How reliable do you think PDK trannies will be?
#16
Rennlist Member
Its true we dont know the long term reliability of PDK-S on the track. PCCBs were new back in 2002 but auto trannies have been in Porsches for two or more decades so the underlying core principles are when known and documented....
#17
Burning Brakes
I'm comforted by the fact that the PDK was designed originally for the 962 Race cars in the early 1980s as a racing transmission built for Endurance Racing 850 HP Turbocharged Torque monsters . So they have over 3 decades of experience in the development of dual clutch transmissions - far more than any other sports car competitor. PDK may be new for us...... but definitely not for the most senior Porsche Engineers.
#18
I think the PDK itself is not a problem. Mechanically, it is probably perfect.
The electrics / sensors / control units I think are the weak point. Especially in hot environments...
The electrics / sensors / control units I think are the weak point. Especially in hot environments...
#19
Race Director
I'm comforted by the fact that the PDK was designed originally for the 962 Race cars in the early 1980s as a racing transmission built for Endurance Racing 850 HP Turbocharged Torque monsters . So they have over 3 decades of experience in the development of dual clutch transmissions - far more than any other sports car competitor. PDK may be new for us...... but definitely not for the most senior Porsche Engineers.
#20
Nordschleife Master
#21
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Wishing I Was At The Track
Posts: 13,519
Received 1,729 Likes
on
916 Posts
I'm comforted by the fact that the PDK was designed originally for the 962 Race cars in the early 1980s as a racing transmission built for Endurance Racing 850 HP Turbocharged Torque monsters . So they have over 3 decades of experience in the development of dual clutch transmissions - far more than any other sports car competitor. PDK may be new for us...... but definitely not for the most senior Porsche Engineers.
As for durability in latest GT3 application we're unlikely to know much for at least 12-18 months. That's about how long it took on average for issues like RMS, coolant fittings, intake manifolds, center-locks, clutch failures to filter back.
#22
Race Director
PDK has been available in the Carrera models since 2009 and in the TTS and Panamera Turbo, which have a lot more HP and torque than the 991 GT3, since 2010. There have been more than 12-18 months of history already with this gearbox, and I don't expect that PDK-(S) will be any less durable in the GT3 than it has been in those other cars.
Last edited by Mike in CA; 11-16-2013 at 02:54 AM.
#23
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Wishing I Was At The Track
Posts: 13,519
Received 1,729 Likes
on
916 Posts
PDK has been available in the Carrera models since 2009 and in the TTS and Panamera Turbo, which have a lot more HP and torque than the 991 GT3, since 2010. There have been more than 12-18 months of history already with this gearbox, and I don't expect that PDK-(S) will be any less durable in the GT3 than it has been in those other cars.
#25
Rennlist Member
#26
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: West Vancouver and San Francisco
Posts: 4,186
Received 1,150 Likes
on
568 Posts
With such complex systems, changing something even a little bit can cause stuff to blow up in unexpected ways, so I understand where you are coming from. But the wet clutches in general are not big of a deal. I remember the paranoia on BMW forums when DCT first came out - people were afraid to track DCT cars or use launch control, and replacement costs of $15K+ were thrown around. Now there are cars with over 50K miles and close to 100-200 hard track days on original clutches, some supercharged to over 600HP. I'd be surprised for Porsche to be any worse. And clutch pack replacement can be done for $3500-3800 all-in at a dealer or for noticeably less at a friendly tuner shop - I don't know about Porsche (googling revealed just a bunch of hearsay), but would hope it's not much more expensive.
#27
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2006
Location: sydney
Posts: 6,222
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#28
I'm comforted by the fact that the PDK was designed originally for the 962 Race cars in the early 1980s as a racing transmission built for Endurance Racing 850 HP Turbocharged Torque monsters . So they have over 3 decades of experience in the development of dual clutch transmissions - far more than any other sports car competitor. PDK may be new for us...... but definitely not for the most senior Porsche Engineers.
The other one is a road car, completely different world..and knowing Porsche a bit these days (where there are clearly fixed budgets)...we will see.
In fact, I would encourage all 991 GT3 owners.."please track your car as heavily as possible"..so that we can discuss the long term results here on RL. Lets se how things will have evolved in 5 years.
I remember the days when CLs were celebrated as the "innovation" etc...and now owners will have to cover the not sufficient R&D - testing of the time.
PS: I know that 458s dont like long term tracking (more than 1 hour) on their gearboxes..a quick lap yes....but more..rather no..
PS2: remember that PdK boxes cannot and will not be repaired by independet - or even Porsche dealers, they will be changed completely and are sent back to the factory.
#29
PDK was born in racing
PDK is not new guys. It was born in the 80s in motor racing! I have no idea how anyone is questioning the reliability of PDK under high performance stress conditions - all high performance cars by Porsche the GT3, GT3 RS, 911 Turbo S and really? The 918 Spyder, they all have the same technology behind them as any other "lower end" models. So before you question Porsche's reliability and about a technology standing the test of time, remember Porsche has always blazed the trail for sports cars. Heck they invented the concept itself or at the very least largely revolutionized it. Trust Porsche - because Porsche leads fearlessly with daring innovations and everyone follows suit but if you research closely the innovation is never an experiment - Porsche doesn't do experiments. Porsche wins. Bye.
Last edited by Rashid Amin; 05-23-2017 at 01:58 AM. Reason: Spelling
#30
This season (on track) I have seen 4 P cars with problems (1) 1 x engine - money shift (2) 2 x diffs (3) 1 x 3rd gear - all were manuals. I have seen one PDK with a problem - it was fixed by replacing a sensor (actually I think it was by cleaning a sensor).
Last edited by randr; 05-23-2017 at 06:59 AM.