Another Water Pump Thread. Help!!!
#61
Obviously that's at the end of the PKT range, but also because the Audi tensioner/damper compresses (to dampen), the tension will lower the more you work the belt.
Sounds like you are sold on the factory unit, but you could alternately upgrade to a PKT-S bracket, which was made with shaved heads in mind.
Sounds like you are sold on the factory unit, but you could alternately upgrade to a PKT-S bracket, which was made with shaved heads in mind.
#62
#63
I have put on another 5k Km's. When I tear it down this winter I will measure it again. Before the factory unit goes back in.
#64
I finally got a chance to tear into the WP today, here's what I found:
Belt tension cold -
https://rennlist.com/forums/images/attach/jpg.gif
Belt tension at operating temp -
https://rennlist.com/forums/images/attach/jpg.gif
PKT at 7.55mm -
https://rennlist.com/forums/attachme...1&d=1505259177
Belt tension cold -
https://rennlist.com/forums/images/attach/jpg.gif
Belt tension at operating temp -
https://rennlist.com/forums/images/attach/jpg.gif
PKT at 7.55mm -
https://rennlist.com/forums/attachme...1&d=1505259177
#66
That engine got smaller before it hit the showroom floor. (Don't blame the ruler!)
It's OK. It's about how you use it, am-I-right?
#67
To make a reasonable evaluation, we'd need to see that test before and after a tensioner swap.
#68
#70
Captain Obvious
Super User
Super User
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 22,846
Likes: 340
From: Cambridge, Ontario, Canada
Same with my 87 when I went in to change the water pump this summer after 20k km's. The PKT was extended to 9mm and the belt was easy to pull off. With a new belt and pump it was down to 7mm. This winter I'm going back to a factory tensioner.
The 89 motor I just built got a stock tensioner as well.
Imo000, I'm assuming you are talking about Danny's 91. How far was the pkt extended on his with the shaved heads? Did you use the thicker head gasket? Just curious.
The 89 motor I just built got a stock tensioner as well.
Imo000, I'm assuming you are talking about Danny's 91. How far was the pkt extended on his with the shaved heads? Did you use the thicker head gasket? Just curious.
#71
Captain Obvious
Super User
Super User
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 22,846
Likes: 340
From: Cambridge, Ontario, Canada
How about retrofitting a tensioner with a longer reach? This would fix the design flaw. Heck, stack them so when one stops extending, the other one takes over. Whatever it takes to fix the problem.
#72
So now I'm only getting 9 months and less than 2k miles (if that) out of the fin water pumps!!!
Full disclosure, I replaced the WP last September as shown in this thread with a Geba unit as the Lasso WP I got from Worldpac was still under warranty and they no longer supply Lasso WP's. Believe it or not they claim 1% failure on the Lasso and 0.5% failure on the Geba. Take it all with a grain of salt. I figured what the hell the Lasso's are failing what do I have to loose. As I probably noted above I had already bought another new Gates Racing Belt and since there were 300 or so out there with no problems so I thought I'd just throw it on and change to a regular Gates belt over the winter. The Porken unit was within spec so I just chalked it up to really bad luck and nothing was gonna go wrong in a few months right? Wrong. Unfortunately I had some health issues that started last fall and I lost 6 months of wrenching time. Fast forward to spring and Hershey, and then a couple of short runs around town, a dyno run...
I'm going back to stock now. Good thing is I'm a GD pro at this and it will give me chance to get in there and really clean it up this time! GRRRR!
Oh the REALLY sucky part, I leave for Camp 928 tomorrow evening. Anyone want to lead the short fun run? Just wouldn't be right to do it in the Alfa:/
Full disclosure, I replaced the WP last September as shown in this thread with a Geba unit as the Lasso WP I got from Worldpac was still under warranty and they no longer supply Lasso WP's. Believe it or not they claim 1% failure on the Lasso and 0.5% failure on the Geba. Take it all with a grain of salt. I figured what the hell the Lasso's are failing what do I have to loose. As I probably noted above I had already bought another new Gates Racing Belt and since there were 300 or so out there with no problems so I thought I'd just throw it on and change to a regular Gates belt over the winter. The Porken unit was within spec so I just chalked it up to really bad luck and nothing was gonna go wrong in a few months right? Wrong. Unfortunately I had some health issues that started last fall and I lost 6 months of wrenching time. Fast forward to spring and Hershey, and then a couple of short runs around town, a dyno run...
I'm going back to stock now. Good thing is I'm a GD pro at this and it will give me chance to get in there and really clean it up this time! GRRRR!
Oh the REALLY sucky part, I leave for Camp 928 tomorrow evening. Anyone want to lead the short fun run? Just wouldn't be right to do it in the Alfa:/
#74
Stan,
Sorry, I thought I answered this early this morning. Basically I have the same problem I had with the other WP's that failed. If you listen you can hear the WP chaffing, it starts once it gets warmed up. Bearing is toast.
Sorry, I thought I answered this early this morning. Basically I have the same problem I had with the other WP's that failed. If you listen you can hear the WP chaffing, it starts once it gets warmed up. Bearing is toast.
#75
Shameful Thread Killer
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 19,831
Likes: 101
From: Rep of Texas, N NM, Rockies, SoCal
What was the dwell time between the 2k miles in the past 9 months? Do you drive it short distances often, or did you drive it quite a bit and let it sit for a few months? If this is a seal/bearing failure, this kind of drive cycle is important to know.
Once the engine is shut off when warm, there is pressure in the water system for a few hours. If the seal has even a small leak, or the shaft has a small defect, hot water(coolant) can seep in. If this happens a few times with long stretches of not running, the bearing race, and the ***** are subject to contamination. In a perfect world, 928s would get exercised regularly, and the seals would be perfect as well. The real world is different.
My catastrophic WP fail happened after the car had been sitting undriven for 7 months. I started driving it small trips, and then one trip it just gave up. I suspect invasive coolant got past the seal and into the bearing.
Once the engine is shut off when warm, there is pressure in the water system for a few hours. If the seal has even a small leak, or the shaft has a small defect, hot water(coolant) can seep in. If this happens a few times with long stretches of not running, the bearing race, and the ***** are subject to contamination. In a perfect world, 928s would get exercised regularly, and the seals would be perfect as well. The real world is different.
My catastrophic WP fail happened after the car had been sitting undriven for 7 months. I started driving it small trips, and then one trip it just gave up. I suspect invasive coolant got past the seal and into the bearing.