Transmission options for 87S
#16
Instructor
The turn around time perspective is a factor for some I'm sure; a swap for a used box will generally be quicker if you're just re/re-ing. I love the quote "You already own a used gearbox; why buy another?" and personally I prefer to do things right the first time as my time to play with these cars is not infinite. I can certainly appreciate if your car was your daily or if you were looking for the solution with the lowest up-front cost then a used replacement makes sense. The community is better for having solutions from Lart and others available, I think that for as many cars that Lart has parted over the years, he's kept just as many on the road with a viable secondary part option. If only shipping wasn't so prohibitive to Canada....
#17
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Yes, that seems to be the case. I have also seen this for 944S2 transmissions, although I don't know others that have.
My bias is toward people who want to keep their car for the long term, that's true. If you are just interested in getting another year or two use out of your car, then by all means a used transmission can be a good option. However, a used transmission is almost always a pig-in-a-poke. While rebuilding is more expensive in the short term, if you do the math on cost-to-rebuild / anticipated-longevity, a rebuild is always less expensive.
My bias is toward people who want to keep their car for the long term, that's true. If you are just interested in getting another year or two use out of your car, then by all means a used transmission can be a good option. However, a used transmission is almost always a pig-in-a-poke. While rebuilding is more expensive in the short term, if you do the math on cost-to-rebuild / anticipated-longevity, a rebuild is always less expensive.