Im ready to get the ball rolling in the next few months with my rotors and pads.
Thanks for the feedback!!