Oil leak at or very near oil filter (using LN engineering adapter)
#17
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
There are so many things and areas on all cars that can be dramatically improved with the aftermarket - the manufactures don't do them purely for financial reasons, as that plastic filter housing probably costs Porsche a quarter.,
#18
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
And not to get too personal but this is exactly why racers are not mechanics or mechanical engineers, necessarily
I am 99% sure that this was user error, meaning my mistake, versus the product purchased from LN engineering
I am sure if you are familiar with the company or been to the website you are well aware of their race scene heritage and background
I am 99% sure that this was user error, meaning my mistake, versus the product purchased from LN engineering
I am sure if you are familiar with the company or been to the website you are well aware of their race scene heritage and background
#19
You people are sensitive! As I said, not a knock on anybody or their products (LN is close to me and you can bet when my motor blows like it's supposed to as I have read on these forums, it's going to them for a rebuild). Again, just saying one should think twice. Introducing the opportunity for user error is the number one reason to carefully consider whether to add failure points to a system on a car.
#20
Actually, the racer in you should understand the value of a metal canister filter where a piece of track debris won't fracture it like it can a plastic one, and where each oil change uses a brand new filter instead of reusing the plastic case with a new element, that over hundreds of heat cycles becomes brittle as the esters in the plastic are evaporated out. And that's not to mention that the OEM design also incorporates a spring based bypass valve. As that spring ages and fatigues, how much of our oil do you think is actually bypassing the filtration and going through the bypass valve instead of through the media?
There are so many things and areas on all cars that can be dramatically improved with the aftermarket - the manufactures don't do them purely for financial reasons, as that plastic filter housing probably costs Porsche a quarter.,
There are so many things and areas on all cars that can be dramatically improved with the aftermarket - the manufactures don't do them purely for financial reasons, as that plastic filter housing probably costs Porsche a quarter.,
#21
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I can see an argument for the plastic getting brittle--so replace it. I'd be willing to bet that the chance of debris hitting the canister is less than the chance that user error results in a leak like in this case. As for the bypass spring--you tell me. How much flow is being directed? None? Some? Lots? Who knows, but I can avoid that concern by keeping up with frequent oil changes.
I think it is so I use the LN adapter like Rod does.
#23
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Ok. Finally got a chance now that the Holidays are over and visitors are gone, to tackle this “fix”.
Good news and bad news. I jacked up the car, took the old filter off and the LN adapter came off with it, which means I had to put the filter in a vise and use a modified spanner wrench to get the LN adaptor off.
Once I got it off, reinstalled it using the spec 18 ft lbs of torque. Lubed (with the oil) the seals on the adaptor and the new K&N filter. Cleaned the area fairly well with degreaser so I can tell where any new oil might be coming from if there is an issue.
Drove around yesterday and today there is another pile of oil on the floor.
Totally frustrated tonight I jacked it back up. The good news is that it appears to be leaking from either between the oil filter and the adaptor OR the adapter and the car. My guess is that it is the adaptor and the car since, when I went to twist it on, even though there was a seal, it didn’t feel like there was anything there, no resistance or tightness. Here are the pics that show that there is only oil coming out above the filter and not the engine (which is the good news)
now what? 🤔
Good news and bad news. I jacked up the car, took the old filter off and the LN adapter came off with it, which means I had to put the filter in a vise and use a modified spanner wrench to get the LN adaptor off.
Once I got it off, reinstalled it using the spec 18 ft lbs of torque. Lubed (with the oil) the seals on the adaptor and the new K&N filter. Cleaned the area fairly well with degreaser so I can tell where any new oil might be coming from if there is an issue.
Drove around yesterday and today there is another pile of oil on the floor.
Totally frustrated tonight I jacked it back up. The good news is that it appears to be leaking from either between the oil filter and the adaptor OR the adapter and the car. My guess is that it is the adaptor and the car since, when I went to twist it on, even though there was a seal, it didn’t feel like there was anything there, no resistance or tightness. Here are the pics that show that there is only oil coming out above the filter and not the engine (which is the good news)
now what? 🤔
#24
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Ok. Finally got a chance now that the Holidays are over and visitors are gone, to tackle this “fix”.
Good news and bad news. I jacked up the car, took the old filter off and the LN adapter came off with it, which means I had to put the filter in a vise and use a modified spanner wrench to get the LN adaptor off.
Once I got it off, reinstalled it using the spec 18 ft lbs of torque. Lubed (with the oil) the seals on the adaptor and the new K&N filter. Cleaned the area fairly well with degreaser so I can tell where any new oil might be coming from if there is an issue.
Drove around yesterday and today there is another pile of oil on the floor.
Totally frustrated tonight I jacked it back up. The good news is that it appears to be leaking from either between the oil filter and the adaptor OR the adapter and the car. My guess is that it is the adaptor and the car since, when I went to twist it on, even though there was a seal, it didn’t feel like there was anything there, no resistance or tightness. Here are the pics that show that there is only oil coming out above the filter and not the engine (which is the good news)
now what? 🤔
Good news and bad news. I jacked up the car, took the old filter off and the LN adapter came off with it, which means I had to put the filter in a vise and use a modified spanner wrench to get the LN adaptor off.
Once I got it off, reinstalled it using the spec 18 ft lbs of torque. Lubed (with the oil) the seals on the adaptor and the new K&N filter. Cleaned the area fairly well with degreaser so I can tell where any new oil might be coming from if there is an issue.
Drove around yesterday and today there is another pile of oil on the floor.
Totally frustrated tonight I jacked it back up. The good news is that it appears to be leaking from either between the oil filter and the adaptor OR the adapter and the car. My guess is that it is the adaptor and the car since, when I went to twist it on, even though there was a seal, it didn’t feel like there was anything there, no resistance or tightness. Here are the pics that show that there is only oil coming out above the filter and not the engine (which is the good news)
now what? 🤔
#25
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Did you reinstall the same filter or a new one? Just this weekend I did an oil change on my pickup and use K&N filters on all of my vehicles as they do pretty well in tests and I like the convenience of the bottom nut for wrenching it on and off. For the first time ever, my filter looked like yours with oil running down the side of the filter. The truck doesn't have a sandwich adapter like the 997 does, so I'm wondering if the seals on some of these K&N filters might have an issue. I never had this occur with the previous Mobil 1 filters. Before scrapping the LN adapter or trying a different one, I'd try a Mobil 1 M1-107 filter or the Napa Gold equivalent to see if maybe it's an issue with the filter. You can remove the filter and only lose the oil that's in it. When I installed the new K&N onto my truck, I added an extra 1/4 turn to see if that helps seal it up better.
#26
Seals and threads on the spin-on filters can be bad from the get go, many years ago when I raced motorcycles there was a manufacturer that made spin-on oil filters for bikes that had bad threads and seals from the factory lots, such that they kept blowing off the bikes at race speeds and injured people in the oil spill crash. Not saying this is your problem, but it might be.
#27
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Did you reinstall the same filter or a new one? Just this weekend I did an oil change on my pickup and use K&N filters on all of my vehicles as they do pretty well in tests and I like the convenience of the bottom nut for wrenching it on and off. For the first time ever, my filter looked like yours with oil running down the side of the filter. The truck doesn't have a sandwich adapter like the 997 does, so I'm wondering if the seals on some of these K&N filters might have an issue. I never had this occur with the previous Mobil 1 filters. Before scrapping the LN adapter or trying a different one, I'd try a Mobil 1 M1-107 filter or the Napa Gold equivalent to see if maybe it's an issue with the filter. You can remove the filter and only lose the oil that's in it. When I installed the new K&N onto my truck, I added an extra 1/4 turn to see if that helps seal it up better.
#28
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: Long Island, NY; South Florida
Posts: 4,114
Received 4,075 Likes
on
1,769 Posts
LN offered to replace that unit. I would do that. Keep eliminating problem areas one at a time. Also, clearly that adapter was not fully seated originally as you discovered, but the second time the filter came off without the adapter. Maybe that adapter is somehow not true/flat at the sealing point or the o-ring is counter-sunk too much somehow and therefore not making a good seal. Seems easy enough to swap in a new one.
#30
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
LN offered to replace that unit. I would do that. Keep eliminating problem areas one at a time. Also, clearly that adapter was not fully seated originally as you discovered, but the second time the filter came off without the adapter. Maybe that adapter is somehow not true/flat at the sealing point or the o-ring is counter-sunk too much somehow and therefore not making a good seal. Seems easy enough to swap in a new one.
No. It didn’t leak before I installed the adaptor and I don’t have a new filter for the OEM, so I don’t want to throw it back on there with the old, dirty filter. But since it didn’t leak before I switched them out, It appears that the OEM one is fine. I have a feeling it is the seal on the adapter. Like I mentioned, there was absolutely no resistance or “snug” feeling when putting the adapter on, which makes me think it isn’t being properly sealed.