Surrendered on allocation game / SE Florida Dealership Reviews
#31
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
@detansinn FL doesn't "blow goats for car enthusiasts" at all. I live here and am a very happy, comfy car enthusiast. It might not be great for DRIVING enthusiasts, however we can DRIVE to some great spots (GA, Carolinas, etc.) that have great driving areas. Each state has some very cool spots to drive, like to the Keys and back, top down, tunes up, having a blast, even if you have some extra goat *** sweat because it is warm. FL could be better and isn't amazing for a driving experience, but hey, every single minute I am driving I am happy! Doesn't matter really where, whatever opportunity I have presented to me is a gift.
Agreed, if your definition of being a "car enthusiast" is staring at your car parked and/or driving on straight flat roads, Florida is entirely adequate.😜
I am just glad that you’re having fun. Have a great holiday!
Last edited by detansinn; 12-24-2023 at 01:58 PM.
The following 2 users liked this post by detansinn:
Freddie Two Bs (12-24-2023),
PHX (12-26-2023)
#32
Last edited by malba2366; 12-24-2023 at 01:56 PM.
#33
Burning Brakes
Less than 2 miles from my house, I'm away from traffic and have access to a wide range of twisty two lane roads that I can take all the way up into the mountains (or the Appalachian equivalent thereof). Having to drive out of the state doesn't make Florida blow goats any less. Heck, I can drive to the Carolinas too. I can also be in West Virginia or New England in a matter of hours. Not as great as California, but entirely serviceable.
Agreed, if your definition of being a "car enthusiast" is staring at your car parked and/or driving on straight flat roads, Florida is entirely adequate.😜
I am just glad that you’re having fun. Have a great holiday!
Agreed, if your definition of being a "car enthusiast" is staring at your car parked and/or driving on straight flat roads, Florida is entirely adequate.😜
I am just glad that you’re having fun. Have a great holiday!
#34
When there are excess cars around (which was the case until mid 2020) they will sell to anyone, however when they can sell all the cars they are getting locally there is no reason to sell cars out of market unless it is with an ADM that local customers will reject. At some point things will change again, and the dealers in smaller markets will be happy to sell out of market because they can't sell all of their allocations locally.
#35
@detansinn FL doesn't "blow goats for car enthusiasts" at all. I live here and am a very happy, comfy car enthusiast. It might not be great for DRIVING enthusiasts, however we can DRIVE to some great spots (GA, Carolinas, etc.) that have great driving areas. Each state has some very cool spots to drive, like to the Keys and back, top down, tunes up, having a blast, even if you have some extra goat *** sweat because it is warm. FL could be better and isn't amazing for a driving experience, but hey, every single minute I am driving I am happy! Doesn't matter really where, whatever opportunity I have presented to me is a gift.
Porsche Naples is an amazing store, although I did not purchase a new 911 there and we bought CPO'ed. Porsche Ft Myers was pretty good with our new 911 purchase when we ordered from there. Yes, it was a poverty spec base cabriolet, however they were not pushy, ADM-ish, or add-on pushy. I don't know about know though. I know this is on the left coast, however you might, OP, have some luck over here if you are still sniffing around the ordering process. As others have said, CPO is a great and amazing way to go, plus it is actually a more interesting way to "shop" for a car, trying to filter though all the available options, colors, etc from the available ones across the country.
Porsche Naples is an amazing store, although I did not purchase a new 911 there and we bought CPO'ed. Porsche Ft Myers was pretty good with our new 911 purchase when we ordered from there. Yes, it was a poverty spec base cabriolet, however they were not pushy, ADM-ish, or add-on pushy. I don't know about know though. I know this is on the left coast, however you might, OP, have some luck over here if you are still sniffing around the ordering process. As others have said, CPO is a great and amazing way to go, plus it is actually a more interesting way to "shop" for a car, trying to filter though all the available options, colors, etc from the available ones across the country.
IMO the OP is right not to bother
Last edited by BondJ; 12-25-2023 at 01:19 PM.
The following users liked this post:
Freddie Two Bs (12-25-2023)
#36
#37
In the UK charging ADM is illegal. There are a certain number of allocations to dealers for a particular model in a specific time frame. Dealers will have their regular, favoured customers who will go to the top of their list for whatever model they order. But, if you lay down enough deposit to prove you’re serious (IMO perfectly reasonable), you’ll get the car…without buying a crap watch. To be clear, I’m not criticising those who choose to pay ADM, just supporting those who won’t
The following users liked this post:
Freddie Two Bs (12-25-2023)
#38
In the UK charging ADM is illegal. There are a certain number of allocations to dealers for a particular model in a specific time frame. Dealers will have their regular, favoured customers who will go to the top of their list for whatever model they order. But, if you lay down enough deposit to prove you’re serious (IMO perfectly reasonable), you’ll get the car…without buying a crap watch. To be clear, I’m not criticising those who choose to pay ADM, just supporting those who won’t
#39
I’m not daft enough to believe that flipping can’t happen but…in the UK the car will have to be registered by the purchaser and subject to VAT. This makes it a pre-owned car, so more expensive to sell on
#40
ahh ok. I wasn’t trying to be a dick like most of Rennlist. Was genuine question. I’ve noticed about 20+ Dakars for sale 2nd market in Europe, some in uk, so was curious.
#41
Burning Brakes
Less than 2 miles from my house, I'm away from traffic and have access to a wide range of twisty two lane roads that I can take all the way up into the mountains (or the Appalachian equivalent thereof). Having to drive out of the state doesn't make Florida blow goats any less. Heck, I can drive to the Carolinas too. I can also be in West Virginia or New England in a matter of hours. Not as great as California, but entirely serviceable.
Agreed, if your definition of being a "car enthusiast" is staring at your car parked and/or driving on straight flat roads, Florida is entirely adequate.😜
I am just glad that you’re having fun. Have a great holiday!
Agreed, if your definition of being a "car enthusiast" is staring at your car parked and/or driving on straight flat roads, Florida is entirely adequate.😜
I am just glad that you’re having fun. Have a great holiday!
Cheers!
The following users liked this post:
detansinn (12-26-2023)
#42
Race Car
Not just in that area of US- many US dealers treat their prime cars as an auction house; i.e. no loyalty to previous customers- just let them go to the highest bidder. Right? Basically an auction house with a Porsche logo on the outside of the damn building.
#43
Rennlist Member
Yeah, Florida blows goats for car enthusiasts. There are no good roads there. In many places, the only way that you’re going to enjoy curves are the highway interchanges. That’s not even addressing how it is miserably hot in the warm months. I spent a few years in Miami and the only reason to bother with something nice is for the flex, which has never been a motivator for me. I’m sure that someone is going to weigh in about that one road that they know somewhere, but even places like Ohio are the land of twisties compared to Florida.
There are so many threads whining about allocations…
There are so many threads whining about allocations…
- If you want a new 911 in your spec, paying a modest ADM like $5k isn’t a big deal and it’s the current market.
- If you have a modern 911 to trade in, that’s likely going to bump you up in line and right now, you will be paying no ADM in most markets.
- Your “place in line” without an allocation means nothing. Everyone gets to cut ahead of you… existing customers, people willing to throw down ADM, VIPs, and heck, even new clients with clear long term potential.
- If you want to further marginalize your position in line and move all the way to the back, insist on “not a dime” over MSRP. That position, completely ignoring the market and who you’re competing with, is the equivalent of being number 42 on the first class standby list, ie not happening. Paying a mere $5k ADM can get you a car. Waiting for MSRP or discounting will cost you years.
- The GTS is the sweet spot… and by sweet spot, I mean the intersection of crushed hopes and disillusionment. There are more people fighting for GTS allocations than anything else. Stop to trying to buy the new 911 that everyone else wants to buy. Sure, it’s a nice trim level, but at the end of the day, it’s still just a Carrera. It’s hilarious to see you all fight over them. It’s much easier to get an allocation for a T (and nearly every other Carrera) than the GTS.
- Build a relationship with a local/local-ish dealer and SA. Be a customer with service potential and a long-tail of current/future business. I know that some people scoff at this and maybe it’s a generational thing, but it has served me well and I like spending money with people who I know and like.
I have a friend (former 997 owner) who wants to get back into the P-car ownership but is aghast at the cost and difficulty getting a car...the changing market, ADMs, and waiting line/periods have him just pained. He has been offered a Carrera T at least twice in the last 6-12 mos w/ADM at $10k and $15k respectively. He declined each as it put the car too much above what he wanted to spend and did on his 997 he said. Fast forward he just got his local dealer call on a Carrera T at $2500 + MSRP, $5k deposit NOW for a $144k build with a summer/Fall delivery date. Yet...he's still at pause due to the cost of acquisition..and most likely the Macan T he got his spouse earlier last Spring also. Still he thinks the dealer and process with Porsche is wrong somehow compared to his previous ownership. My advice to him is the deal is the deal...its not 2009 when he last had a 997 and the cars have changed significantly as have the market. So if he wants a spec'd car (he absolutely is crazed about the car MUST have Carbon Bucket seats) then that is where we are. Unfortunate but reality and he's lucky to have found a local allocation as many guys in the Carrera T forum have been waiting for cars for over 12 mos since announced!
Guys! There’s this thing called the Internet that makes every dealer your dealership! Do NOT limit yourself to what’s local. Buy the car from a dealer in the middle of nowhere that has allocations but no 911 customers. Purchasing the PEC Delivery option can sometimes be a nice way to take a relatively local delivery. I myself will fly and drive up to ~500 miles and that usually makes getting the right car (or motorcycle) at the right price. You will need to spend some quality time on the internet tracking down the websites for all the dealers you’d consider, but it pays quite well to do this.
PCNA doesn't allow dealers to do out of region sales, that's been closed off for a while now. And even these "middle of nowhere" dealers have no cars either. Unless you are willing to pay ADMs of some form, realistically you aren't getting a car. And the economy is being reflated now in 2024 with interest rate cuts and a juiced stock market again, so any macro economic factors that might have led to a dip in demand, that's all over now.
They can't stop it, but they do penalize the selling dealer for selling out of market by reallocating credit of the sale to the customers in market dealers for the purpose of determining future allocations. A significant ADM may change the equation, but at the moment getting a car out of market at MSRP is not going to be an easy task.
Here's an interesting link I saw...some ways I'd say possibly so!
The following users liked this post:
detansinn (12-28-2023)
#44
Drifting
I just don't see anyone posting here that they are getting allocations from "flyover state" dealers, where supply of them are plentiful. Sure maybe technically you can do it, but that isn't viable for most people who can't get allocations.