986s or 987 2.7 ?
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
986s or 987 2.7 ?
Im looking at a used boxster in the £35k range. I could get a very basic 987 or a well specced low miles "S". Any opinions welcome .Is the new range so much better ?
#4
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Interesting so far the 987 is winning.Not sure i could get PASM at this price,its desirable but i dont like the stopwatch on the dash anyway.I could wait but no signs of values slipping soon.
Any reasons why a 986S wouldnt be a better package?
Any reasons why a 986S wouldnt be a better package?
#5
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
There were many improvements made in the 987 and in my opinion it's a better platform. But if you can get a 986S with warranty and at a decent price then there is certainly nothing wrong with doing that.
#6
Rennlist Member
Just FYI, the stopwatch does not come with PASM option. It comes with the Sport Chrono option.
I would try to drive them back to back and see if you notice any difference. They increased the power in the 2.7 in the 987 to 240 hp so it's pretty close to that of the 986S although i don't think that it has quite the torque.
You may find that the improvements that they made on the 987 (especially on the interior) make it more desireable than the 986S, but that's just my personal opinion.
Either way you're looking at a super fun car, so have fun shopping.
I would try to drive them back to back and see if you notice any difference. They increased the power in the 2.7 in the 987 to 240 hp so it's pretty close to that of the 986S although i don't think that it has quite the torque.
You may find that the improvements that they made on the 987 (especially on the interior) make it more desireable than the 986S, but that's just my personal opinion.
Either way you're looking at a super fun car, so have fun shopping.
#7
Originally Posted by ELUSIVE
You may find that the improvements that they made on the 987 (especially on the interior) make it more desireable than the 986S, but that's just my personal opinion.
Regardless, it is a matter of personal preference on design. Sure we can track these cars and given the same driver a 987 out performs its 986 peer, but Boxsters are beautiful little gems that are meant to be seen, felt, and heard (ahh, shift, burble-burble-burble)
Trending Topics
#8
Back in March we traded our two 2002 Boxsters (S and base) in on two 2005 Boxters (S and base).
Wow what a difference! Build quality is an order of magnitude better and the body structure is tight with no rattles. I even think the base is more fun to drive than the S with it's Ferrari-like intake noise.
In fact, I think the new Boxster is better than the 997 we purchased in July. It has less power but that's it. The new Boxster has now been perfected.
Wow what a difference! Build quality is an order of magnitude better and the body structure is tight with no rattles. I even think the base is more fun to drive than the S with it's Ferrari-like intake noise.
In fact, I think the new Boxster is better than the 997 we purchased in July. It has less power but that's it. The new Boxster has now been perfected.
#11
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by rkeyser
Back in March we traded our two 2002 Boxsters (S and base) in on two 2005 Boxters (S and base).
Wow what a difference! Build quality is an order of magnitude better and the body structure is tight with no rattles. I even think the base is more fun to drive than the S with it's Ferrari-like intake noise.
In fact, I think the new Boxster is better than the 997 we purchased in July. It has less power but that's it. The new Boxster has now been perfected.
Wow what a difference! Build quality is an order of magnitude better and the body structure is tight with no rattles. I even think the base is more fun to drive than the S with it's Ferrari-like intake noise.
In fact, I think the new Boxster is better than the 997 we purchased in July. It has less power but that's it. The new Boxster has now been perfected.
#12
Nordschleife Master
Originally Posted by john ashcroft
.Sadly i hear no word of engine redesign....so i guess RMS etc will continue...
One more reason to go with the 987 over the 986.
#13
I had the same dilemma '03 986 S vs. '05 987 and drove both (twice). I just love the pull of the S (even moreso the 987 S, but that's beyond budget). The 987 just felt more solid to me. Better chassis feel and actually fit my body better. I like the newer design and it didn't feel *too* slow (but I'm sure I'll miss my E36 M3 when it's sold).
I ended up taking the plunge on a end-of-year '05 at $500 over invoice. No comments so far on the lack of power since I haven't taken delivery yet. But take several test drives and you'll figure it out one way or the other.
I ended up taking the plunge on a end-of-year '05 at $500 over invoice. No comments so far on the lack of power since I haven't taken delivery yet. But take several test drives and you'll figure it out one way or the other.
#14
Intermediate
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Pleasanton, CA
Posts: 44
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I drove both back in July, and I would go for the 987. The interior is much nicer (IMHO), the power is comparable, but more important to me was that I thought the 987 sounded better. Handling-wise, I think there was something wrong with the S that I drove (wobbly steering wheel > 60 mph - could've just been tire pressue), so I didn't get a good feel. I can't say enough good things about the 987, though.
If I could deal with a 2-seater then there would be a 987 (base, with very few options) in my garage.
Forgot to add - not to make anyone feel like they paid too much, but back in July I was offered $5k off sticker for any 987 I chose/configured/etc without even trying to negotiate. Not sure if the same deals are available these days or not, though.
If I could deal with a 2-seater then there would be a 987 (base, with very few options) in my garage.
Forgot to add - not to make anyone feel like they paid too much, but back in July I was offered $5k off sticker for any 987 I chose/configured/etc without even trying to negotiate. Not sure if the same deals are available these days or not, though.
#15
Burning Brakes
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Southern Calif
Posts: 838
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
For my wife's car it was simply a matter of which to buy, the base model or the S. She drove both and chose the S. Guards, tip, and chromed lobster forks.. She loves it, its a trip to drive and I really like the stock exhaust notes. Much better sounding than my 997 without PSE.