"Compatible" washer fluid? (Bear with me!)
#1
Nordschleife Master
Thread Starter
"Compatible" washer fluid? (Bear with me!)
Ok now this sounds like a dumb question.... but searches here and on 6speed show some results....
I first noticed this phenomenon with one of the first Cayenne service loaners I had.... seems Porsche uses a windshield washer solvent that, when mixed with the stuff you buy at the gas station, turns into almost a thick gel.
The dealer usually tops off the washer fluid, and it seems so long as I use the official Porsche stuff it's fine. All the loaners I've had, it's been 50/50 shot if the fluid that comes out is super thick... or normal.
So we've had CRAP weather lately. I got the "low fluid" warning... salty wet roads means I'm going through a lot.
Anybody know what I'm talking about - and has anybody found a washer fluid at a parts store that DOESN'T cause this to happen? I don't want to go to the damned dealer for a top-off, I'd rather hit Autozone or something...
But not if I'm going to wind up with thick slime coming out of the washer jets. The stuff winds up leaving a THICK crusty residue and makes a MESS.
I first noticed this phenomenon with one of the first Cayenne service loaners I had.... seems Porsche uses a windshield washer solvent that, when mixed with the stuff you buy at the gas station, turns into almost a thick gel.
The dealer usually tops off the washer fluid, and it seems so long as I use the official Porsche stuff it's fine. All the loaners I've had, it's been 50/50 shot if the fluid that comes out is super thick... or normal.
So we've had CRAP weather lately. I got the "low fluid" warning... salty wet roads means I'm going through a lot.
Anybody know what I'm talking about - and has anybody found a washer fluid at a parts store that DOESN'T cause this to happen? I don't want to go to the damned dealer for a top-off, I'd rather hit Autozone or something...
But not if I'm going to wind up with thick slime coming out of the washer jets. The stuff winds up leaving a THICK crusty residue and makes a MESS.
#2
Burning Brakes
I've been using the $5.99 for 2 at BJ's, Rain X stuff, here: https://www.walmart.com/ip/Rain-X-20...3=2660&veh=sem
No issues at all.
Before that, I was using the cheapest $1.50 per bottle jug of blue fluid I could get my hands on.
No issues at all.
Before that, I was using the cheapest $1.50 per bottle jug of blue fluid I could get my hands on.
#4
Burning Brakes
I had only been in twice, once to have a new hitch installed and the other time for the fix.
#5
I have no idea about compatability, but given the price of the P stuff, I'd drain the reservoir and system completely via whatever mechanism necesssary and refill with the el cheapo brand. If you must visit the dealer, top your tank off prior so that it's full when you go in.
#6
Rennlist Member
Wonder if the dealer is cutting their fluid with water or using mostly just a soap and water mix with no anti-freeze and what you're seeing is the "gelling" - slushing, really - from a mix of partial solution with anti-freeze (that comes as part of W/W fluid) and the water mix your dealer uses?
#7
Nordschleife Master
Thread Starter
Wonder if the dealer is cutting their fluid with water or using mostly just a soap and water mix with no anti-freeze and what you're seeing is the "gelling" - slushing, really - from a mix of partial solution with anti-freeze (that comes as part of W/W fluid) and the water mix your dealer uses?
I've read a few threads where it was said to not "mix" the Porsche stuff..... that the gelling is what happens?
I fear if I drain the system, fill it with el-cheapo... the first dealer service they'll top it off and I wind up with gelled goo. At 35k miles a year that's a lot of oil changes and chances for the dealer to top mine off.
Trending Topics
#9
Drifting
OmniGLH,
I use the following. The large bottle is the Porsche winter concentrate and the smaller one is M-B summer concentrate. One of the Porsche dealers in my area also owns a M-B dealer right next door to each other. They use the M-B and Porsche window concentrates in both makes...apparently they’re the same product, just labeled as Porsche or M-B. There’s a winter and summer formula which can be mixed without harm. The winter just has a lower freezing point, and I think the summer may have something in it that also helps with bugs. Both concentrates are to be mixed with purified water according to dilution ratios listed on the bottle. Both of these can be acquired at many online sources for less than most dealers charge.
I use the following. The large bottle is the Porsche winter concentrate and the smaller one is M-B summer concentrate. One of the Porsche dealers in my area also owns a M-B dealer right next door to each other. They use the M-B and Porsche window concentrates in both makes...apparently they’re the same product, just labeled as Porsche or M-B. There’s a winter and summer formula which can be mixed without harm. The winter just has a lower freezing point, and I think the summer may have something in it that also helps with bugs. Both concentrates are to be mixed with purified water according to dilution ratios listed on the bottle. Both of these can be acquired at many online sources for less than most dealers charge.
#10
Rennlist Member
I have no idea about compatability, but given the price of the P stuff, I'd drain the reservoir and system completely via whatever mechanism necesssary and refill with the el cheapo brand. If you must visit the dealer, top your tank off prior so that it's full when you go in.
I didn't use Porsche-branded stuff, it was messy out and the MFD was nagging me that the fluid was low so I just grabbed some stuff at the local hardware store. Haven't seen any signs of being gelled, just operating as usual. However, the last time I was in the dealer for an oil change it was still milder weather, so they probably didn't use the winter formulation.
#11
During my CD service I've watched the tech mix the Porsche fluid with tap water and fill the washer reservoir. Since taking over servicing the CD myself I mix the Porsche concentrate with distilled water. The Porsche fluid is supposed to help with wiper chatter. Of course at some services they didn't refill the washer fluid and I got the warning message by the next service.
#12
Nordschleife Master
Thread Starter
Ok I didn't want to wait for the dealer but with another Winter Storm Warning put up for this evening's commute I bought a bottle of the cheap stuff to get me through.
Seeing as how the P stuff is a "concentrate" I wonder if, for the past service loaners I've had, the dealer just got the dilution ration messed up and that's why it all came out super thick?
Will see how my P-stuff and cheap-stuff mix works out.
Seeing as how the P stuff is a "concentrate" I wonder if, for the past service loaners I've had, the dealer just got the dilution ration messed up and that's why it all came out super thick?
Will see how my P-stuff and cheap-stuff mix works out.
#13
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Spring Lake, NJ, US of A
Posts: 10,085
Received 1,140 Likes
on
758 Posts
It's possible the concentrate mixed with water had a bad reaction to the water used.. if they used tap water - hard to say what's in it. Distilled water is pretty much pure. Tap water - well - Flint Michigan tells that story..
#14
Rennlist Member
I'm guessing the recommendation to use distilled has more to do with avoiding any potential conflicts with the worldwide range of water conditions out there than any likely interactions.
Is there an MSDS sheet available on the winter concentrate?
Is there an MSDS sheet available on the winter concentrate?
#15
Rennlist Member
I've topped mine off with the winter formula of whatever was on the shelf at Walmart fro $3 and have had zero issues. In my life I got 99 problems but gelled washer fluid ain't one