When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
I bought my Macan in September after enjoying over 180000 miles in my 2012 Cayenne S.
I averaged about 30000 per year on the Cayenne and it gave me very little problems but it wasn't perfect.
Here's what I consumed in 6 years::
5 sets of tires.(to be expected)
Fortunately my miles were mostly highway so I only needed to change brake pads and rotors once.
1 ignition sensor. It wouldn't start one morning so my dealer had to come with a flatbed truck and get it.
3 transfer cases (including the original) #2 cost $4000 because it was just out of warranty. (#3 was covered by warranty on #2)
1 driver's-side window switch because the silver trim on the original started to de-laminate.
Overall, I was very satisfied with the Cayenne and expect to put many happy miles on my Macan!
I bought my Macan in September after enjoying over 180000 miles in my 2012 Cayenne S.
I averaged about 30000 per year on the Cayenne and it gave me very little problems but it wasn't perfect.
Here's what I consumed in 6 years::
5 sets of tires.(to be expected)
Fortunately my miles were mostly highway so I only needed to change brake pads and rotors once.
1 ignition sensor. It wouldn't start one morning so my dealer had to come with a flatbed truck and get it.
3 transfer cases (including the original) #2 cost $4000 because it was just out of warranty. (#3 was covered by warranty on #2)
1 driver's-side window switch because the silver trim on the original started to de-laminate.
Overall, I was very satisfied with the Cayenne and expect to put many happy miles on my Macan!
LUV the white! Thank you for the detail about your Cayenne S. Impressive. Will be interesting (for both of us?) to see if our Macan Turbo's roll up the miles just as (relatively) dependably.
What were the primary reasons you sized down from the Cayenne to the Macan?
I'll play! (since I did the same....958 CTT to Macan GTS)
Pretty simple....my wife and I are empty nesters now and after having a Macan S and a Macan GTS as service loaners for extended periods when I had my CTT, I realized I just didn't need that much vehicle anymore. I still wanted some utility, and I really enjoyed the tidier package and the increased driving dynamics of the Macan versus the Cayenne, so the Macan was a great selection in my case (the PDK was a factor too, just wonderful!) Additionally my Cayenne had just crossed the 70k mile mark so I was looking to get something else soon anyway. I do miss the V8 TT torque on occasion, but I'd still do it all over again.
I considered both the Turbo and GTS Macan models, but in the end I preferred the driving dynamics of the GTS and my dealer had one in stock uniquely equipped as I would have ordered one.
I bought my Macan in September after enjoying over 180000 miles in my 2012 Cayenne S.
I averaged about 30000 per year on the Cayenne and it gave me very little problems but it wasn't perfect.
Here's what I consumed in 6 years::
5 sets of tires.(to be expected)
Fortunately my miles were mostly highway so I only needed to change brake pads and rotors once.
1 ignition sensor. It wouldn't start one morning so my dealer had to come with a flatbed truck and get it.
3 transfer cases (including the original) #2 cost $4000 because it was just out of warranty. (#3 was covered by warranty on #2)
1 driver's-side window switch because the silver trim on the original started to de-laminate.
Overall, I was very satisfied with the Cayenne and expect to put many happy miles on my Macan!
Is the transfer case a known problem in AWD Porsches? Three transfer cases in such a short time sounds really bizarre! (and bad!)
Did you do a lot of off-road driving, or other extreme driving that would put stress on the transfer case?
Is the transfer case a known problem in AWD Porsches? Three transfer cases in such a short time sounds really bizarre! (and bad!)
Did you do a lot of off-road driving, or other extreme driving that would put stress on the transfer case?
Not sure if the TCs on all AWD Porsches are problematic (I don't think so?), but they certainly are on the 958 gen Cayennes (2011-2018). My 2011 CTT had 2 additional ones installed in 70k miles.
Macans can have an issue with the transfer case, but I think it's a one time thing (I thought it only affected older macans but apparently it sometimes can affect newer models as well). Porsche replaced the transfer cases in question, but many owners found that changing the fluid resolved any issues.
Wow that's a lot of miles! Have you thought about just getting a 911? Gets around 30mpg hwy vs. 23mpg. Save you about 500 gallons of gas a year. Unless of course you need to haul a lot of stuff. Well, not even a lot as not much fits in the 911, ha!
I had a great experience with the Cayenne but I wanted something more sporty. As you can see from the picture, my wife drives a GLS450 so we have a tow and haul vehicle. The Macan PP has less room for passengers and stuff but is a bit better balance between an SUV and a sports car. The PDK is much more responsive than the Tiptronic.
12-14-2018, 11:17 PM
Drive 50,000 miles a year
