Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums

Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums (https://rennlist.com/forums/)
-   GT4/Spyder (https://rennlist.com/forums/gt4-spyder-235/)
-   -   718 GT4? (https://rennlist.com/forums/gt4-spyder/1033199-718-gt4.html)

Buteo 11-05-2017 10:46 AM

The Spyder spy shot and this GT4 shot look like they have similar exhaust/diffuser.

I know there was quite a bit of discussion in the spyder thread that it looked similar to a turbo car exhaust...I wonder if what we see here is in fact a turbo car.

ExMB 11-05-2017 11:04 AM

AFAIK both engines, T & NA, have been evaluated. This could be part of the exhaust outlet redesign. Maybe one was easier to redesign/modify than the other.

Regardless its interesting to note that the OP was asked to take it down whereas on a German forum, PFF, with a Porsche presence, no comment was made of such a request.

Buteo 11-05-2017 11:14 AM


Originally Posted by ExMB (Post 14582565)
Regardless its interesting to note that the OP was asked to take it down whereas on a German forum, PFF, with a Porsche presence, no comment was made of such a request.

Hmmm any guess to why that may be?

bk_911 11-05-2017 11:28 AM


Originally Posted by Buteo
The Spyder spy shot and this GT4 shot look like they have similar exhaust/diffuser.

I know there was quite a bit of discussion in the spyder thread that it looked similar to a turbo car exhaust...I wonder if what we see here is in fact a turbo car.

I think it probably is. A lot of people are hung up on this whole “the turbo six wont fit in the cayman” thing that was stated at some point. People forget a few key data points:

1) The first Gt4 had its own body in white. They could definitely do that for the second to fit a new engine
2) the first gt4 had a hand me down regular 911 engine
3) The 991.2 gt3 engine is special to that car. I’m sure they want to keep it that way. Why would they want to cannibalize their own sales?
4) GT4 is a “parts bin” car. So the exhaust pictured has only been used on turbo cars - the gt3 still uses the center exit design. It logically makes sense if you’re using he new 991.2 turbo then you would use the same exhaust.

I think now the possibilities are in this order:
1) Turbo 6 tuned between C2 and C2S spec
2) Turbo 4
3) GT3 detuned (unlikely)

No cleaning lady for me - this is my prediction based on the spyder and gt4 pics.

Buteo 11-05-2017 11:35 AM


Originally Posted by bk_911 (Post 14582615)
I think it probably is. A lot of people are hung up on this whole the turbo six wont fit in the cayman thing that was stated at some point. People forget a few key data points:

1) The first Gt4 had its own body in white. They could definitely do that for the second to fit a new engine
2) the first gt4 had a hand me down regular 911 engine
3) The 991.2 gt3 engine is special to that car. I m sure they want to keep it that way. Why would they want to cannibalize their own sales?
4) GT4 is a parts bin car. So the exhaust pictured has only been used on turbo cars - the gt3 still uses the center exit design. It logically makes sense if you re using he new 991.2 turbo then you would use the same exhaust.

I think now the possibilities are in this order:
1) Turbo 6 tuned between C2 and C2S spec
2) Turbo 4
3) GT3 detuned (unlikely)

No cleaning lady for me - this is my prediction based on the spyder and gt4 pics.

agreed. I'd be willing to bet they are using the same formula from the 981 GT4....Carrera S engine (larger turbo over standard) detuned.

With that assumption I'd guess power is 405 hp 355 lb/ft torque.

bk_911 11-05-2017 11:39 AM

Oh and the cloud of the morning got to me. Disregard my exhaust comment. It would have to be different I think because the obvious engine mounting position in the 911 vs the Cayman. I still think it’s the carrera engine.

ExMB 11-05-2017 12:40 PM

Everybody seems to be forgetting that homologation would require the same engine in the GT4CS as in the street version. Those with PMNA contacts (members posted on RL) seem to be pretty sure (have been told) that a detuned 4.0 NA from the GT3 will be in that one for the 2019 season.


Originally Posted by Buteo (Post 14582585)
Hmmm any guess to why that may be?

Who knows? Ignored? Not seen yet? Etc.

Pokerhobo 11-05-2017 01:53 PM


Originally Posted by bk_911 (Post 14582615)
3) The 991.2 gt3 engine is special to that car. I’m sure they want to keep it that way. Why would they want to cannibalize their own sales?

It's targeting two different segments. Many 911 owners wouldn't consider the Cayman. The first GT4 probably took some GT3 sales only because a manual wasn't offered in the GT3 which is no longer the case.

The GT3 engine is special to the GT dept. The GT4 comes from the GT dept. From economies of scale, it would make sense to reuse a detuned 4.0 flat-6 particularly since AP has already said that motor was modular.


Originally Posted by bk_911 (Post 14582615)
4) GT4 is a “parts bin” car.

Except for the custom wing, wheels, and (for the first gen) completely new rear suspension...

Viperguy324 11-05-2017 05:50 PM

This crap about "please take it down", is a load of BS. The car has street plates on it... The real protos do not get parked outside for every tom, dick and jane walking by to whip out their phone and take a picture.


Again, this is all fake news anyways... Someone will figure it out soon. This is nothing but a standard 718 with a bunch of test parts on it.

Archimedes 11-05-2017 07:27 PM

The near rear design of the 718 looks bad on its own, but it really looks bad when you add a wing to it.

Shockwave 11-05-2017 07:44 PM


Originally Posted by Viperguy324 (Post 14583368)
This crap about "please take it down", is a load of BS. The car has street plates on it... The real protos do not get parked outside for every tom, dick and jane walking by to whip out their phone and take a picture.


Again, this is all fake news anyways... Someone will figure it out soon. This is nothing but a standard 718 with a bunch of test parts on it.

Ive got confirmation that this is the real deal and a test mule. GT4 wing, brakes, wheels and diffuser is not just a standard 718 with a bunch of parts on it. Lol

TeutonicCarFan 11-05-2017 08:45 PM


Originally Posted by Shockwave (Post 14583565)
Ive got confirmation that this is the real deal and a test mule. GT4 wing, brakes, wheels and diffuser is not just a standard 718 with a bunch of parts on it. Lol

Did they confirm an engine :jumper:

James88 11-05-2017 08:53 PM


Originally Posted by Shockwave (Post 14583565)
Ive got confirmation that this is the real deal and a test mule. GT4 wing, brakes, wheels and diffuser is not just a standard 718 with a bunch of parts on it. Lol


Originally Posted by TeutonicCarFan (Post 14583664)
Did they confirm an engine :jumper:

Yes this one crucial bit is missing, can you ask if its NA or Turbo?

BryanCO 11-05-2017 08:56 PM


Originally Posted by Viperguy324 (Post 14583368)
Again, this is all fake news anyways... Someone will figure it out soon. This is nothing but a standard 718 with a bunch of test parts on it.

Im slow, please explain.

G-forceGT4 11-05-2017 09:14 PM

The back end of car in photo definitely looks 718, neutered, & very lame. Front aero nothing special for improvements. If a 4.0L NA in car, that will be the highlight. I'm keeping my GT4 b/c it already is something special.

When the overwhelming majority of auto journalists have raved about 981 GT4 along with Evo car of the year 2015, & people continue to refer to GT4 as parts bin GT car :confused:, they should watch this PCA video done by someone who knows a thing or two about P cars. S. Merali quote
"proper GT car"



All times are GMT -3. The time now is 07:07 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands