How can this be? No compression in all 8 cyls ?
#136
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Gone. On the Open Road
Posts: 16,508
Received 1,648 Likes
on
1,075 Posts
#137
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Thread Starter
The Answer !!
I pulled the t-belt so I could rotate the cam by hand. Then I pulled an intake runner so I could see the back side of the intake valve. As soon as I had the runner off the problem was obvious. The intake port was contaminated with glass bead. My fault.. I didn't do a very good job cleaning out the plenum and runners after they were glass beaded. I washed them but there must have been a pocket of bead material somewhere in the plenum.
So..I can actually see the beads holding the valve open. Introduce air into the bore and add carb cleaner behind the valve, it blows bubbles. I was able to wash that valve with carb cleaner and get it to seal. Unfortunatly I cant' reach the exhaust valves but my leakdown tester tells me they are leaking. I need to wash this material out of there. I have been told that water won't do any harm.
I am thinking of making a hose fitting for the sparkplug hole and a bolt on flange/fitting for the intake port. I'll unbolt my exhaust from the headers and then just flood the cylinder while opening and closing the valves to wash everything out. I may add some compressed air to the water line to agitate and scrub better.
What do you think? Am I nuts? Just tear the motor down do it the "right" way?
I pulled the t-belt so I could rotate the cam by hand. Then I pulled an intake runner so I could see the back side of the intake valve. As soon as I had the runner off the problem was obvious. The intake port was contaminated with glass bead. My fault.. I didn't do a very good job cleaning out the plenum and runners after they were glass beaded. I washed them but there must have been a pocket of bead material somewhere in the plenum.
So..I can actually see the beads holding the valve open. Introduce air into the bore and add carb cleaner behind the valve, it blows bubbles. I was able to wash that valve with carb cleaner and get it to seal. Unfortunatly I cant' reach the exhaust valves but my leakdown tester tells me they are leaking. I need to wash this material out of there. I have been told that water won't do any harm.
I am thinking of making a hose fitting for the sparkplug hole and a bolt on flange/fitting for the intake port. I'll unbolt my exhaust from the headers and then just flood the cylinder while opening and closing the valves to wash everything out. I may add some compressed air to the water line to agitate and scrub better.
What do you think? Am I nuts? Just tear the motor down do it the "right" way?
#138
Dave,
The exhaust valves are prone to burn in this situation so my suggestion is to pull the heads and have them checked by a good machine shop.
I was hoping it would be something simple (and cheap).
Dennis
The exhaust valves are prone to burn in this situation so my suggestion is to pull the heads and have them checked by a good machine shop.
I was hoping it would be something simple (and cheap).
Dennis
#139
Administrator - "Tyson"
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
again, it would have to be near 14.7:1 and not real lean. real lean would actually be good, as that would cool everything down, including Power output
the range can be hit and this is how engines get melted, but there are many S4s that run near 14:1 WOT on the dyno and dont grenade (surprisingly enough)
the range can be hit and this is how engines get melted, but there are many S4s that run near 14:1 WOT on the dyno and dont grenade (surprisingly enough)
Lean air/fuel is not the only way to detonate a motor. Too much timing + boost (toss in high compression from all the carbon) can (and usually does) cause detonation. Just the timing + boost alone is how many boosted motors are destroyed.
I've seen motors running 10:1 detonate on the dyno, it's NOT the only factor.
To say being "real lean" on a boosted motor would cool the charge........please stop giving advice like this. I'm not saying the "theory" is false, it's not good advice.
Based on Tass's last post it looks like detonation was not the issue, just needed to clarify a few things.
/it's early, I'm the only one on my team working today so yea, I'm crabby. Please tell me someone else will be tuning your new motor.
#140
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Thread Starter
In light of my very short run time ( 5 minutes or so) do you think I may have been spared the burnt valves ? I am thinking of tryng the wash-out technigue on one cyl to see if I can get it to pass a leakdown test. What do you think of the idea of washing with water?
#141
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Lillington, NC
Posts: 2,742
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Would some of those beads get down around the piston rings and damage the cylinder walls?
I would say pull the heads and really clean everything good. That's the only way to be sure.
It will cost you more time, but less money if the beads start to do damage after the engine is running again.
I would say pull the heads and really clean everything good. That's the only way to be sure.
It will cost you more time, but less money if the beads start to do damage after the engine is running again.
#142
Because of the pressure of the valves on the seats, it's likely you crushed the glass beads into the seats. You will not be able to get the seats and valve clean by trying to wash them with water. Then it's very likely you have glass bead material in the rings now. In my opinion you need to do a tear down. Glass beads in your piston rings sliding up and down are a death sentence. The cylinder temps won't be high enough to melt the beads.
I built a franken engine for my BMW 2002 which involved notching the pistons for clearance, I made a cutter out of a valve and used an old cylinder head as a guide. I cut the pistons in the engine. I thought I got all the aluminum shavings out. As soon as I started the engine a small aluminum chip was blown into the exhaust valve and was pinched in the seat. I pull the head and was able to lap the valve to clean the aluminum off the seat. I doubt you'll get by with a water wash.
I built a franken engine for my BMW 2002 which involved notching the pistons for clearance, I made a cutter out of a valve and used an old cylinder head as a guide. I cut the pistons in the engine. I thought I got all the aluminum shavings out. As soon as I started the engine a small aluminum chip was blown into the exhaust valve and was pinched in the seat. I pull the head and was able to lap the valve to clean the aluminum off the seat. I doubt you'll get by with a water wash.
#143
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2001
Location: Wilbraham, MA
Posts: 2,758
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have an engine hoist and would find time to give you a hand... Probably bring in plenty of local help as well. Many would appreciate the opportunity to help you, as you have been quite the local event host
#145
Administrator - "Tyson"
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Because of the pressure of the valves on the seats, it's likely you crushed the glass beads into the seats. You will not be able to get the seats and valve clean by trying to wash them with water. Then it's very likely you have glass bead material in the rings now. In my opinion you need to do a tear down. Glass beads in your piston rings sliding up and down are a death sentence. The cylinder temps won't be high enough to melt the beads.
Is this a stock 79 engine? If so that is the good news since it's not like you wrecked a set of EuroS heads.
I guess this is why a few engine builders I know will never bead (or sand) blast heads.
Hopefully the cylinders are ok, I fear as 918 pointed out, glass bead material scraping up and down the cylinder wall is not a good thing.
Look at the bright side, since that motor had so much carbon buildup, in the long run you will come out way ahead with a clean combustion chamber.
Not to be confused with the famous "Andrew Olson peter pulling contest".
#146
Race Car
someone's been trying to seel Euro heads on here for a while....Fabio, maybe?
Probably hafta send em out for port and polish, there's a few months...Paeco?
j/k
Probably hafta send em out for port and polish, there's a few months...Paeco?
j/k
#147
Race Car
wow...high end ownership takes it's toll, but it's a '70- must be first prototype ever?
Just kidding. too bad BIN is still too high for eng trans and headlights, even if they were in good cond.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/Porsc...spagenameZWDVW
I especially like the bleeding fuel pump and ill fitting hatch.
Just kidding. too bad BIN is still too high for eng trans and headlights, even if they were in good cond.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/Porsc...spagenameZWDVW
I especially like the bleeding fuel pump and ill fitting hatch.
#148
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Thread Starter
I have a lot of effort into this car so I don't want to finish it off with a questionable engine ( glass bead contaminated= questionable). I am going to talk to Carl and see what options are compatible with my supercharger set up.
Maybe a complete rebuild or maybe just buy something else. If I have to do a complete rebuild I might as well keep the engine I have. It was running very well and has only 100K on it.
Thoughts?
Maybe a complete rebuild or maybe just buy something else. If I have to do a complete rebuild I might as well keep the engine I have. It was running very well and has only 100K on it.
Thoughts?
#149
Supercharged
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Back in Michigan - Full time!
Posts: 18,925
Likes: 0
Received 60 Likes
on
34 Posts
I think it's too early to say what you can do. You need to pull it apart and see if there is any permanent damage. If it's damaged, then assess your options.
#150
Administrator - "Tyson"
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
From 928 International, 4.5 liter rings:
78-79 = $616
80-82 = $1,080
I'm not sure what the difference are so I posted both.
When I discovered this (and I own two 4.5 cars) I bought up the frist two 4.7's that came across my path that were a good deal.
4.7 liter rings = $250
So if you can find a 4.7 liter shortblock for $300-$400 or less (they are out there) IMO you are better off going that route.
For a boosted track car a 5 liter motor is the way to go since the pistons are stronger & you can run 951 rings. That adds a bit to the budget though.