Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums

Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums (https://rennlist.com/forums/)
-   997 Forum (https://rennlist.com/forums/997-forum-113/)
-   -   Polyurethane engine/transmission mounts, YES or NO? (https://rennlist.com/forums/997-forum/799901-polyurethane-engine-transmission-mounts-yes-or-no.html)

Dubbin' 02-12-2014 01:06 PM

Polyurethane engine/transmission mounts, YES or NO?
 
Hey guys,

I was looking to stiffen up the engine/transmission in my 997S. Car is mostly a weekend street car with occasional track time.

Was thinking about the Torque solutions 75A (street) poly engine mount and transmission inserts.

What are your thoughts?

Thanks,
Mark

PhilD 02-12-2014 01:34 PM

I have the RSS mounts. Noticeable improvement in shifting. Car feels tighter all around and definitely feels tighter when cornering. There is a noticeable increase in sound and vibration in the cabin. I don't mind it at all and quite like it, makes it feel more like a sports car than a GT. At 1500 rpm and 3000 rpm there is a reverberation in the deck lid that is quite loud at times.

Overall, a good improvement, but if you like a nice quiet car it may not be for you.

Function-First 02-13-2014 01:19 AM

Currently, we offer the only Trans Mount Insert for the 997.1 Carrera 6-speed.

Fortifying the transmission mount will lead to enhanced shifter feel with greater accuracy, as well as keep the chassis settled under accel, braking, and cornering.

Check out our thread in the 997 forum to see some customer feedback and reviews:
https://rennlist.com/rennforums/showthread.php?t=782772

808c2s 02-13-2014 02:48 AM

When I added Porsche RS engine mounts, I was rewarded with a tighter chassis and back end. No longer is there slosh movement of the engine in off camber turn and tight corners. There was also noticeably more NVH from the engine, but not in an annoying way. More like what a sport car should sound and feel.

My next upgrade was Function First's transmission mount. Shifts were crisp and solid. Very accurate feeling and tight pattern. No loose feeling. But with this newfound shifting sensation, I was met with more driveline NVH; especially with the presence of my LWFW.

Bottom line, if you want a tighter chassis, as well as, more accurate and enjoyable shifting, and you can tolerate some additional NVH, then these components are for you.

Dubbin' 02-13-2014 09:17 AM

I can support the vibration I am more afraid of creating unnecessary rattles along the way. I dont think I would tolerated having interior bits rattling and shaking out of control. I guess its the type of mod you do, and then if you don't like it change it back I guess? Thanks, Mark

PhilD 02-13-2014 10:31 AM


Originally Posted by Dubbin' (Post 11130753)
I can support the vibration I am more afraid of creating unnecessary rattles along the way. I dont think I would tolerated having interior bits rattling and shaking out of control.

The mounts don't actually cause more rattles, but anything that is prone to rattling does rattle more at certain RPM, for me this is 1500 and 3000.


I guess its the type of mod you do, and then if you don't like it change it back I guess? Thanks, Mark
Yes, of course you can switch back to stock. If you do it yourself, you will just be out the cost of the mounts which you should be able to sell for not much less than you paid for them.

Dubbin' 02-13-2014 11:12 AM


Originally Posted by PhilD (Post 11130941)
The mounts don't actually cause more rattles, but anything that is prone to rattling does rattle more at certain RPM, for me this is 1500 and 3000. Yes, of course you can switch back to stock. If you do it yourself, you will just be out the cost of the mounts which you should be able to sell for not much less than you paid for them.

Hi Phil,

Thanks for the comments.

Is your car tracked frequently? Is it a DD or a weekend car?

Thanks,
Mark

PhilD 02-13-2014 01:05 PM


Originally Posted by Dubbin' (Post 11131085)
Is your car tracked frequently? Is it a DD or a weekend car?

No track time yet, but plan to get some in this year. It's a second car, but I enjoy driving it so much I find myself using any excuse to drive it. It gets its fair share of spirited driving on the street and a few autocross events.

The RSS mounts definitely make it feel more like a sports car and I prefer the feel, but they do come with the drawback of more NVH, although that is part of what makes it feel better to me.

Function-First 02-13-2014 05:23 PM

For those of you unsure about upgrading to the Trans Mount Inserts because of added vibration, we are now offering a softer version as well (70A hardness vs the original 80A hardness).

TRANS MOUNT INSERT

The Inserts are now available in two versions:
STREET (70A) for less NVH
TRACK (80A) for optimized performance

Myself and others daily drive with the TRACK version, but I understand that the threshold for tolerating added NVH is very subjective and varies from driver to driver. Hence, the new addition of the softer compound Inserts, which delivers performance benefits with much less intrusive NVH transfer.


We are also now offering the ENGINE MOUNT UPGRADE for the 997. Get the results of semi-solid mounts at a significantly reduced price point.

http://files.hgsitebuilder.com/hostg...mounts-red.png

Click the link for more information: http://function-first.com/products/e...-mount-upgrade



.

Dubbin' 02-13-2014 10:35 PM


Originally Posted by Function-First (Post 11132219)
For those of you unsure about upgrading to the Trans Mount Inserts because of added vibration, we are now offering a softer version as well (70A hardness vs the original 80A hardness). TRANS MOUNT INSERT The Inserts are now available in two versions: STREET (70A) for less NVH TRACK (80A) for optimized performance Myself and others daily drive with the TRACK version, but I understand that the threshold for tolerating added NVH is very subjective and varies from driver to driver. Hence, the new addition of the softer compound Inserts, which delivers performance benefits with much less intrusive NVH transfer. We are also now offering the ENGINE MOUNT UPGRADE for the 997. Get the results of semi-solid mounts at a significantly reduced price point. Click the link for more information: http://function-first.com/products/e...-mount-upgrade .

That actually does sound like a good alternative.

Have you sold any of the motor mounts yet and what are the reviews?

How resistant are the mounts seeing that they are taken apart and refilled with urethane?

Is urethane the same as polyurethane?

Thanks,
Mark

PhilD 02-14-2014 12:35 AM


Originally Posted by Dubbin' (Post 11133064)
Is urethane the same as polyurethane?

No, the scientific differences are quite in-depth, but poly tends to be harder than urethane, but urethane is more durable and will generally last longer under load and retain it's properties better.

Function-First 02-14-2014 11:28 AM


Originally Posted by Dubbin' (Post 11133064)
That actually does sound like a good alternative.

Have you sold any of the motor mounts yet and what are the reviews?

How resistant are the mounts seeing that they are taken apart and refilled with urethane?

Is urethane the same as polyurethane?

Thanks,
Mark

Mark,

Check out the thread in the 996 section (996/997 engine mounts are the same):
https://rennlist.com/rennforums/showthread.php?t=794188

There's an in depth review that fully explains the experience with the Engine Mount Upgrade.

The urethane fills all the empty voids of the OEM mount, and replaces the hydraulic dampening fluid, so the end result is a much stronger and durable mount.


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 08:56 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands