Stand Alone EMS Trigger Wheels
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Stand Alone EMS Trigger Wheels
I'm building a new motor and plan to use a Megasquirt-based EMS (microsquirt) to control fuel and spark. I've researched various options for trigger wheels and come up with a few options. I've generally settled on a solution but I'm curious for other ideas and maybe some first-hand examples. Here are the options I've come up with:
- S/S2 60-2 flywheel
o Pros: OEM parts and location, cheap/easy to source replacements
o Cons: 225mm diameter doesn't support 951 clutch components, harder to adjust sensor gap
- TTV 60-2 flywheel
o Pros: Allows for 951 clutch parts, use OEM parts
o Cons: Relatively expensive, production lead time
- 968 60-2 ring gear
o Pros: Can adapt to stock 951 flywheel (I think?)
o Cons: Hard to source, requires machine work to flywheel, must be clocked properly
- Front-mount trigger wheel
o Pros: Cheap (~$40), easy to adjust sensor gap
o Cons: Requires custom (expensive) sensor mount, new or extended wiring harness
As of right now I've settled on the front mounted trigger wheel but I can't seem to find much information on folks who have mounted the 36-1 trigger wheel from goingsuperfast.com. I picked up a pretty sweet crank sensor mount intended for this application from eBay at a fairly reasonable $100 price. Here's the sensor mount Front mount crank sensor on eBay.
Would anyone who has used the goingsuperfast 36-1 trigger wheel on their car be willing to post up some pics of the install and where you mounted the sensor? I understand on a 4 cylinder car the missing tooth will ideally be located 9 teeth before the sensor at TDC but there's no way to do it with the mount I picked up. I feel like I'm missing a critical step here but I don't have enough information to fill in the blanks.
- S/S2 60-2 flywheel
o Pros: OEM parts and location, cheap/easy to source replacements
o Cons: 225mm diameter doesn't support 951 clutch components, harder to adjust sensor gap
- TTV 60-2 flywheel
o Pros: Allows for 951 clutch parts, use OEM parts
o Cons: Relatively expensive, production lead time
- 968 60-2 ring gear
o Pros: Can adapt to stock 951 flywheel (I think?)
o Cons: Hard to source, requires machine work to flywheel, must be clocked properly
- Front-mount trigger wheel
o Pros: Cheap (~$40), easy to adjust sensor gap
o Cons: Requires custom (expensive) sensor mount, new or extended wiring harness
As of right now I've settled on the front mounted trigger wheel but I can't seem to find much information on folks who have mounted the 36-1 trigger wheel from goingsuperfast.com. I picked up a pretty sweet crank sensor mount intended for this application from eBay at a fairly reasonable $100 price. Here's the sensor mount Front mount crank sensor on eBay.
Would anyone who has used the goingsuperfast 36-1 trigger wheel on their car be willing to post up some pics of the install and where you mounted the sensor? I understand on a 4 cylinder car the missing tooth will ideally be located 9 teeth before the sensor at TDC but there's no way to do it with the mount I picked up. I feel like I'm missing a critical step here but I don't have enough information to fill in the blanks.
#4
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Michael, I thought I remembered your solution being interesting but not repeatable for my intended use. Looks like a solid mount for sure but balance shafts are a must for me.
I'll post some pics in this thread of the mount and wheel setup I've got currently. I'm just concerned I won't be able to use my setup because at best I can align the sensor to the 6th tooth from the missing tooth. No way I can get to 9.
I'll post some pics in this thread of the mount and wheel setup I've got currently. I'm just concerned I won't be able to use my setup because at best I can align the sensor to the 6th tooth from the missing tooth. No way I can get to 9.
#6
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
I think that would totally work if you were running balance shaft delete on an early block. Don't think it would work on a block with the late tensioner.
#7
Rainman
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Aaron, can MS run the standard 951 132-tooth wheel?
I know people get frustrated with speed/ref sensors and want to ditch them somehow, but if you think about it, the parts are all mounted already, the sensors aren't THAT expensive, they are protected from the elements...
Make sure your wiring harness plugs are in good shape, and maybe swap the sensors every 3rd timing belt change as preventative maintenace.
I know people get frustrated with speed/ref sensors and want to ditch them somehow, but if you think about it, the parts are all mounted already, the sensors aren't THAT expensive, they are protected from the elements...
Make sure your wiring harness plugs are in good shape, and maybe swap the sensors every 3rd timing belt change as preventative maintenace.
Trending Topics
#8
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Aaron, can MS run the standard 951 132-tooth wheel?
I know people get frustrated with speed/ref sensors and want to ditch them somehow, but if you think about it, the parts are all mounted already, the sensors aren't THAT expensive, they are protected from the elements...
Make sure your wiring harness plugs are in good shape, and maybe swap the sensors every 3rd timing belt change as preventative maintenace.
I know people get frustrated with speed/ref sensors and want to ditch them somehow, but if you think about it, the parts are all mounted already, the sensors aren't THAT expensive, they are protected from the elements...
Make sure your wiring harness plugs are in good shape, and maybe swap the sensors every 3rd timing belt change as preventative maintenace.
If I were going to add MS to an NA car, I would just spend the ~$100 on a S/S2 flywheel and call it a day.
The additional power from a turbo motor makes clutch options for the smaller flywheel a bit more difficult and it's more expensive for exotic clutch parts than it is for a new flywheel. If the damned machine shops here didn't charge like they were trying to make up for six months' alimony I would probably have gotten a stock 951 flywheel notched with 60-2 teeth.
I'm pretty sure AZbanks is correct and tunerstudio allows you to tell the MS which tooth has the sensor relative to the missing tooth/teeth. I haven't played with the software that much because I'm still working on the hardware.
Somewhat humorously, it looks like using MS on a 951 is the most difficult application based on the availability of OEM/OEM-ish solutions.
#9
Rainman
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
use a longer bolt to hold the auto-tensioner sprocket in place...let the long end poke through the belt covers and just fit the sensor between the two nuts....its not like it moves once you set it in place...
#10
Rennlist Member
I looked at using the stock triggers but it ends up being annoying. High tooth count is questionable in a Microsquirt without using a hardware divider (132 / 3 = 44), maybe possible in a MS3X or MS3Pro because they have much more powerful hardware.
This is good reading for using the stock triggers:
http://74.124.198.224/~micro/viewtop...1244fbc51d1931
http://www.microsquirt.com/viewtopic.php?f=87&t=23063
Tl;dr it's possible but a PITA. I've had zero sync losses ever with a basic $40 wheel on the front and can cleanly rev to 6500 (rev limiter) all day long.
Re-reading the 2nd link, it's very possible that your Microsquirt already has the uprated shunt diode and it'll be ready to go out of the box.
This is good reading for using the stock triggers:
http://74.124.198.224/~micro/viewtop...1244fbc51d1931
http://www.microsquirt.com/viewtopic.php?f=87&t=23063
Tl;dr it's possible but a PITA. I've had zero sync losses ever with a basic $40 wheel on the front and can cleanly rev to 6500 (rev limiter) all day long.
Re-reading the 2nd link, it's very possible that your Microsquirt already has the uprated shunt diode and it'll be ready to go out of the box.
#11
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
I took some pics of how my trigger wheel and crank sensor are currently set up. I know the sensor isn't correctly oriented but I'm not really chomping at the bit to start cutting my timing covers either.
This is the $40 36-1 trigger wheel from going super fast and the $100 crank sensor mount from eBay. The crank sensor came with the mount. Not sure if the sensor will actually work with this set up but so far it appears it will.
This is the $40 36-1 trigger wheel from going super fast and the $100 crank sensor mount from eBay. The crank sensor came with the mount. Not sure if the sensor will actually work with this set up but so far it appears it will.
#13
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
The plating was done by a company in Ft. Worth. Send me a PM if you'd like the details.
#14
Rennlist Member
The tooth it aligns with isn't significant unless a) you're using an EDIS module for ignition, in which case it needs to be at a certain point or b) your missing tooth is less than, say, 15* BTDC on cyl #1 (because it won't get the "heads up" until the ignition event has likely occurred). The last point isn't even significant because you only have 35 teeth to begin with, which isn't that many to count before the next sync.
Your sensor looks like a generic VR sensor and should work fine, but I'd make sure to take a trigger composite log to make sure it reads cleanly. And because there's no ground sheath (a 3rd pin, like in our OEM reference sensors) you really should consider shielding the cable against EMI, as it's near the alternator. Other solutions include using a VR sensor with that built it, or using a hall effect sensor with the same body dimensions.
Thanks for the tip on the plating, I'll PM you when I have all my parts together and decide if I'm going that route.
Your sensor looks like a generic VR sensor and should work fine, but I'd make sure to take a trigger composite log to make sure it reads cleanly. And because there's no ground sheath (a 3rd pin, like in our OEM reference sensors) you really should consider shielding the cable against EMI, as it's near the alternator. Other solutions include using a VR sensor with that built it, or using a hall effect sensor with the same body dimensions.
Thanks for the tip on the plating, I'll PM you when I have all my parts together and decide if I'm going that route.