water pump? whirring sound
#1
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
water pump? whirring sound
Hey everyone,
A quick story: my car has had hot-start and hot-hesitation problems since i bought it. After chasing the problem down to the FPR I replaced it. I took it out for a test run and the headgasket blew. I replaced the headgasket and all other gaskets that come with the set, as well as the oil cooler seals while i was in there, just to be safe. As I fired her up after 2 weeks of sitting headless, i saw water dripping from the water pump, and i heard a WHIRRING sound proportional to engine speed. I don't know if this sound was there before, i never listened for it. I figured the water pump was shot so I replaced it, along with the timing belt (just to be safe) and all the front seals except for cam (while i was in there), I just finished yesterday. Turned it on and I still hear the sound. I did a complete timing / balance shaft belt job with all rollers just 200 miles ago. I used a screwdriver as a stethoscope on the WP and i hear the sound from there.
I will try other places to see if the sound is louder anywhere else. My question is, assuming the rebuilt WP is not faulty (I hope its not) what else could cause this sound? Would the belt rubbing the rear cover make a sound like a worn bearing? Any ideas are welcome, I'll try anything before taking the WP out again. TIA!
A quick story: my car has had hot-start and hot-hesitation problems since i bought it. After chasing the problem down to the FPR I replaced it. I took it out for a test run and the headgasket blew. I replaced the headgasket and all other gaskets that come with the set, as well as the oil cooler seals while i was in there, just to be safe. As I fired her up after 2 weeks of sitting headless, i saw water dripping from the water pump, and i heard a WHIRRING sound proportional to engine speed. I don't know if this sound was there before, i never listened for it. I figured the water pump was shot so I replaced it, along with the timing belt (just to be safe) and all the front seals except for cam (while i was in there), I just finished yesterday. Turned it on and I still hear the sound. I did a complete timing / balance shaft belt job with all rollers just 200 miles ago. I used a screwdriver as a stethoscope on the WP and i hear the sound from there.
I will try other places to see if the sound is louder anywhere else. My question is, assuming the rebuilt WP is not faulty (I hope its not) what else could cause this sound? Would the belt rubbing the rear cover make a sound like a worn bearing? Any ideas are welcome, I'll try anything before taking the WP out again. TIA!
#2
Drifting
Last time I pulled the head and put the engine back together I had a sound like the whirring of a roller. Turned out to be one of the belts rubbing a little on the plastic covers. I would check that first. Beyond the covers, pump, rollers, and idlers I don't know what it could be.
#4
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Check the belts for rubbing, and get the tension professionally done by a shop. These cars will sound supercharged if the belts are even slightly overtight.
#5
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Granite Falls, Washington
Posts: 1,637
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Just a couple things to make sure of might be: (1) make very sure that shoulders on all rollers/wp are in proper alignment/direction, and you have full belt engagement on all these rollers/idlers. lower BS gear on the crank must position with shoulder forward, and belt is not rubbing on cover. (2) make sure you turned the tension roller ecentrics in the proper direction when you installed them.....clockwise for BS, and CCW for cam tensioner. (3) possibly, the BS belt is just a little tighter than it should be?
I have recieved a rebuilt wp in the past, with the pulley on it positioned wrong/wrong pulley for the pump, causing cam belt to ride about an 1/8th of inch off the inside edge of pulley.
I have the same thing as far as waterpump leaking. It is a new pump, and is leaking from behind it at that super thin gasket that I used, and installed dry. I need to remove and do over, this time using a sealant on that gasket. AFAIK, some belt noise is common, but shouldn't sound real prominant for long.
Just some thoughts.....not expert advice. Good luck!
I have recieved a rebuilt wp in the past, with the pulley on it positioned wrong/wrong pulley for the pump, causing cam belt to ride about an 1/8th of inch off the inside edge of pulley.
I have the same thing as far as waterpump leaking. It is a new pump, and is leaking from behind it at that super thin gasket that I used, and installed dry. I need to remove and do over, this time using a sealant on that gasket. AFAIK, some belt noise is common, but shouldn't sound real prominant for long.
Just some thoughts.....not expert advice. Good luck!
#6
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Awesome advice, thanks everyone. I'll see if the belt is rubbing the back cover, since i left the front cover off to check everything for the first start-up. I filled the coolant system with the high-point bolt open until water spilled out. Later, some water overflowed from the tank, as expected. I'll check that the tensioners are turned the right way. Come to think of it, i did notice the belt had 'migrated' back quite a bit. What could remedy this? if i move it forward, wont it just 'migrate' back again?
#7
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
As far as belt tension goes, I would like very much to have it done professionally, but I can't afford it. That pretty much applies to most of the work I do on it, though there are jobs that are actually a lot of fun (TB tension isn't one of them...). I'm using a kriket tension checker, as well as the 3-piece tool kit from arnnworx (flywheel lock and 2 wrenches). Lots of patience and lots of turning the engine by hand.
Trending Topics
#9
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Maybe I didn't bleed the coolant properly... I just opened the high-point bolt (on the metal spout-like neck at the top front of the engine) and filled the reservoir until water spilled out from the high-point. I did all this with the engine off and cold. Did I miss something?
#10
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Id say find the money to get the tension check professionally. If theyre worth their salt, theyll look over the work youve done. And The $100 or whatever it is in the US is a great price for peace of mind with the belts.
~$100 or $3000?
~$100 or $3000?
#11
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Is it really only $100? And they'll fix the tension if I got it wrong? In that case I'll do it... I thought it would cost more like $500-$1000.
#12
Burning Brakes
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Indiana
Posts: 1,022
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
nothing came out of my bleed valve until i ran the engine. i would try bleeding it again while running to see if that fixes anything. also the balance shaft belt tension is much looser than you would think.
#13
Official Bay Area Patriot
Fuse 24 Assassin
Rennlist Member
Fuse 24 Assassin
Rennlist Member
while we're on the subject of belts, I had observed that my mechanic always sets the belts on a tension of 4 on the Porsche belt tensioning gauge. I had brought the car back to him after a while to get a retension and the belts appeared to have been fine and no retension was needed. There's something I don't understand here. Why do our cars require the retension? when the tension had been checked on mine it had been around in the area of 3 1/2 or just a little over. The tension wasn't too tight but I had the whining sound. My last 84 had the same thing and the tension never really got all screwy and loose. call it luck I guess, but I hope I didn't jinx myself just saying this I can't afford to spend another $2500 for another engine and having it dropped in. yeesh...
#14
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by FRporscheman
Is it really only $100? And they'll fix the tension if I got it wrong? In that case I'll do it... I thought it would cost more like $500-$1000.
#15
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by TheStig
while we're on the subject of belts, I had observed that my mechanic always sets the belts on a tension of 4 on the Porsche belt tensioning gauge. I had brought the car back to him after a while to get a retension and the belts appeared to have been fine and no retension was needed. There's something I don't understand here. Why do our cars require the retension? when the tension had been checked on mine it had been around in the area of 3 1/2 or just a little over. The tension wasn't too tight but I had the whining sound. My last 84 had the same thing and the tension never really got all screwy and loose. call it luck I guess, but I hope I didn't jinx myself just saying this I can't afford to spend another $2500 for another engine and having it dropped in. yeesh...
IMHO as long as you follow the suggested belt replacement and retension intervals, things are fine.