2016 Cayenne auto start/stop: ARRRRRRRGH!!!!
#31
Rennlist Member
Thanks Rennaissance,
So what I hear you saying is that my 2012 958 CTT is working flawlessly, actually better than most, since it does NOT shut off early in the warm up period.
AND, that since mine has "Memory", and thus it always stays as I have left it from the previous drive, that I ONLY set it to turn off when I KNOW I will be sitting at a very long light.
And so I LOVE it. Great technology. Gives me the CHOICE to save fuel when I want to.
(Btw, we have LOTS of long lights here in MD - In fact, these "smart lights" they have here not only capture your damn speed - which is a WHOLE NUTHA rant on our Gov't watchful eye,.. but the length of the light is dependent upon the time of day and take into account high commute timeframes, etc. One light when I come home from hockey games after midnight is over 5 min long!! - I usually go another longer route to avoid that one!!... anyway,... sidebarz ...)
=Steve
So what I hear you saying is that my 2012 958 CTT is working flawlessly, actually better than most, since it does NOT shut off early in the warm up period.
AND, that since mine has "Memory", and thus it always stays as I have left it from the previous drive, that I ONLY set it to turn off when I KNOW I will be sitting at a very long light.
And so I LOVE it. Great technology. Gives me the CHOICE to save fuel when I want to.
(Btw, we have LOTS of long lights here in MD - In fact, these "smart lights" they have here not only capture your damn speed - which is a WHOLE NUTHA rant on our Gov't watchful eye,.. but the length of the light is dependent upon the time of day and take into account high commute timeframes, etc. One light when I come home from hockey games after midnight is over 5 min long!! - I usually go another longer route to avoid that one!!... anyway,... sidebarz ...)
=Steve
#32
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
From the user comfort perspective, A-S-S may or may not make sense. Depends on your preferences.
From the fuel economy perspective, the effects are negligible. The restart itself is inefficient. The engine needs to be off for at least 16 seconds just to save the fuel that the subsequent startup will consume. Time your typical traffic stop interval - I doubt it lasts 16 seconds.
Now from the longevity point of view, the effects are also negligible IMHO. The auto start is far more gentle than a normal startup. The one thing to watch out for are auto starts at below normal operating temperature.
From the fuel economy perspective, the effects are negligible. The restart itself is inefficient. The engine needs to be off for at least 16 seconds just to save the fuel that the subsequent startup will consume. Time your typical traffic stop interval - I doubt it lasts 16 seconds.
Now from the longevity point of view, the effects are also negligible IMHO. The auto start is far more gentle than a normal startup. The one thing to watch out for are auto starts at below normal operating temperature.
Your prior comment about the 958 CTT exhaust noise at idle is funny as I just inquired with my service guys to determine if my muffler was shot!
I've also heard the complaint from drivers of the new model that the steering goes dead upon approaching a light. It's too bad the PIWIS can't change the programming option. It can on the 958.1's... though I can't imagine anyone would want it always reverting to the ON status, as the default on 958.1's is to remember the last setting used.
#33
Auto Start/Stop does not bother me. I've gotten the hang of modulating the brake pedal to kick the engine back on as the cross light goes yellow, avoiding that sudden jerk if you just hit the throttle. I also turn it off occasional in traffic, but prefer it to default to engaged. Just not a big deal for me. And in my 2012 it only engages once the Cayenne has come to a complete stop.
#34
Wow, I would die of slavery if I had to wait that long for a light. A detour is the way to go
#35
#36
I took my 2016 Cayenne to my dealer hoping that they could disable it as well. They say no way. I'm guessing that legality (from Porsche's perspective) plays a hand in this. Hopefully some propellerhead out there comes up with a hack. I drive mine in Sport mode all the time so I don't notice it all that much. But, it's still irritating.
It's interesting (to me) that the sales staff conveniently seem to forget to mention this before you sign on the bottom line. I found out about it after I left the dealership. It could be a deal breaker some folks.
Every new iteration of these cars loses functionality to the on board computers. They're taking some of the fun out of that's for sure.
It's interesting (to me) that the sales staff conveniently seem to forget to mention this before you sign on the bottom line. I found out about it after I left the dealership. It could be a deal breaker some folks.
Every new iteration of these cars loses functionality to the on board computers. They're taking some of the fun out of that's for sure.
#37
Guys, I'm a new Cayenne GTS owner and this drives me nuts as well.
I know the Jaguar F-Type guys were able to defeat this as follows: The F-type used a small battery, not the main battery, for the start/stop restarting. They simply removed the small battery which deactivated the system.
Anyone know if Porsche does it the same way?
I know the Jaguar F-Type guys were able to defeat this as follows: The F-type used a small battery, not the main battery, for the start/stop restarting. They simply removed the small battery which deactivated the system.
Anyone know if Porsche does it the same way?
#38
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
We at T-Design9.com developed a memory module for 981/718/911 cars. Simple plug-and-play installation. It remembers the important buttons (sport,A-SS, PSE) setting over restarts. But it's way beyond PIWIS setup that all the dealer can do. If there's a guaranteed demand interest from Macan/Cayenne owners - we might work on that next.
Vlad / T-Design9.com
Vlad / T-Design9.com
Start Car
Press the Sport Button (lowers the ride height and stiffens the suspension)
Press the Suspension Normal Buttom
Hit the ride height toggle to come up one level to Normal
So instead of starting the car and having to do 3 different button presses, I'd just like it to start in these settings. Ideally I wouldn't have to be in Sport mode either to have the transmission start in 1st gear, but I don't believe you can change since it's deeper in the vehicle system program.
Thanks and let me know.
#39
I'm not very knowledgeable about Cayenne at the moment. But I would guess 2009 is different from current model? I was thinking about current model, as A S S is the biggest problem for most people.
Vlad
Vlad
#40
We at T-Design9.com developed a memory module for 981/718/911 cars. Simple plug-and-play installation. It remembers the important buttons (sport,A-SS, PSE) setting over restarts. But it's way beyond PIWIS setup that all the dealer can do. If there's a guaranteed demand interest from Macan/Cayenne owners - we might work on that next.
Maybe I just need to know more about it, but on the face of it I'd rather not have the factory part messed with.
#41
I would love such an option, but from your website it looks like you are doing something to the existing button module rather than plug-in adapter somewhere on the CAN bus.
Maybe I just need to know more about it, but on the face of it I'd rather not have the factory part messed with.
Maybe I just need to know more about it, but on the face of it I'd rather not have the factory part messed with.
But the new module is straight plug-n-play. No messing with factory parts. Check the site again, I just updated it yesterday, because I just got them in...
http://t-design9.com/memory_module.html
If I only could find a test Porsche Cayenne/Macan in Michigan... Sometimes I don't see another Porsche for weeks!
#42
If I was in Michigan I'd be your test mule.
Try to get a diesel to test on too. We don't have the *** (what a great acronym!) feature and it would be nice to know the sport mode works.
As well as sport mode, remembering the last PSM setting would be nice too.
#43
I've seen calculations that state it is 3 seconds for the break-even point, not 16, which does include factoring in the fuel volume required to recharge the battery drain occurring during the stopped period. 16 is a lot and I'd imagine would negate any benefit.
Your prior comment about the 958 CTT exhaust noise at idle is funny as I just inquired with my service guys to determine if my muffler was shot!
I've also heard the complaint from drivers of the new model that the steering goes dead upon approaching a light. It's too bad the PIWIS can't change the programming option. It can on the 958.1's... though I can't imagine anyone would want it always reverting to the ON status, as the default on 958.1's is to remember the last setting used.
Your prior comment about the 958 CTT exhaust noise at idle is funny as I just inquired with my service guys to determine if my muffler was shot!
I've also heard the complaint from drivers of the new model that the steering goes dead upon approaching a light. It's too bad the PIWIS can't change the programming option. It can on the 958.1's... though I can't imagine anyone would want it always reverting to the ON status, as the default on 958.1's is to remember the last setting used.
#44
Racer
Brought my 2016 to the dealer to check for the brake pedal clip, and asked them to reflash the computer in case they made changes to the auto stop start. Now it has to be almost at a complete stop before it shuts down. Before it shut off at 4 km/hr which was really dumb.
#45
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Brought my 2016 to the dealer to check for the brake pedal clip, and asked them to reflash the computer in case they made changes to the auto stop start. Now it has to be almost at a complete stop before it shuts down. Before it shut off at 4 km/hr which was really dumb.
__________________
T-Design9 : Mods and ergonomic accessories bespoke designed for Porsche cars
Memory Modules : remember SC **** settings; A/S/S, PSE, Spoiler, Sport/+ buttons
Phone Mounts : keep your phone up and close and charged
Cupdholders, Sunglass Holsters and more at T-Design9.com
T-Design9 : Mods and ergonomic accessories bespoke designed for Porsche cars
Memory Modules : remember SC **** settings; A/S/S, PSE, Spoiler, Sport/+ buttons
Phone Mounts : keep your phone up and close and charged
Cupdholders, Sunglass Holsters and more at T-Design9.com