Anatomy of a fuel pump failure
#16
Pro
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 700
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have had three go in my two '89s. Once in the middle of nowhere farm country where the nearest property was about 1 1/2 miles away. The other was at Watkins Glen and I had to be towed back home to Ontario (3 1/2 hr). I have been thinking to keep a spare with me as well.
#17
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
The commutator was not machined that way, both the brushes and commutator were badly worn. There was no mechanical binding that I could find, the rotor and pump turned freely and the pump ran quietly. These things run immersed in fuel, and we almost always fill with Chevron or Shell 92-octane.
It is particularly annoying since these things are sealed cans-- there is no way that I know of to open them for periodic inspection and then put them back in service. Other than taking it down to the clinic and trying to talk them into an x-ray, I don't know of any way to identify this sort of wear before it fails. And at $200-250 a pop it's kind of painful to just add a fuel pump to the every-60K-mile list. (But that's probably what the clinic would charge for an x-ray, if they could be talked into it).
Cheers, Jim
#18
Rennlist Member
Wonder if the resistance of the windings on the armature/rotor of this particular pump was causing a higher than normal current draw but not enough to have a fuse blow could have been the cause of the premature wear of the commutator and brushes. Only thing that may make sense as others have had original pumps for 100,000's miles.
#19
Drifting
I'd bet they got a batch of spring from a different supplier that were stiffer than spec. Thus the extra wear from the brushes. Quality control has improved leaps and bounds in the last 30 years.
That said, nice work on the actual pictures.
That said, nice work on the actual pictures.
#20
Pro
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 700
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The mechanic I use, who was from the factory and trained in Stuttgart in 70's and 80's asked if i used the octane boost in my fuel. I did when I would go on the track. He mentioned that many of the pump failures he had seen, seemed to have a correlation with added octane boost in the fuel and the pump failure. Not sure exactly how that could lead to failures in the pump itself, but I do have to say that it occurred with me three times over the years. Could the extra octane/acetone or whatever they use contribute to this? Just something else to ponder.
#22
Rennlist Member
My guess would be some resistance somewhere lifting the current - check the new pump's draw, and see if its higher than normal. My 83 CIS pump pulls 7-8A - now. I have chewed through 2 pump relays in my 10 years with the car. Last time it failed I had to jumper the relay to get home, and while I was checking things I saw a spark out of the corner of my eye - the the pump fuse (early bullet style)! Poor contact. Now I have made some adapters so I can fit blade style fuses for the high current show stoppers. The pump fuse on mine is a 16A (IIRC?), so there is some room for the current to rise before blowing the fuse.
jp 83 Euro S AT 55k
jp 83 Euro S AT 55k
#23
Three Wheelin'
What can you tell about the commutator construction, is it machined copper or press formed from some kind of mix?
This really deserves some effort to find the cause.
Gasoline formulations have changed alot and have caused mysterious degradation of lines in the aviation industry that nobody could understand.
If the commutator is solid copper though, that rules chemical attack out.
Could the polarity have been reversed?
In electrical discharge machining, changing polarity can have a huge effect on the wear of the electrode or workpiece.
This really deserves some effort to find the cause.
Gasoline formulations have changed alot and have caused mysterious degradation of lines in the aviation industry that nobody could understand.
If the commutator is solid copper though, that rules chemical attack out.
Could the polarity have been reversed?
In electrical discharge machining, changing polarity can have a huge effect on the wear of the electrode or workpiece.
#25
Shameful Thread Killer
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
After hearing about the octane booster additives, I'm leaning toward a chemical issue. The additives are supposed to be high in Oxegenates. Wondering if there is some aggressive chem reaction between the O2 in the booster and the pure or nearly pure copper of the commutator. If the car sits with the commutator in a bath rich in O2, I think it might make a lot of surface Cu2O, or CuO? Chemists?
Just an idea, but I don't have much to back it up.
Just an idea, but I don't have much to back it up.
#26
Rennlist Member
IIRC the pump is straight after the tank, the filter after the pump. So fuel contaminated with fine (abrasive) particles could get into the pump and cause the heavy wear you have found ?
It would be interesting to see what's inside the filter...
It would be interesting to see what's inside the filter...
#27
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Site Sponsor
Octane boost?
If you are talking about the standard parts store octane boost, you are just wasting money. They do a fair job of doing exactly what they say that they do...
The problem is that adding $5 to $10 worth of octane boost to increase the octane of the fuel four or five points is pretty silly. They are counting on you thinking that a "point" is one octane number - it isn't. An "octane point" is actually 0.1 octane number, so your fuel goes from 89 to 89.5 octane, or 91 to 91.5. Whoopee.
If you are talking about the standard parts store octane boost, you are just wasting money. They do a fair job of doing exactly what they say that they do...
The problem is that adding $5 to $10 worth of octane boost to increase the octane of the fuel four or five points is pretty silly. They are counting on you thinking that a "point" is one octane number - it isn't. An "octane point" is actually 0.1 octane number, so your fuel goes from 89 to 89.5 octane, or 91 to 91.5. Whoopee.
#28
Rennlist Member
"And at $200-250 a pop it's kind of painful to just add a fuel pump to the every-60K-mile"
Jim
I am using this.
http://www.ebay.ca/itm/390476309080?...84.m1423.l2649
The volume is 228L/Hour
At this price I can keep a spare. If anyone is concerned about volume this puts out 228L/hour or 60 gal/hour.More than any 928 requires we hope.
From the WSM
1979 1360 CC/30 SEC
FOR K-JETRONIC
(1981/1982 Models)
Engine M 28.09 and M 28.10 1120 CC/ 30 SEC
(1980/1981/1982/1983 Models) L JETRONIC
at least 1150 cc/30 sec.
Beginning with 1984 Models
Engine Type M 28.21/22 1350 CC/30 SEC
85 on 1350 CC/30 SEC. M28 43 44 45 46
As from Model 87
Englne type M 28. 41/42/47/49/50
87 on 1250 CC/30 SEC
At 6300 rpm the fuel pump is turned off at the relay
228 L/ hour or 1900cc/ 30 sec so we are well covered. If you need more pressure put a restrictor in the return line to the tank but more than likely the pressure regulators will take care of that.
Jim
I am using this.
http://www.ebay.ca/itm/390476309080?...84.m1423.l2649
The volume is 228L/Hour
At this price I can keep a spare. If anyone is concerned about volume this puts out 228L/hour or 60 gal/hour.More than any 928 requires we hope.
From the WSM
1979 1360 CC/30 SEC
FOR K-JETRONIC
(1981/1982 Models)
Engine M 28.09 and M 28.10 1120 CC/ 30 SEC
(1980/1981/1982/1983 Models) L JETRONIC
at least 1150 cc/30 sec.
Beginning with 1984 Models
Engine Type M 28.21/22 1350 CC/30 SEC
85 on 1350 CC/30 SEC. M28 43 44 45 46
As from Model 87
Englne type M 28. 41/42/47/49/50
87 on 1250 CC/30 SEC
At 6300 rpm the fuel pump is turned off at the relay
228 L/ hour or 1900cc/ 30 sec so we are well covered. If you need more pressure put a restrictor in the return line to the tank but more than likely the pressure regulators will take care of that.
#29
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
The commutator should be solid copper, but is badly discolored as well as worn. That would suggest surface oxidation of some sort, e.g. chemical contamination. Which could be related to rapid wear (i.e. heat and arcing where the brushes meet the commutator). I'm no expert but folks who are, worry about clean commutators.
No additives except occasional techron, years ago. No octane booster, ever (no need...). The tank was clean when I had the sender out last year (intermittent fuel gauge). I'll check it again as soon as I get the GT put back together... And filter pic's coming...
No additives except occasional techron, years ago. No octane booster, ever (no need...). The tank was clean when I had the sender out last year (intermittent fuel gauge). I'll check it again as soon as I get the GT put back together... And filter pic's coming...
#30
Jim,
Here's some info from the web....
[URL="http://www.gulfelectroquip.com/technical.php?technicalname=commutator"]Here's another site with more info, including photos of types of brush wear and causes.URL]
Here's some info from the web....
Threading. Threading involves the transfer of excessive amounts of metal to the brushes during commutation when brush path(s) start to resemble the threads on a bolt (Fig. 3). As with streaking, threading may be due to inadequate brush spring tension or too light a load. Left unchecked, the condition will lead to rapid brush wear. If you detect threading soon enough, you can machine the commutator in place to restore the finish.
[URL="http://www.gulfelectroquip.com/technical.php?technicalname=commutator"]Here's another site with more info, including photos of types of brush wear and causes.URL]