Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums

Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums (https://rennlist.com/forums/)
-   924/931/944/951/968 Forum (https://rennlist.com/forums/924-931-944-951-968-forum-70/)
-   -   Write-up: Budget 4-piston calipers for 944 NA (https://rennlist.com/forums/924-931-944-951-968-forum/962450-write-up-budget-4-piston-calipers-for-944-na.html)

odonnell 11-12-2016 11:14 PM

Write-up: Budget 4-piston calipers for 944 NA
 
My most recent project on the NA was to fit 4-piston front calipers. The stock brakes are sufficient, but an upgrade is an upgrade ;) This guide will detail the steps needed to fit them.

You probably are interested in how much of an upgrade these are, compared to stock. In short, they feel better but overall aren't a silver bullet. By that, I mean it's not night and day - stock brakes on an NA are ok, but at the end of the day, these ARE better and are actually pretty inexpensive. The pedal is firmer and they work harder during intense braking. I've driven an NA with 951 front brakes, and the feel is similar. I would choose these over 951 brakes for ease of installation and price.

The calipers are lifted from a 90-93 Volvo 240. I got mine from Rock Auto, reman, for about $120 total. There are 2 versions of the 240 brakes.... ABS, and non-ABS. You want the ABS variant, as it's almost a direct bolt on part.

The part numbers for the front left: 3530538, 35305382, 5003754, 50037548

and front right: 3530539, 35305390, 5003755, 50037555

Here are links to the ones I bought:

http://www.rockauto.com/en/moreinfo....696&cc=1287097

http://www.rockauto.com/en/moreinfo....695&cc=1287097


As far as brake pads, you can get whatever best fits your needs. I decided to splurge a little and get EBC Redstuff pads, part # DP3143C:
www.ebay.com/itm/301870229598

You may also want to invest in some SS braided brake lines, if you haven't already. I can't guarantee that the stock lines will work (length is the concern here) but I CAN confirm that SS braided lines from our usual vendors will work perfectly. Note: the non-ABS calipers have 2 input ports. The ABS calipers only have 1. Obviously that's a big reason why the ABS calipers are the ones to get, so you don't have to mess with splitters and all.

Here are the calipers, painted up:

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/rennlis...d27abf4730.jpg

I'm a sucker for red calipers, some people may say it's rice or whatever....

The next order of business is removing your old calipers. Start by putting the front of the car on jack stands, removing the wheels, and cracking loose the 2-ea bolts that mount them to the spindle. You may find it easier to access them when you move the steering rack to full right or left lock, depending on the side. Also remove the brake line from the caliper at this time.

Now, go ahead and mock up the calipers so you can get an idea of what will need to be trimmed. Note that some calipers may come with mounting hardware - I've heard that the Volvo spindles have a different thread pitch, so you'll want to re-use your Porsche caliper mounting bolts. No issues.

https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/rennlis...bb2df17987.jpg

In my case, the brake shields clashed slightly. In the photo below, you can see that the mounting ears overlapped with the shield, causing the shield to be pushed into the rotor in 2 places.

https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/rennlis...a81c6581ea.jpg

A quick buzz with the Dremel fixed that right up. You can also use snips or pliers to cut or bend them out of the way, it's pretty easy no matter what you do.

https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/rennlis...2bb023fcd1.jpg

Now that the calipers can cleanly bolt up, snug the bolts down relatively tight and give the hub/rotor assembly a spin.

You probably hear a very light grinding...as though there's just a thousandth or two of contact between the caliper and the rotor's outer edge. Grab your Dremel (or whatever) equipped with a sanding drum, and slightly clearance this inner face:

https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/rennlis...50513daa55.jpg

It's about 30 seconds of sanding, nothing dramatic. This is the last modification you will be doing to ensure fitment :cool:

Now, thread in your brake line. It's a direct fit.

https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/rennlis...43e05a94d3.jpg

Being mindful of the angle of the brake line (it's coming off the opposite edge of the caliper relative to the stock ones), mount up the calipers and snug it down for the last time. Torque spec is 63 ft-lbs. Spin the hub to double check you have no grinding, repeating the grinding process until it's clear. It shouldn't take much.

Other side installed:

https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/rennlis...691804e876.jpg

For installing the pads, you need the 2 slide pins, 2 R-clips (they're small), and the 2 spring clips for each caliper. The picture below shows me being a dumbass and putting the R-clips in FRONT of the pads which is wrong (see 3rd page of comments):

https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/rennlis...9739ae6f95.jpg

If you can't see, the spring clips are perpendicular to the pins. Their clip goes over the brake pad back plate. There are small holes in the pins, which you put the R-clips into. The 3rd or 4th page of this thread shows me being an idiot and a sharp reader finding my original mistake.

I also went ahead and replaced my brake fluid reservoir, to match my coolant tank :cool: Of course, you need to now bleed the brake system completely.

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/rennlis...8461600478.jpg


After bleeding, you're good to go! Follow the manufacturer's recommendation for pad break-in like always.

tims944 11-12-2016 11:43 PM

I Approve
 
Good job mike, that makes 1 dedicated follower, this will be a winter project already sourced the parts for a decent price and will enjoy some extra braking power in the spring !

Keep up the good work !

V2Rocket 11-13-2016 12:13 AM

Sweet!
did you happen to take measurements of piston diameters?

looking forward to impressions...confirm these fit under 15" wheels?

chanothemekhanik 11-13-2016 02:29 AM


Originally Posted by odonnell (Post 13742625)
My most recent project on the NA was to fit 4-piston front calipers. The stock brakes are sufficient, but an upgrade is an upgrade ;) This guide will detail the steps needed to fit them. The calipers are lifted from a 90-93 Volvo 240. I got mine from Rock Auto, reman, for about $120 total. There are 2 versions of the 240 brakes.... ABS, and non-ABS. You want the ABS variant, as it's almost a direct bolt on part. The part numbers for the front left: 3530538, 35305382, 5003754, 50037548 and front right: 3530539, 35305390, 5003755, 50037555 Here are links to the ones I bought: http://www.rockauto.com/en/moreinfo....696&cc=1287097 http://www.rockauto.com/en/moreinfo....695&cc=1287097 As far as brake pads, you can get whatever best fits your needs. I decided to splurge a little and get EBC Redstuff pads, part # DP3143C: www.ebay.com/itm/301870229598 You may also want to invest in some SS braided brake lines, if you haven't already. I can't guarantee that the stock lines will work (length is the concern here) but I CAN confirm that SS braided lines from our usual vendors will work perfectly. Note: the non-ABS calipers have 2 input ports. The ABS calipers only have 1. Obviously that's a big reason why the ABS calipers are the ones to get, so you don't have to mess with splitters and all. Here are the calipers, painted up: I'm a sucker for red calipers, some people may say it's rice or whatever.... The next order of business is removing your old calipers. Start by putting the front of the car on jack stands, removing the wheels, and cracking loose the 2-ea bolts that mount them to the spindle. You may find it easier to access them when you move the steering rack to full right or left lock, depending on the side. Also remove the brake line from the caliper at this time. Now, go ahead and mock up the calipers so you can get an idea of what will need to be trimmed. Note that some calipers may come with mounting hardware - I've heard that the Volvo spindles have a different thread pitch, so you'll want to re-use your Porsche caliper mounting bolts. No issues. In my case, the brake shields clashed slightly. In the photo below, you can see that the mounting ears overlapped with the shield, causing the shield to be pushed into the rotor in 2 places. A quick buzz with the Dremel fixed that right up. You can also use snips or pliers to cut or bend them out of the way, it's pretty easy no matter what you do. Now that the calipers can cleanly bolt up, snug the bolts down relatively tight and give the hub/rotor assembly a spin. You probably hear a very light grinding...as though there's just a thousandth or two of contact between the caliper and the rotor's outer edge. Grab your Dremel (or whatever) equipped with a sanding drum, and slightly clearance this inner face: It's about 30 seconds of sanding, nothing dramatic. This is the last modification you will be doing to ensure fitment :cool: Now, thread in your brake line. It's a direct fit. Being mindful of the angle of the brake line (it's coming off the opposite edge of the caliper relative to the stock ones), mount up the calipers and snug it down for the last time. Torque spec is 63 ft-lbs. Spin the hub to double check you have no grinding, repeating the grinding process until it's clear. It shouldn't take much. Other side installed: For installing the pads, you need the 2 slide pins, 2 R-clips (they're small), and the 2 spring clips for each caliper. Assembly looks like this: If you can't see, the spring clips are perpendicular to the pins. Their clip goes over the brake pad back plate. There are small holes in the pins, which you put the R-clips into. Zoom in to the pic if necessary. I also went ahead and replaced my brake fluid resorvoir, to match my coolant tank :cool: Of course, you need to now bleed the brake system completely. After bleeding, you're good to go! Follow the manufacturer's recommendation for pad break-in like always.

Is this for front and rear and does is matter early or late 944?

Ish_944 11-13-2016 09:50 AM

Great job, excellent write-up!

What about the rears? :)
Do you have any plans?

odonnell 11-13-2016 10:10 AM


Originally Posted by V2Rocket (Post 13742701)
Sweet!
did you happen to take measurements of piston diameters?

looking forward to impressions...confirm these fit under 15" wheels?

Clearance seems to be fine under my 16" Fuchs, can't verify 15" wheels though. I didn't measure the pistons, but I read online that they're 38mm I think?


Originally Posted by chanothemekhanik (Post 13742826)
Is this for front and rear and does is matter early or late 944?

This is only the front brakes. Should work for all NA models.


Originally Posted by Ish_944 (Post 13743027)
Great job, excellent write-up!

What about the rears? :)
Do you have any plans?

The easiest solution is probably to use 951 rear brakes, they bolt right on. Using 951 brakes up front requires 951 spindles, rotors, hubs, struts, etc. I'll probably leave my rears alone unless I happen across a great deal.

V2Rocket 11-13-2016 01:21 PM

99% sure that the NA caliper bolt spacing is the same in the back as it is the front.
So might be able to fit some of these calipers on the back as well...
I don't have my 944 handy, Michael...please measure the rear caliper bolt spacing!
Might as well try to mock it up while you've got it apart...:p

Benefit is that these Volvo calipers are way easier to find and much cheaper than 951 stuff. Also 951 stuff is questionable in ability to rebuild them due to some NLA parts...

Who cares what they look like...they're calipers. If you really want you could get a stencil or some lettering made up to say PORSCHE or whatever.

Ish_944 11-13-2016 02:15 PM


Originally Posted by V2Rocket (Post 13743392)
99% sure that the NA caliper bolt spacing is the same in the back as it is the front.
So might be able to fit some of these calipers on the back as well...
I don't have my 944 handy, Michael...please measure the rear caliper bolt spacing!
Might as well try to mock it up while you've got it apart...:p


Wow, would that be ~300 for a 16-pot brake system? If it works well with the stock master cylinder... :)

odonnell 11-13-2016 03:06 PM

I wasn't planning on pulling them but hell, if they're the same, I'll throw my stock front calipers back there :)

V2Rocket 11-13-2016 03:13 PM

Would you mind just checking the fitment...do the Volvo calipers at least bolt up to the rear arms and clear everything?
Give you an extra $5 lol

odonnell 11-13-2016 04:18 PM

I'll let you know. About to head out of town for a few days for work but when I get back I should have my act together for the rears.

And don't worry about the $40 or whatever for the calipers ;) I'm just happy they're installed.

catamax944 11-14-2016 03:05 AM

rears have 951 bolt spacing ...95mm
An interesting combo in my opinion would be to use 964 2 pot calipers in the rear .

SloMo228 11-14-2016 11:12 AM

Nice write-up! I completely forgot about having to trim the dust shields. :o

I have been running these Volvo calipers for about 2 years now with no issues. I even painted them red and used Redstuff pads too! I can confirm that they fit under 15" phone dials with no issues as that's the size I ran last winter.

V2Rocket 11-14-2016 11:50 AM

:cool: ^^

V2Rocket 11-14-2016 07:10 PM

been bored for a while at work so ive been doing reading about brake systems...

found some interesting info re: piston sizing.

Stock 944NA: 1x 54mm (floating style)..........= 4580 sq.mm piston area...we'll call this 100%
Stock 86 951: 2x 38mm + 2x 36mm (fixed)...= 4302 sq.mm piston area.......................93.9%
Stock 87 951: 2x 40mm + 2x 36mm (fixed)...= 4547 sq.mm piston area.......................99.3%
1992 VOLVO: 240 4x 38mm (fixed) ...............= 4534 sq.mm piston area.......................98.9%

so the stock 944NA calipers actually have the MOST piston area of all these options. (even though it is a single piston, the floating design effectively doubles piston area)

however the fixed type calipers (951 and Volvo) tend to have advantages in:
1) heat dissipation (due to material, mass, and general caliper design)
2) more even pad+rotor contact = more efficient braking and better pad wear
3) weight (if you've ever held a 944NA caliper and a 951 caliper at the same time, WOW)

Since the 944 NA and 951 have the same brake master cylinder, the caliper piston areas must have been kept similar to achieve similar pedal feel. What is nice is that we can see the Volvo calipers are almost identical in piston area to the later 951, but actually a little bit more than the 1986 951 brakes.


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 06:24 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands