Mysterious damage to my OEM GT4 wheel .. any thoughts ?! [New Video uploaded]
#76
Rennlist Member
#77
Burning Brakes
http://www.m3post.com/forums/showpos...38&postcount=1
#78
Advanced
Thread Starter
Speaking of your E9X crew....what's up ole' man I would say Apex wheels had and still have a great following. And at their rate of sale, problems seemed to be very minimal. Now if you want to talk price and junk together...ADV is your topic. Also wanted to drop this off for another wheel manufacturing prospective........Phil
http://www.m3post.com/forums/showpos...38&postcount=1
http://www.m3post.com/forums/showpos...38&postcount=1
please guys lets not change the topic .. We need an answer about my Mystery
#79
Burning Brakes
Man, I also do have a 1M and my brother have E92 M3 .. he is running Apex since 2 years, he have abused them in bahrain more than I did with my GT4, they are still perfect, thats why I am going to have Apex for my 1M
please guys lets not change the topic .. We need an answer about my Mystery
please guys lets not change the topic .. We need an answer about my Mystery
#80
Advanced
Thread Starter
One of my friends was in yesterday's Nurburgring VLN Race .. He have asked PORSCHE test drivers .. read his message below:
I'm speechless now ! .. is that acceptable from PORSCHE ? should I respect their Warranty anymore ???
May I have your opinions guys regarding a reliable contact in PORSCHE? detail may be sent in a private message.
I'm speechless now ! .. is that acceptable from PORSCHE ? should I respect their Warranty anymore ???
May I have your opinions guys regarding a reliable contact in PORSCHE? detail may be sent in a private message.
Last edited by ASM_GT4; 03-26-2017 at 04:41 AM.
#81
Rennlist Member
Porsche has evaded warranty claims on cars that had been tracked before.
If it was posted in the club track day article that you were present with your P car, the dealers were known to scour them for reasons to deny warranty claims. Any claim
If it was posted in the club track day article that you were present with your P car, the dealers were known to scour them for reasons to deny warranty claims. Any claim
Last edited by Perimeter; 04-23-2017 at 12:22 PM.
#82
#83
Rennlist Member
Delete
Last edited by Alan C.; 03-26-2017 at 11:24 PM.
#84
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: On a pygmy pony over by the dental floss bush
Posts: 3,309
Received 618 Likes
on
422 Posts
I agree, even if the distance between dimples matched the distance on the ground between tops of individual curbs, seems non-intuitive it could happen. But, often times our intuition is not right when it involves high energy and high speed events that we don't encounter on a day-to-day basis.
I am leaning on the theory there was some initial defect, like OP says, which then caused the cylinder shape to be more vulnerable to mechanical buckling. Google "buckling modes of cylinder" and choose images and check those out. Here is an example:
I am leaning on the theory there was some initial defect, like OP says, which then caused the cylinder shape to be more vulnerable to mechanical buckling. Google "buckling modes of cylinder" and choose images and check those out. Here is an example:
#86
Rennlist Member
If you use a set of point mics to measure the thickness in the defect area you might find a deviation. The rims are pretty thin. That coupled with an initial shock when seating the bead may have caused localized thinning. I have a photo of a GT4 wheel that hit a curb breaking all of the spokes and leaving a hole in the barrel.
#89
Nordschleife Master
Originally Posted by s2ktaxi
I think the heat radiating from the rotors may also have something to do with it
#90
Rennlist Member
Got into this late but here are some thoughts;
1. Are you sure your request actually went to Germany, did you get a copy of Germany's response or just the dealer's paraphrase.
2. Porsche customer service has always been good but you need to re-file your claim directly to Porsche.
3. The GT4 is a trackable street car not a race car. With your admitted almost all track use, there is some responsibility to assure, tires/wheels/ brakes/etc. are up to the stresses.
4. Had you purchased an RSR from the factory (I have) there is absolutely no warranty. Your on your own.
5. Many track day enthusiasts buy track specific wheels and tires while saving OEM's for the street.
Now, having said all that I again suggest you put forth your issue yourself directly to Porsche. Your owners manual provides such contact information. Do not put your chances of a positive resolution in an intermediary. Good Luck
1. Are you sure your request actually went to Germany, did you get a copy of Germany's response or just the dealer's paraphrase.
2. Porsche customer service has always been good but you need to re-file your claim directly to Porsche.
3. The GT4 is a trackable street car not a race car. With your admitted almost all track use, there is some responsibility to assure, tires/wheels/ brakes/etc. are up to the stresses.
4. Had you purchased an RSR from the factory (I have) there is absolutely no warranty. Your on your own.
5. Many track day enthusiasts buy track specific wheels and tires while saving OEM's for the street.
Now, having said all that I again suggest you put forth your issue yourself directly to Porsche. Your owners manual provides such contact information. Do not put your chances of a positive resolution in an intermediary. Good Luck