Need some wheel/tire setup advice
#1
Advanced
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Marquette, MI
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Need some wheel/tire setup advice
Here's my situation. I've got an '83 944 that I'm looking to use a bit more heavily for autocross and some track events this coming season. I'm going as far as to say that if funds allow, it will become a dedicated track car, though I would like it to remain street legal.
I have two sets of wheels for the car, both of which are at the point of needing new tires. The original set for the car which are the 15x7 cookie cutters and a set of Mille Miglia Cup II replicas (993 look) which have the huge backspacing in them to allow for correct offset on an early 944. The Cup II's are 17x7.5 up front and 17x9 in the rear. These tires allow for a pretty large contact patch but seem to have some drawbacks. I haven't weighed them but I know they are pretty heavy, mostly due to the design of the wheel and backspacing. Also I realize that rotational mass might be higher then on the 15's which may affect acceleration.
My question really boils down to this. Would it be more beneficial to me to use the cookie cutters, with a smaller diameter tire, maybe a dedicated slick, or go with something similar for the Cup II's? One way or the other, I could use the second set for some street tires. Is the effects of a smaller diameter tire on the 15's enough to counteract the amount of lost contact patch?
I realize the basic handling effects of the wider rear tires and as I do some set up work on the car, would change settings to counteract them depending on which route I go.
I know alot of guys here track their early na's, so I'm hoping to get some good feedback.
I have two sets of wheels for the car, both of which are at the point of needing new tires. The original set for the car which are the 15x7 cookie cutters and a set of Mille Miglia Cup II replicas (993 look) which have the huge backspacing in them to allow for correct offset on an early 944. The Cup II's are 17x7.5 up front and 17x9 in the rear. These tires allow for a pretty large contact patch but seem to have some drawbacks. I haven't weighed them but I know they are pretty heavy, mostly due to the design of the wheel and backspacing. Also I realize that rotational mass might be higher then on the 15's which may affect acceleration.
My question really boils down to this. Would it be more beneficial to me to use the cookie cutters, with a smaller diameter tire, maybe a dedicated slick, or go with something similar for the Cup II's? One way or the other, I could use the second set for some street tires. Is the effects of a smaller diameter tire on the 15's enough to counteract the amount of lost contact patch?
I realize the basic handling effects of the wider rear tires and as I do some set up work on the car, would change settings to counteract them depending on which route I go.
I know alot of guys here track their early na's, so I'm hoping to get some good feedback.
#2
Instructor
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Florence, SC
Posts: 202
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
For autocross go with the smaller diameter wheels for better acceleration/deceleration.
Reduce unsprung weight is a basic principle of race car engineering. There has to be some other strong reason to override that principle.
All theory aside, go to the track and see what the fastest cars are doing, then do what they do, if you can.
Reduce unsprung weight is a basic principle of race car engineering. There has to be some other strong reason to override that principle.
All theory aside, go to the track and see what the fastest cars are doing, then do what they do, if you can.
#3
Advanced
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Marquette, MI
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by ekeeton
For autocross go with the smaller diameter wheels for better acceleration/deceleration.
Reduce unsprung weight is a basic principle of race car engineering. There has to be some other strong reason to override that principle.
All theory aside, go to the track and see what the fastest cars are doing, then do what they do, if you can.
Reduce unsprung weight is a basic principle of race car engineering. There has to be some other strong reason to override that principle.
All theory aside, go to the track and see what the fastest cars are doing, then do what they do, if you can.
The other question I meant to include in the original post was, for those who are running 15x7's, what size tires are you running on them?
#5
Nordschleife Master
The popular size for 944's running 15x7 in my area is 225/50/15. You might be able to find 225/45/15 but you probably will only find this size in an r-comp tire, like V710's, V700's...etc.
Use the replica's for street use and keep the cookies for auto-x, they are a really lightweight wheel and tires will be cheaper. My friend has a set of turbo twist replicas and they are incredibly heavy.
Use the replica's for street use and keep the cookies for auto-x, they are a really lightweight wheel and tires will be cheaper. My friend has a set of turbo twist replicas and they are incredibly heavy.
#7
Advanced
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Marquette, MI
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by MAD MAC
If you run big brakes you may run into a clearance issue with the 15's.
Trending Topics
#8
Advanced
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Marquette, MI
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Techno Duck
The popular size for 944's running 15x7 in my area is 225/50/15. You might be able to find 225/45/15 but you probably will only find this size in an r-comp tire, like V710's, V700's...etc.
Use the replica's for street use and keep the cookies for auto-x, they are a really lightweight wheel and tires will be cheaper. My friend has a set of turbo twist replicas and they are incredibly heavy.
Use the replica's for street use and keep the cookies for auto-x, they are a really lightweight wheel and tires will be cheaper. My friend has a set of turbo twist replicas and they are incredibly heavy.
#9
Advanced
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Marquette, MI
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by tifosiman
Stick with the 15's and get some Hoosiers. You'd get clobbered at an autocross with those repro 17's.
You guys are making my mind up rather quickly!
#10
Advanced
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Marquette, MI
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Oh, and another question, the tire I was looking at was the Hoosier A6. From what I read it is designed for autocross primarily. Will I have heat issues with it on road course track days? I'm curious if it would be better to go with a heat cycled R6 instead. I did a quick search and found them both available in 225/45's so either the A6 or R6 sound like contenders.
#11
Nordschleife Master
Take my advice with a grain of salt here because i am pretty new to a R-Comp type tire. The A6 will probably not be very good on a road course as they are designed to offer maximum grip with minimal heat, meaning you will probably heatcycle these out on a track very quickly. The R6 compound can take the heat punishment but will take longer to get heat in them. Im not sure how long it would take to get a desirable level of heat into the R6 at an auto-x type event, or if you would ever get enough heat into them to make them sticky.
Have you considered the Toyo RA-1? Ive read great things about these tires and many people use them for dual purpose track and auto-x use. I also know a few people that run them on the street all the time. They will never be as competitive as say a Kumho v710, but still offer good grip over even the best summer tire ive read. These also last stupid long i hear.
Have you considered the Toyo RA-1? Ive read great things about these tires and many people use them for dual purpose track and auto-x use. I also know a few people that run them on the street all the time. They will never be as competitive as say a Kumho v710, but still offer good grip over even the best summer tire ive read. These also last stupid long i hear.
#12
Race Director
Hoosier A6's will kill the RA-1's. The RA-1's are slow to come up to heat and do not stick that well at an autocross until the 3rd run (if you have a small turn-out of competitors, if it is a large turn-out and a long time between runs you are screwed). The RA-1's are better than a street tire, but not the best for autox.
#13
Race Car
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Jacksonville, FL Duval County
Posts: 4,220
Likes: 0
Received 35 Likes
on
24 Posts
I've got a similar situation with my 89 944. It has 15" phone dials and I had planned on getting another set of wheels for autox (and maybe a couple of track events). I found some 16" (which are wider in the back) phone dials. Is the wider contact patch going to help or is there going to be too much of a difference in weight? And could someone fill me in on exactly what wheel is the really nice lightweight one...Fuchs, right? But what do they look like? Are they all 15"?
#14
Advanced
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Marquette, MI
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Your 16" phone dials are 15x7 and 15x8 I believe. I know that with my car, switching to the wider rears gave me noticeably more understeer from turn in to apex, but on exit, if I did things right, it also allowed me to lay down alot of traction on exit under power. Despite more of a tendancy to understeer, its still pretty easy to hang the tail out i I want.
Fuchs are the classic Porsche wheel used since the late '60's through '80's on various Porsches. From what I recall, they are supposedly lighter then comparable wheels (cookie cutter/phone dial) of same size. Not positive though, thus me asking in the beginning of the thread.
Fuchs are the classic Porsche wheel used since the late '60's through '80's on various Porsches. From what I recall, they are supposedly lighter then comparable wheels (cookie cutter/phone dial) of same size. Not positive though, thus me asking in the beginning of the thread.
#15
Burning Brakes
I am running 15X7 cookie cutters on my 924S which I assume has all the same suspension offsets and geometry etc as the pre 85.5 944's. Im thinking about converting to turbo brakes which would mean turbo knuckles and 16" rims. Is there any particular offset of 16" rim that you should look for to maintain the pre 85.5 steering geometry?