Walter Röhrl interview (german) - "EV is deviant/abnormal"
#16
#17
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Mar 2016
Location: Washington, Ontario, Michigan
Posts: 892
Received 281 Likes
on
141 Posts
I personally welcome the change however I do hope that ICE doesn't completely die out. I think it's our environmental responsibility at least try and make things better and if EV, trains, and walking/cycling help I am completely for that. I can't write off EVs yet. Who knows we might actually make some really fun and engaging EVs. But if we don't try we'll never get there. I think 10 years from now there will be an EV sports car that will be fun and many of us naysayers will try it and buy in. I'm sure my parents never imagined owning ipads 20 years ago either, I can't pry them out of their hands now.
#18
Originally Posted by richardbf
I personally welcome the change however I do hope that ICE doesn't completely die out. I think it's our environmental responsibility at least try and make things better and if EV, trains, and walking/cycling help I am completely for that. I can't write off EVs yet. Who knows we might actually make some really fun and engaging EVs. But if we don't try we'll never get there. I think 10 years from now there will be an EV sports car that will be fun and many of us naysayers will try it and buy in. I'm sure my parents never imagined owning ipads 20 years ago either, I can't pry them out of their hands now.
#19
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Mar 2016
Location: Washington, Ontario, Michigan
Posts: 892
Received 281 Likes
on
141 Posts
^exactly.
My fear isn't the EV, my fear is being legislated off the road. I think when (not if) driver-less cars become the norm it will start out like cigarettes. "oh you drive your own car, how socially irresponsible of you" and that will eventually lead to groups that will successfully lobby to not allow flesh driven vehicles on the road. Insurers would love nothing more than folks paying small premiums and rarely paying out damages. Not to mention reduced traffic, less accidents, and all the benefits that come from it. Government bodies would love that kind of stuff. I really think that's the direction transportation is going. And yes I know you can still legally smoke but you see what I am getting at. You can't ride your horse/carriage on the streets and that's for good reason. I am sure for the experience horse rider it's perfectly safe to ride most anywhere; but the benefits/practicality of the motorcar and how it fits into society far outweigh the horse. I think driving cars will one day be something you will have to do at a club on private grounds like the equestrian today.
/rant sorry I took things off subject. EVs are coming. Lets embrace it and try and help them be cool rather than stick our noses up in the air.
My fear isn't the EV, my fear is being legislated off the road. I think when (not if) driver-less cars become the norm it will start out like cigarettes. "oh you drive your own car, how socially irresponsible of you" and that will eventually lead to groups that will successfully lobby to not allow flesh driven vehicles on the road. Insurers would love nothing more than folks paying small premiums and rarely paying out damages. Not to mention reduced traffic, less accidents, and all the benefits that come from it. Government bodies would love that kind of stuff. I really think that's the direction transportation is going. And yes I know you can still legally smoke but you see what I am getting at. You can't ride your horse/carriage on the streets and that's for good reason. I am sure for the experience horse rider it's perfectly safe to ride most anywhere; but the benefits/practicality of the motorcar and how it fits into society far outweigh the horse. I think driving cars will one day be something you will have to do at a club on private grounds like the equestrian today.
/rant sorry I took things off subject. EVs are coming. Lets embrace it and try and help them be cool rather than stick our noses up in the air.
#20
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
My fear isn't the EV, my fear is being legislated off the road...
I really think that's the direction transportation is going. And yes I know you can still legally smoke but you see what I am getting at. You can't ride your horse/carriage on the streets and that's for good reason. I am sure for the experience horse rider it's perfectly safe to ride most anywhere; but the benefits/practicality of the motorcar and how it fits into society far outweigh the horse. I think driving cars will one day be something you will have to do at a club on private grounds like the equestrian today.
I really think that's the direction transportation is going. And yes I know you can still legally smoke but you see what I am getting at. You can't ride your horse/carriage on the streets and that's for good reason. I am sure for the experience horse rider it's perfectly safe to ride most anywhere; but the benefits/practicality of the motorcar and how it fits into society far outweigh the horse. I think driving cars will one day be something you will have to do at a club on private grounds like the equestrian today.
#21
Burning Brakes
Sorry, I don't think this is the right forum for that. But I can say I have seen numbers like 19970 rpm and 918 hp on the dyno... Unfortunately I ended my employment before we cracked 20000 rpm and shortly after the 2.4l V8:s were introduced.with a lot more restrictions on geometries and also later on revlimits of first 19000 and then 18000. Pffft...
Sorry for OT.
Sorry for OT.
#22
Rennlist Member
Porsche should make a 2-door 2+2 electric sports car at some point in the future, the EV equivalent of a 911; but I think they should retire the 911 name when the last petrol powered car roles of the production line.
Of course with VW's money men running the company who knows what they'll do, but that's what I think they should do.
Of course with VW's money men running the company who knows what they'll do, but that's what I think they should do.
#23
You are crazy if you think EVs are somehow green. The power to charge them has to be generated... more fossil fuels burnt to do it. "Renewable" energy is a scam and not viable.
#24
Porsche should make a 2-door 2+2 electric sports car at some point in the future, the EV equivalent of a 911; but I think they should retire the 911 name when the last petrol powered car roles of the production line.
Of course with VW's money men running the company who knows what they'll do, but that's what I think they should do.
Of course with VW's money men running the company who knows what they'll do, but that's what I think they should do.
Then again, I'm already eyeing older 911s rather than looking at 992 etc...
Uh.... Solar? My electric bill is $17/mo And in the PNW, hydro?
#25
Rennlist Member
I think it's great that Walter is outspoken on his preferences...and love that the Carrera GT is still in his mental mix. Still in mine, too. Along with small-bore flat sixes and 3.9/4.0-liter GT3 engines, etc.
While I can't see my garage without a sporting ICE car in it, I am open to seeing how EVs develop. The 918 in pure electric mode surprised me...quite fun on a mountain road with a 987 Boxster Spyder on my tail—and the pace wasn't slow. Heard other noises hidden by ICE, tires, wheel bearings, suspension bits, etc. As exciting aurally as a flat six or V10 or even an I4? No. Nowhere close—but the torque vs. grip was definitely fun and there was a bizarre purity to the experience that I really liked. It's hard to remember an ICE car of any kind that felt like such a pure handling experience. The motive power felt more akin to sailing than motoring, like a great force harnessed and applied as I saw fit. Kinda neat.
But the comments about EV being green, etc. are also spot on. Then again...if we get to a spot where it's not crazy to run solar roof tiles that don't wreck the look of your home to an electricity storage device that can power your home as well as a good-looking, great-handling EV daily driver with good range that's parked next to your fun car(s), well, that doesn't sound so bad to me. I always hate using my ICE cars on short trips, where the oil doesn't get up to temp, and a TDI taught me to hate weekly (or more regular…) stops at the gas station.
While I can't see my garage without a sporting ICE car in it, I am open to seeing how EVs develop. The 918 in pure electric mode surprised me...quite fun on a mountain road with a 987 Boxster Spyder on my tail—and the pace wasn't slow. Heard other noises hidden by ICE, tires, wheel bearings, suspension bits, etc. As exciting aurally as a flat six or V10 or even an I4? No. Nowhere close—but the torque vs. grip was definitely fun and there was a bizarre purity to the experience that I really liked. It's hard to remember an ICE car of any kind that felt like such a pure handling experience. The motive power felt more akin to sailing than motoring, like a great force harnessed and applied as I saw fit. Kinda neat.
But the comments about EV being green, etc. are also spot on. Then again...if we get to a spot where it's not crazy to run solar roof tiles that don't wreck the look of your home to an electricity storage device that can power your home as well as a good-looking, great-handling EV daily driver with good range that's parked next to your fun car(s), well, that doesn't sound so bad to me. I always hate using my ICE cars on short trips, where the oil doesn't get up to temp, and a TDI taught me to hate weekly (or more regular…) stops at the gas station.
#26
Drifting
I think it's great that Walter is outspoken on his preferences...and love that the Carrera GT is still in his mental mix. Still in mine, too. Along with small-bore flat sixes and 3.9/4.0-liter GT3 engines, etc.
While I can't see my garage without a sporting ICE car in it, I am open to seeing how EVs develop. The 918 in pure electric mode surprised me...quite fun on a mountain road with a 987 Boxster Spyder on my tail—and the pace wasn't slow. Heard other noises hidden by ICE, tires, wheel bearings, suspension bits, etc. As exciting aurally as a flat six or V10 or even an I4? No. Nowhere close—but the torque vs. grip was definitely fun and there was a bizarre purity to the experience that I really liked. It's hard to remember an ICE car of any kind that felt like such a pure handling experience. The motive power felt more akin to sailing than motoring, like a great force harnessed and applied as I saw fit. Kinda neat.
But the comments about EV being green, etc. are also spot on. Then again...if we get to a spot where it's not crazy to run solar roof tiles that don't wreck the look of your home to an electricity storage device that can power your home as well as a good-looking, great-handling EV daily driver with good range that's parked next to your fun car(s), well, that doesn't sound so bad to me. I always hate using my ICE cars on short trips, where the oil doesn't get up to temp, and a TDI taught me to hate weekly (or more regular…) stops at the gas station.
While I can't see my garage without a sporting ICE car in it, I am open to seeing how EVs develop. The 918 in pure electric mode surprised me...quite fun on a mountain road with a 987 Boxster Spyder on my tail—and the pace wasn't slow. Heard other noises hidden by ICE, tires, wheel bearings, suspension bits, etc. As exciting aurally as a flat six or V10 or even an I4? No. Nowhere close—but the torque vs. grip was definitely fun and there was a bizarre purity to the experience that I really liked. It's hard to remember an ICE car of any kind that felt like such a pure handling experience. The motive power felt more akin to sailing than motoring, like a great force harnessed and applied as I saw fit. Kinda neat.
But the comments about EV being green, etc. are also spot on. Then again...if we get to a spot where it's not crazy to run solar roof tiles that don't wreck the look of your home to an electricity storage device that can power your home as well as a good-looking, great-handling EV daily driver with good range that's parked next to your fun car(s), well, that doesn't sound so bad to me. I always hate using my ICE cars on short trips, where the oil doesn't get up to temp, and a TDI taught me to hate weekly (or more regular…) stops at the gas station.
#27
how much did the panels cost you? and show me a solar panel producing factory that is sustained by purely solar panels.
#28
Skip to 4:34 for those not interested in watches:
#29
I think it's great that Walter is outspoken on his preferences...and love that the Carrera GT is still in his mental mix. Still in mine, too. Along with small-bore flat sixes and 3.9/4.0-liter GT3 engines, etc.
While I can't see my garage without a sporting ICE car in it, I am open to seeing how EVs develop. The 918 in pure electric mode surprised me...quite fun on a mountain road with a 987 Boxster Spyder on my tail—and the pace wasn't slow. Heard other noises hidden by ICE, tires, wheel bearings, suspension bits, etc. As exciting aurally as a flat six or V10 or even an I4? No. Nowhere close—but the torque vs. grip was definitely fun and there was a bizarre purity to the experience that I really liked. It's hard to remember an ICE car of any kind that felt like such a pure handling experience. The motive power felt more akin to sailing than motoring, like a great force harnessed and applied as I saw fit. Kinda neat.
But the comments about EV being green, etc. are also spot on. Then again...if we get to a spot where it's not crazy to run solar roof tiles that don't wreck the look of your home to an electricity storage device that can power your home as well as a good-looking, great-handling EV daily driver with good range that's parked next to your fun car(s), well, that doesn't sound so bad to me. I always hate using my ICE cars on short trips, where the oil doesn't get up to temp, and a TDI taught me to hate weekly (or more regular…) stops at the gas station.
While I can't see my garage without a sporting ICE car in it, I am open to seeing how EVs develop. The 918 in pure electric mode surprised me...quite fun on a mountain road with a 987 Boxster Spyder on my tail—and the pace wasn't slow. Heard other noises hidden by ICE, tires, wheel bearings, suspension bits, etc. As exciting aurally as a flat six or V10 or even an I4? No. Nowhere close—but the torque vs. grip was definitely fun and there was a bizarre purity to the experience that I really liked. It's hard to remember an ICE car of any kind that felt like such a pure handling experience. The motive power felt more akin to sailing than motoring, like a great force harnessed and applied as I saw fit. Kinda neat.
But the comments about EV being green, etc. are also spot on. Then again...if we get to a spot where it's not crazy to run solar roof tiles that don't wreck the look of your home to an electricity storage device that can power your home as well as a good-looking, great-handling EV daily driver with good range that's parked next to your fun car(s), well, that doesn't sound so bad to me. I always hate using my ICE cars on short trips, where the oil doesn't get up to temp, and a TDI taught me to hate weekly (or more regular…) stops at the gas station.
As Richard said, my fear is not EVs now, but exactly what he said. Being legislated off the roads for autonomous driving etc.... That would take away a big pleasure I derive out of life (I am not alone here I am sure)
I'm also queued up for Tesla solar roof tiles, I hope their tiles will be better than their cars..
#30
No electric for me also. My children are all aware that I prefer ICE.
My office mate was asking me why don't I like Tesla. He ordered one with Government EV credit. He said that my children will like it. I countered his question with this, "If I ask my children which car to choose when I am done driving, Porsche or Tesla, which one will they pick". He did admit that it will be the Porsche. Case close.
My office mate was asking me why don't I like Tesla. He ordered one with Government EV credit. He said that my children will like it. I countered his question with this, "If I ask my children which car to choose when I am done driving, Porsche or Tesla, which one will they pick". He did admit that it will be the Porsche. Case close.