White smoke! Head gasket?
#62
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Well, I picked up that recommended combustion leak detector. I did the test according to the directions and there was no change in the fluid color. This indicates there are no combustion gases in the coolant system. Does that completely rule out the HG?
#63
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
They can be separate issues. The head gasket can be gone and some debris in the oil pickup , oil lines, or failing oil pump or seal(s) or other oil leak.
In any event the OP will have to quit driving the car and get it to someone knowledgeable with these cars or a qualified independent Porsche service and tech to sort out these problems .
In any event the OP will have to quit driving the car and get it to someone knowledgeable with these cars or a qualified independent Porsche service and tech to sort out these problems .
#66
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
I did the coolant system pressure test and it didn't lose any pressure at 15 psi, so I did it again at 20 psi and it still didn't lose any pressure over 15 min.
#68
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
The oil pressure issue I saw looks like it may be an issue with the gauge/sender it now reads 1 on the gauge all the time, even it the engine isn't running, if the key is on.)
#69
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Well, with your smoke issue, I would replace the oil sending switch ASAP. Buy one of the decent ones, not the super cheap one.
Yes, it could just be the wires, but most likely it's not. When they go they go. Also, how do you know that the gage isn't actually reading the correct number?
Yes, it could just be the wires, but most likely it's not. When they go they go. Also, how do you know that the gage isn't actually reading the correct number?
#70
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
I assume the gauge is the issue, since I just replaced the sensor with a cheap one a couple weeks before the problem occured, but more importantly it shows a pressure of 1 when the engine is NOT running and it should be 0 when it isn't running! I have not lost significant oil in the time since the problem started and I definately didn't have an oil pressure loss when the problem started, because I've watched very carefully since then and it didn't start until about the 4th time I started the car for testing. I do agree that I need to replace the sender before I go any further, just to make sure the oil pressure isn't a problem.
With that said does the testing I've done eliminate the HG? (Not to say I shouldn't put the HG on my short list of things to do on the car.) If the oil pressure isn't a problem (as I believe but will confirm before going further), what would be the next thing? As a reminder, the smoke started suddenly under full boost, it won't build full boost anymore. I have a small oil leak from the back of the cam tower gasket that drips on the exhaust and the smoke out the exhaust doesn't start, when the engine is cold, until about the same time the smoke starts from the leak.
With that said does the testing I've done eliminate the HG? (Not to say I shouldn't put the HG on my short list of things to do on the car.) If the oil pressure isn't a problem (as I believe but will confirm before going further), what would be the next thing? As a reminder, the smoke started suddenly under full boost, it won't build full boost anymore. I have a small oil leak from the back of the cam tower gasket that drips on the exhaust and the smoke out the exhaust doesn't start, when the engine is cold, until about the same time the smoke starts from the leak.
#72
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
I would say that the HG is still in play. The one thing that the test won't always catch is a semi-blown HG like a few of us here have experienced. It shows up best when the engine is hot and trying to boost. It's tough to do the coolant pressure test on a hot engine, so it's hard to diagnose, but my money is still on the hg.
#73
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
The oil pressure gauge had worked properly for a couple weeks after replacing the sender, so I know the wires aren't connected wrong. I will replace the sensor.
Just to get it straight, from my understanding of everything I've read, at this point the only symptom of a failed HG is that I have is the white/light gray smoke that starts after about a minute on a cold start. You may be right about the HG, but is there anything else that could be causing the problem that I can test/check before I tear the head off? For example is there a way to check the seals in the turbo? Do you just check for play in it?
Thank again for your help!s
Just to get it straight, from my understanding of everything I've read, at this point the only symptom of a failed HG is that I have is the white/light gray smoke that starts after about a minute on a cold start. You may be right about the HG, but is there anything else that could be causing the problem that I can test/check before I tear the head off? For example is there a way to check the seals in the turbo? Do you just check for play in it?
Thank again for your help!s
#74
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
I can't think of anything else to check without taking the aforementioned assemblies apart. Be it turbo, oil cooler, HG. etc., the only real way to check them is to tale them off and tear them apart.