Recall: Rolling away because of a bad bushing
#1
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Recall: Rolling away because of a bad bushing
Heads up, a buddy of mine saw this on carbuzz. Apparently a whole bunch of Cayennes and Panameras are affected. You can't search yet on the porsche site for whether or not you vehicle is, but I'm sure we will be able to search eventually. Use that parking brake for now!
https://carbuzz.com/news/your-porsch...assing-problem
Seems like a simple fix, wonder how long this one will take?!
https://carbuzz.com/news/your-porsch...assing-problem
Seems like a simple fix, wonder how long this one will take?!
Last edited by Travis; 06-24-2019 at 12:30 PM.
#2
#3
Instructor
From the NHTSA PDF:
Makes/Models/Model Years:
PORSCHE/CAYENNE/2004-2006, 2008-2010
PORSCHE/CAYENNE S/2003-2006
PORSCHE/CAYENNE TURBO/2003-2006
PORSCHE/CAYENNE TURBO S/2006
PORSCHE/PANAMERA/2011-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA 4/2011-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA 4S/2010-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA S/2010-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA GTS/2013-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA TURBO/2010-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA TURBO S/2012-2016
Makes/Models/Model Years:
PORSCHE/CAYENNE/2004-2006, 2008-2010
PORSCHE/CAYENNE S/2003-2006
PORSCHE/CAYENNE TURBO/2003-2006
PORSCHE/CAYENNE TURBO S/2006
PORSCHE/PANAMERA/2011-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA 4/2011-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA 4S/2010-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA S/2010-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA GTS/2013-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA TURBO/2010-2016
PORSCHE/PANAMERA TURBO S/2012-2016
#4
Transport Canada's recall notice (Much more readable than the US versions!):
http://wwwapps.tc.gc.ca/Saf-Sec-Sur/...s=1&rn=2019290
Essentially all V6 955's and 957's
For the V8 models only the 955's. The 957's seem to be in the clear.
http://wwwapps.tc.gc.ca/Saf-Sec-Sur/...s=1&rn=2019290
Essentially all V6 955's and 957's
For the V8 models only the 955's. The 957's seem to be in the clear.
#6
#7
Burning Brakes
Just from observations over the years, ...
Yes. It's about safety. Airbags exploding with shrapnel, rolling away in park, fuel fumes in the passenger compartment, etc. all can hurt people. Those get recalled. Both the NHTSA and the manufacturers place high value on human injury, which far exceeds costs of mechanical failures.
Mechanical problems that kill the car or require expensive repairs that are not dangerous are not covered.
There are some cases I've seen where a mechanical problem that is not directly dangerous gets recalled, and those tend to be justified by the fact that they might cause an accident due to failure while driving. For example, simple ignition switches - not going to burn the car down (probably), but if you're driving through an intersection and the car just dies due to the defect, and an accident results ... that would count. Gray area as to what defects count as being likely to cause an accident vs. not.
Once in a while there will be a civil legal action that leads to a settlement giving things like reimbursement for repairs or extended warranty. But those are rare. Bore scored engines could fit this category one day, and maybe should already, except I think it would be so expensive that Porsche will fight to the end rather than settle. When the engine in my 2004 S scored at around 47k miles in 2009, while out of warranty, Porsche was very generous with goodwill, when they did not need to be. The failed engine disappeared and was never seen again, taken away by black helicopters I think.
Yes. It's about safety. Airbags exploding with shrapnel, rolling away in park, fuel fumes in the passenger compartment, etc. all can hurt people. Those get recalled. Both the NHTSA and the manufacturers place high value on human injury, which far exceeds costs of mechanical failures.
Mechanical problems that kill the car or require expensive repairs that are not dangerous are not covered.
There are some cases I've seen where a mechanical problem that is not directly dangerous gets recalled, and those tend to be justified by the fact that they might cause an accident due to failure while driving. For example, simple ignition switches - not going to burn the car down (probably), but if you're driving through an intersection and the car just dies due to the defect, and an accident results ... that would count. Gray area as to what defects count as being likely to cause an accident vs. not.
Once in a while there will be a civil legal action that leads to a settlement giving things like reimbursement for repairs or extended warranty. But those are rare. Bore scored engines could fit this category one day, and maybe should already, except I think it would be so expensive that Porsche will fight to the end rather than settle. When the engine in my 2004 S scored at around 47k miles in 2009, while out of warranty, Porsche was very generous with goodwill, when they did not need to be. The failed engine disappeared and was never seen again, taken away by black helicopters I think.
Trending Topics
#8
A dead car is a safe car. Engine failures are a feature not a bug. Also replacing every engine that has had bore scoring issues would be enormously expensive. Much better that the customer just buys a new car with the latest safety features. They're just looking after you.
I bet all the while the dealership service advisers or technicians were claiming that your case was a freak occurrence and they've definitely never heard of this bore scoring phenomenon... I wonder what they do to the people that accidentally admit to knowing its a common issue...
I bet all the while the dealership service advisers or technicians were claiming that your case was a freak occurrence and they've definitely never heard of this bore scoring phenomenon... I wonder what they do to the people that accidentally admit to knowing its a common issue...
#10
Rennlist Member
No reason to get excited - Porsche's have been rolling away since the 80s.
The following users liked this post:
sweetskillsrk (11-01-2019)
#12
Instructor
Since I'm still learning things about the Cayenne correct me if I'm wrong here. Isn't the gear selector electronic and not a cable? Otherwise how would you be able to manually shift it with the wheel paddles or pushing forward/rearward on the shift lever (when in manual, of course)?
#13
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Spring Lake, NJ, US of A
Posts: 10,085
Received 1,160 Likes
on
767 Posts
Since I'm still learning things about the Cayenne correct me if I'm wrong here. Isn't the gear selector electronic and not a cable? Otherwise how would you be able to manually shift it with the wheel paddles or pushing forward/rearward on the shift lever (when in manual, of course)?
The following users liked this post:
J'sWorld (11-23-2019)
#14
Race Car
Still waiting 5yrs for an airbag on my Mercedes,
No updates on fuel flange fix from Porsche...sadly expectations and recalls seem to lack a sense of urgency. Sigh.
No updates on fuel flange fix from Porsche...sadly expectations and recalls seem to lack a sense of urgency. Sigh.
#15
Instructor
Ah, I see. That makes some sense. Otherwise they would just go with a **** like the new caddy's and merc's.