Notices
924/931/944/951/968 Forum Porsche 924, 924S, 931, 944, 944S, 944S2, 951, and 968 discussion, how-to guides, and technical help. (1976-1995)
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

My Memoirs: Feedback on my Manual Steering Rack swap

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 01-14-2005 | 09:25 PM
  #61  
Manning's Avatar
Manning
Addict
Rennlist Member

 
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 5,910
Likes: 3
Default

Uninsulated is a pretty good description. Like I wrote on the previous page (page 3), the hydraulics of the power system actually provide quite a bit of damping, kind of like shock absorbers. I experienced this most dramatically when a line blew on my old Scirocco. No kickback really, just a really good sense of what is happening between your front tires and the road. It is actually kind of freaky at first.

Regarding price, I'm going with Tifo on this as well - YMMV. I think it is important to figure in the cost of used parts that you may buy that you wind up not using because they are too worn out. I lucked out though and only had to buy new boots and tie rods and still wound up paying between $300 and $350 total.

Last edited by Manning; 01-15-2005 at 12:57 PM.
Old 01-15-2005 | 09:44 AM
  #62  
shortyboy's Avatar
shortyboy
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 2,528
Likes: 34
From: Honolulu,HI
Default

so the manual tie rod ends for the late 944 are hard to find?damn that sucks.
Old 01-15-2005 | 09:53 AM
  #63  
Luis de Prat's Avatar
Luis de Prat
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 9,714
Likes: 7
From: Barcelona
Default

Originally Posted by TaylorSea4
Jim, you know someone who owns one of the US Turbo Cup/ Escort cars?? Which sponsorship livery did it originally run? Those are real gems, man. As uber-rare as it gets...
FWIW there's a member right here in this forum who found one literally "in a barn" and has been putting it back on the road. It was originally Al Holbert's race car, to boot!
Old 01-15-2005 | 10:06 AM
  #64  
Steve PH's Avatar
Steve PH
Instructor
 
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 214
Likes: 0
From: Reading UK
Default

________________________________________________________________________ _____________
so the manual tie rod ends for the late 944 are hard to find?damn that sucks.
________________________________________________________________________ _____________
If your struggling for tie rods try importing them from a UK (there's no difference lhd/rhd) or EU supplier. I don't believe there is a shortage over here.
Old 01-15-2005 | 01:06 PM
  #65  
Manning's Avatar
Manning
Addict
Rennlist Member

 
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 5,910
Likes: 3
Default

Originally Posted by shortyboy
so the manual tie rod ends for the late 944 are hard to find?damn that sucks.
Word has it the tie rod assemblies for the late offset cars are almost impossible to find. I don't think the ones for the early offset are impossible to find yet, but they have gone up in price since I bought mine. I paid about $85.00 each back in '02 and now Zim's list them for about $119.00.

And don't forget the left boot is the same as the one use on power steering, but the right boot is different.
Old 01-15-2005 | 04:30 PM
  #66  
DER951's Avatar
DER951
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 810
Likes: 35
From: Turtle Cove, Maine
Default

After driving a student's 930 at the Glen last summer, I was very impressed with the steering feedback. I don't think my 951 will ever steer like a 930 (too much weight on front), but I would like to try manual.

What would be involved in making a PS rack truly manual. Not just short circuiting the feed hose back into the return, but removing internal parts.

It seems finding an old manual rack is hard, finding a good one harder, and good tie rods and intemediate shaft nearly impossible.

I haven't disassembled a PS rack, but what's inside there that isn't needed in a manual mode?
Old 01-15-2005 | 07:05 PM
  #67  
tifosiman's Avatar
tifosiman
Thread Starter
Race Director
 
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 12,208
Likes: 16
From: The Heart of it All
Default

Originally Posted by DER951
After driving a student's 930 at the Glen last summer, I was very impressed with the steering feedback. I don't think my 951 will ever steer like a 930 (too much weight on front), but I would like to try manual.

What would be involved in making a PS rack truly manual. Not just short circuiting the feed hose back into the return, but removing internal parts.

It seems finding an old manual rack is hard, finding a good one harder, and good tie rods and intemediate shaft nearly impossible.

I haven't disassembled a PS rack, but what's inside there that isn't needed in a manual mode?
You really need a real manual rack. The manual rack has the proper ratio to te used un-assisted. A power rack, stipped of all of it's pump, fluid, etc, is still equipped with the wrong ratio on the rack and pinion gears. It will be hard as hell to turn and use at low speeds (think about what it's like when your powere steering pump goes out or the belt breaks, same feel). I guess you could swap in a manual rack r and p gearset, but then what is the point? You could have just put the complete manual rack in there that you would have rogued the gearset from.

Hope that makes sense!
Old 01-15-2005 | 07:06 PM
  #68  
FSAEracer03's Avatar
FSAEracer03
TRB0 GUY
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 3,769
Likes: 0
From: Daphne, AL
Default

Originally Posted by TaylorSea4
Rock on, Tifo. I'd be currious to know if it increased any bump steer in rougher corners. The Excellence article on that Turbo Cup car last month had a quote from some driver that said the bump steer/ kickback/ whatever wasn't good. Sounded to me like a lilly boy cryin' for momma, but maybe that's just me.
That's not dependant on the tie-rod anlge (Ackerman) like was said, but on the height of the rack and the mounting location of the tie-rods. The bumpsteer is determined basically by the angle difference of the tie-rod and the a-arm. And yes... it can very well be the difference between a win and a barrier wall.

I am very happy with the steering communication from the late 951 PS rack... it's still weighty (not assisted much) and translates road surface well. I'm curious as to how much different they are. I have never had to perform a service on a non-PS equiped 944 at the shop, but I'll have to keep my eye out. I'd driven other manual rack cars and was very pleased save <5mph maneauvers! Tifo, will you be at the 944Fest with the famous CS? I want to see this thing in person. It's very impressive behind this screen.
Old 01-15-2005 | 07:20 PM
  #69  
tifosiman's Avatar
tifosiman
Thread Starter
Race Director
 
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 12,208
Likes: 16
From: The Heart of it All
Default

Thanks!

I plan on being there this year. Honestly, the paint is dead. I needs to be repainted bad. That's the last thing on my ever-growing list to do.............
Old 01-15-2005 | 07:25 PM
  #70  
Oddjob's Avatar
Oddjob
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 4,697
Likes: 80
From: Midwest - US
Default

Originally Posted by TaylorSea4
Jim, you know someone who owns one of the US Turbo Cup/ Escort cars?? Which sponsorship livery did it originally run? Those are real gems, man. As uber-rare as it gets...

The car came from Randy Alexander who I believe got it from/thru Kelly Moss Racing, but I dont think they ever raced it professionally. The guy I know bought it from Randy about 4 years ago, and just sold it to another PCA guy in the area. So at this point, the car is still in MN.

Yes its quite a rare car, more so than the Canadian or European Turbo Cup cars. I have heard the number of US Spec Escort cars to be fewer than 10, and the number 7 rings a bell. But no confirmation on that whatsoever. There were a few '86 model year cars imported in for Escort Series, and then a few more in '87. I have never heard of an 88+ Escort car, but not sure that they dont exist. I believe all the Canadian Cup cars were 1988s.

Anyway, this car (an 87) is white and has had a couple different number/graphics schemes on it since Ive known of it, but none were the original Escort series logos or sponsorship (just numbers and stripes used by the current owners for PCA Club Racing). So I dont know the history of the car, who raced it or what the color scheme was on it back in the late 80's.

As far as late offset tie rods being available, you can still get them through the dealership for around $180 list price for each. Its a RoW part, since power steering was standard equipment on US cars, so your regular dealer might have to do some searching, and expect to wait several weeks, months for the slow boat from Germany to show up, unless you want to pay for air freight. When I had my usual parts guy check for me last week, there were 59 of them on the parts shelf in the Germany warehouse, none in North America.
Old 01-15-2005 | 07:34 PM
  #71  
tifosiman's Avatar
tifosiman
Thread Starter
Race Director
 
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 12,208
Likes: 16
From: The Heart of it All
Default

Originally Posted by Luis de Prat
FWIW there's a member right here in this forum who found one literally "in a barn" and has been putting it back on the road. It was originally Al Holbert's race car, to boot!
That guy has more or less disappeared, unfortunately. I emailed him and PM'd him awhile back and no reply. He bought the car, the motor and other parts are in boxes, then didn't have the money to do anything with it. He posted it for sale on the Turbo BBS stating that he had financial issues and then disappeared. If someone bought it that lurks here on the BBS, or if he has it, I'd be curious......................

I just picked up a pair of 930 16X9 fuchs for the rear of my car, ala the 86 cup cars. After I get them cleaned up, painted red in the centers and some new tires, they will go on the back and the 951 8" fuchs will go to the front. I've been looking for a pair ever since I saw his car with them on it........
Old 01-15-2005 | 07:56 PM
  #72  
Darius Juca's Avatar
Darius Juca
Burning Brakes
 
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 1,201
Likes: 0
From: Orangevale, CA. USA
Default

Tifo how long is the manual steering shaft from column to rack? from beginning of U joint to beginning of U joint?
Old 01-15-2005 | 08:14 PM
  #73  
TaylorSea4's Avatar
TaylorSea4
Pro
 
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 747
Likes: 1
From: 4th Ring of Hades, aka Houston, TX
Default

Yeah, Jim, the number of Escort/ US Cup cars was, indeed, seven. Sean, the guy who found the Holbert/ Rothman's car under a tarp, emailed me right before the holidays, and he and the car are doing fine. He decided to basically sit on the car until his financial situation is such that he can put it right. So, yeah, Jim, that car in Minnesota is a RARE find, regardless of its condition.

Back on track, though, there's a dismantler here in Texas (Dallas- Ft. Worth area) that did my buddy right on some stuff for his '86 NA. Can't remember the name, I'll try to find it. I had no clue that manual racks (and the associated parts) were that hard to find.

Kevin, I wasn't referring to bump steer in the classic sense of the expression. Last month's 'Excellence' had an article on a Canadian Turbo Cup car, and one of the non-factory changes the owner made was the addition of power steering. Mods in the Rothman's Cup were limited to tire pressure and ride height (using the eccentrics?). Would that increase the bump steer? Or maybe it had more to do with the curb-bashing, late-braking, cut-throat tactics employed by the drivers of that series. Yeah, kickback indeed...
Old 01-15-2005 | 09:13 PM
  #74  
Manning's Avatar
Manning
Addict
Rennlist Member

 
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 5,910
Likes: 3
Default

Originally Posted by FSAEracer03
That's not dependant on the tie-rod anlge (Ackerman) like was said, but on the height of the rack and the mounting location of the tie-rods. The bumpsteer is determined basically by the angle difference of the tie-rod and the a-arm. And yes... it can very well be the difference between a win and a barrier wall.
????

I though Ackerman was the relation of toe angle between the front wheels. Bump has to do with how the angle of the tie rods impacts toe as the suspension travels, from full droop to fully compressed. So, since the tie rod mounting point doesn't change from power to manual steering then there is not real impact to bump steer.
Old 01-15-2005 | 09:44 PM
  #75  
TaylorSea4's Avatar
TaylorSea4
Pro
 
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 747
Likes: 1
From: 4th Ring of Hades, aka Houston, TX
Default

Okay, okay. So there's NO increase in feedback to the steering wheels due to the unassisted rack? Mid corner bumps, rough corner entries, curb-hopping all attribute to SOME level of kickback/ feedback/ whatever in the steering wheel, right? I'm not saying it's an issue, either. I asked Tifo about it (cuz I know he's not prone to bull****) to disprove whatever it was those former Rothman's Cup drivers were saying about the Cup cars needing power steering.

My amatuer guess is that on significantly lighter cars (Turbo Cups, Tifo's, an RS'd 924 like yours, Manning) a manual rack would only enhance the experience. Send ALL the info in undiluted and clear. Does anyone know if Ski converted his track car to a manual rack? Anycow, I didn't mean to start a huge debate or anything; I was just currious...


Quick Reply: My Memoirs: Feedback on my Manual Steering Rack swap



All times are GMT -3. The time now is 08:03 PM.