Early off set is WAY better looking and they will look better on your car... heres what mine looks like



and the interior since I never have shown pics of my car here b4

 

I have the 16" Phones (early offset) with Yokahamas and 15" Fuchs with Kuhmo Victoracers, and the Fuchs are quite a bit lighter and from what I hear Victoracers are heavy tires.

BTW, wrong offset in case no one told you

 

There is no way a 16" Phone Dial wheel is lighter than a 15" Fuch wheel unless the Fuch wheel is a replica.
What year is your car and what offset is the Phone Dial wheels? I think the Fuchs would look best being painted the same color as your car but that is just my 2 cents.

 

Victoracer's are r-compound race tires and are usually lighter than street tires.