Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums

Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums (https://rennlist.com/forums/)
-   996 GT2/GT3 Forum (https://rennlist.com/forums/996-gt2-gt3-forum-103/)
-   -   Tire Dilemma (https://rennlist.com/forums/996-gt2-gt3-forum/826360-tire-dilemma.html)

B Fett 07-27-2014 05:35 PM

Tire Dilemma
 
Well I had some some research and reading and decided I was going to use a set of Nitto NT-o1s on my 996 GT3 in 245/40/18 front and 315/30/18 rear. Unfortunately They are all sold out with no ETA on backorder from Nitto. I also can't go with a 235 front and 305 rear because the 305s are sold out.

I need tires because my stock wheels came with terrible Rossos on them and the Volks I have now are shod in a set of Michelin PSC's 235 front and 295 rear but they are shot, past treadwear bars.

So now I can either pony up the big money for a 235/295 replacement set of MPSC, or go with a set of Yokohama ADVAN A048's or Toyo Proxes R888's.

So what do you guys suggest who have used these? What size should I be looking at for each particular brand?

These will be used on a GT3 that sees some street use but this tire purchase is geared toward trackday stuff.

Thanks!

etchhead 07-27-2014 08:07 PM

I ran Hankook TDs (235/295) on my 6TT and thought they were pretty good out of the gate. Not sure their availability but worth a look.

AudiOn19s 07-27-2014 09:31 PM

Just get 235 nitto's. Despite me thinking I'm giving up front grip with the 235's vs 245's the data doesn't lie. There's very very little difference in grip there are two turns at my home track where I give up 1 mph the rest of the turns I'm not loosing any speed at all

This is on a 9" front wheel. And lots and lots of data with nitto's.

vtwin996 07-27-2014 09:54 PM

Where are you finding the Nittos? Also, I've run 235s before and can't tell the difference versus 245s in front. Is be happy just to get a set.

mooty 07-28-2014 12:13 AM


Originally Posted by B Fett (Post 11534935)
Well I had some some research and reading and decided I was going to use a set of Nitto NT-o1s on my 996 GT3 in 245/40/18 front and 315/30/18 rear. Unfortunately They are all sold out with no ETA on backorder from Nitto. I also can't go with a 235 front and 305 rear because the 305s are sold out.

I need tires because my stock wheels came with terrible Rossos on them and the Volks I have now are shod in a set of Michelin PSC's 235 front and 295 rear but they are shot, past treadwear bars.

So now I can either pony up the big money for a 235/295 replacement set of MPSC, or go with a set of Yokohama ADVAN A048's or Toyo Proxes R888's.

So what do you guys suggest who have used these? What size should I be looking at for each particular brand?

These will be used on a GT3 that sees some street use but this tire purchase is geared toward trackday stuff.

Thanks!

chk ur om
and yes 235 front is fine

rbahr 07-28-2014 12:48 PM

I run 235 fronts... Just fine

Ray

B Fett 07-29-2014 12:12 AM


Originally Posted by AudiOn19s (Post 11535282)
Just get 235 nitto's. Despite me thinking I'm giving up front grip with the 235's vs 245's the data doesn't lie. There's very very little difference in grip there are two turns at my home track where I give up 1 mph the rest of the turns I'm not loosing any speed at all

This is on a 9" front wheel. And lots and lots of data with nitto's.


Originally Posted by vtwin996 (Post 11535319)
Where are you finding the Nittos? Also, I've run 235s before and can't tell the difference versus 245s in front. Is be happy just to get a set.


Originally Posted by mooty (Post 11535609)
chk ur om
and yes 235 front is fine

Problem right now is that I can get 235 fronts, but the 305 rears are also out of stock.

So Nitto 18" 245's and 305's out of stock, national backorder.

I can get 235/40/18 fronts and 315/30/18 rears, would that work?

I know there is some measurement you have to adhere to to not confuse the ABS system right? What is the calculation needed for this?

*Edit * I might be able to get a set of 235/40/18 and 305/30/18, will that work correctly with the ABS?

rbahr 07-29-2014 07:47 AM

I run 235 / 315 with no problem.

Ray

AudiOn19s 07-29-2014 08:49 AM

the 305 rear is a 35 series...it's too tall for our cars, if anything that's the tire that will mess up the ABS. I know a couple here have stated they had success putting the 305 on the rear of their cars but my friend tried it and he's slightly lower than stock and the tire rubbed because of how tall it is.

235/40 is 25.3" tall
245/40 is 25.5
315/30 is 25.3
305/35 is 26.4

run the 235/315 combo you will be just fine. I do have data that shows the 245 is marginally better...but I'd venture to say it's worth maybe a couple 10ths a lap at best given my data and my car setup. Now if your car has a good bit of push in it already your car might suffer more than mine. I made no setup changes and it didn't really effect balance. My car is pretty neutral though.

fbirch 07-30-2014 01:37 AM

I have a set with low usage on them that I posted for sale a while back. I never did meet up with the fellow who was going to pick them up from me, and I never got around to re-listing them. My old ad is here:

https://rennlist.com/forums/parts-ma...t01-tires.html

AudiOn19s 07-30-2014 09:26 AM


Originally Posted by fbirch (Post 11540983)
I have a set with low usage on them that I posted for sale a while back. I never did meet up with the fellow who was going to pick them up from me, and I never got around to re-listing them. My old ad is here:

https://rennlist.com/forums/parts-ma...t01-tires.html

Dibs....you have PM

vu.q.le 07-30-2014 08:14 PM

Hankook

powdrhound 07-31-2014 04:26 AM


Originally Posted by AudiOn19s (Post 11538611)
the 305 rear is a 35 series...it's too tall for our cars, if anything that's the tire that will mess up the ABS. I know a couple here have stated they had success putting the 305 on the rear of their cars but my friend tried it and he's slightly lower than stock and the tire rubbed because of how tall it is.

235/40 is 25.3" tall
245/40 is 25.5
315/30 is 25.3
305/35 is 26.4

run the 235/315 combo you will be just fine. I do have data that shows the 245 is marginally better...but I'd venture to say it's worth maybe a couple 10ths a lap at best given my data and my car setup. Now if your car has a good bit of push in it already your car might suffer more than mine. I made no setup changes and it didn't really effect balance. My car is pretty neutral though.

For the last year I've been tracking 245/40/18 and 305/35/18 NT01s along with 245/40/18 and 315/35/18 V710s. Performs much better than the short 315/30 rears. No issues whatsoever with ABS. None, zero. Numerous guys in my area with some fast 6GT3s have switched to this combo and love it. If your offsets are right, you won't have any rubbing. I have no rubbing whatsoever even at 96/120 ride height. If anyone needs these tires, I have 8 sets of the NT01s and 5 sets of the V710s in my basement..

vtwin996 07-31-2014 09:06 AM

Powderhound. Thanks for the insight and you have PM. Thanks

rbahr 07-31-2014 09:16 AM

Hi Powderhound,

what is the difference/issue that you found with the 315/30's?

Thanks

Ray

powdrhound 07-31-2014 05:40 PM


Originally Posted by rbahr (Post 11543714)
Hi Powderhound,

what is the difference/issue that you found with the 315/30's?

Thanks

Ray

Compared to the 315/30/18, I found the 305/35/18 to have better grip and much less rollover. The 305 has a bigger contact patch due to the 1" larger diameter. It also has a higher load rating and a stiffer sidewall which reduces the tendency of the tire to roll over when highly loaded. I have been able to drop my hot pressures by 3psi running the 305 which further increases the contact patch. The larger rear diameter also gives the car a touch more rake. When I switched to these sizes (which are stock 997GT3 sizes) I had the rear of the car lowered a touch and the car realigned. Finally, the taller rear also improved my gearing which was helpful. Lastly, the byproduct of the taller rear is that it seems my speedometer now indicates accurately instead of a little fast as it did with the shorter rears. The 305/35s are a win win all the way around in my book. Pretty much all the 6GT3 guys are switching to these sizes in my area.

rbahr 07-31-2014 06:31 PM

Thanks.

To be sure I understand: the comparison is between the 305 Nitto and the 315 v710, NOT the Nitto 305 & 315?

Ray

powdrhound 07-31-2014 07:18 PM


Originally Posted by rbahr (Post 11544964)
Thanks.

To be sure I understand: the comparison is between the 305 Nitto and the 315 v710, NOT the Nitto 305 & 315?

Ray

No, the comparisson is between the 305/35/18 Nitto and the shorter 315/30/18 Nitto.

fbirch 08-01-2014 12:56 AM

PM's responded

promocop 08-01-2014 01:22 AM

OK, heres mine I'm about to pull the trigger on a 2010 GTS. The PPI picks up that the tires (near to new) are not "Porsche Approved N tires" they are Bridgestone PO2 Poetenzas . So what's the BFD? And are they good tires or should I make the dealer swap them out?

rbahr 08-04-2014 12:26 PM

There is indeed a difference. Might be subtle - and I am not positive ...

WRT the difference between the 305 & 315 - I just got off the phone with a Nitto tire engineer - the 305 does NOT give you a stiffer side wall - the higher load range is affected by the shorter side wall. My question was specifically dealing with potential squirm under load - the 315 will indeed have less due to the shorter sidewall.

This does not explain the differences you feel - that I cannot explain :-)

Ray

9.5 Degrees 08-04-2014 12:58 PM


Originally Posted by promocop (Post 11545743)
OK, heres mine I'm about to pull the trigger on a 2010 GTS. The PPI picks up that the tires (near to new) are not "Porsche Approved N tires" they are Bridgestone PO2 Poetenzas . So what's the BFD? And are they good tires or should I make the dealer swap them out?

the PO2 are fine. The marketing department at Porsche has perpetuated this myth that only N rated Michelin tires should go on P cars because those tires were used during the development of that particular model. Dealers are bound by contractual reasons for CPO to have N rated tires on the car when selling, but there is NOTHING wrong with other brands as you will see from this forum as well as others.

powdrhound 08-04-2014 01:00 PM


Originally Posted by rbahr (Post 11552811)
There is indeed a difference. Might be subtle - and I am not positive ...

WRT the difference between the 305 & 315 - I just got off the phone with a Nitto tire engineer - the 305 does NOT give you a stiffer side wall - the higher load range is affected by the shorter side wall. My question was specifically dealing with potential squirm under load - the 315 will indeed have less due to the shorter sidewall.

This does not explain the differences you feel - that I cannot explain :-)

Ray

Ray,
I ran the 315 for over two years. Probably went through 6-8 pair. All I can tell you is that the 305 does not roll over nearly as much as the 315 did and as a result I can run lower pressures with the 305. It "feels" like the sidewall is stiffer on the 305 which carries a higher load rating. For me, the 305 performs much better and provides more grip.

rbahr 08-04-2014 09:22 PM

WRT to 'N' rated tires.

There is a difference - but it is not well understood. Porsche does not advertise WHY they are better, or HOW they are better - just that they are different and better suited for the Porsche in question. I suspect that it is a bit more than marketing hype, and at the same time, I don't think the car explode if you run the non N tire - But behavior may be different at the limits...


One source is: http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tirete....jsp?techid=26

which does not help answer anything, but...

powdrhound: wrt the tire sizes, the ONLY thing I can think of that makes any sense is that you car sits low enough that when you strap on a set of the 315's and loose another .5" of height, you end up on a portion of the camber curve that makes your car not play nice, the additional height from the 305's may actually make the car a little better. If you were bored and had nothing to do and a lot of money to waste, I would suggest putting the 315's on and raising the rear ~.5" (and setting all of the other parameters as well) and see how that configuration works out...

In any case, it sounds like you know what works on your car, which is really the important bit of information...

Ray

powdrhound 08-04-2014 09:37 PM


Originally Posted by rbahr (Post 11554122)

powdrhound: wrt the tire sizes, the ONLY thing I can think of that makes any sense is that you car sits low enough that when you strap on a set of the 315's and loose another .5" of height, you end up on a portion of the camber curve that makes your car not play nice, the additional height from the 305's may actually make the car a little better. If you were bored and had nothing to do and a lot of money to waste, I would suggest putting the 315's on and raising the rear ~.5" (and setting all of the other parameters as well) and see how that configuration works out...

In any case, it sounds like you know what works on your car, which is really the important bit of information...

Ray

No. When I went to the taller rears, my ride height, alignment, and CB were reset to the correct values to account for the difference. I've tried various rake setting with the 315s prior to the 305s. Not sure why the 305 is better, but it is. The 305 carries a higher load rating than the 315 which may have something to do with it. It was much easier to overpower the 315 than the 305. The 305 definitely has more grip due to the nature of the larger diameter which provides a larger contact patch. It's beyond my pay grade, but I'm sure there is a reason why Porsche runs a taller rear tire on all the Cup cars (996 included) and why they switched to this set up on all the 997tt/gt2/3 cars.

B Fett 08-06-2014 08:22 PM

Alright so before I buy a brand new set...

Does anyone have a set of Nitto NT-01's in 245/40/18 and 315/30/18 new sitting around they can sell ME?

A used set in either 235/40/18, 245/40/18, 305/30/18 or 315/30/18 would work too, just so I can try these out and see how I like them.

Please PM ME, as if you post here the vultures will swoop in to buy before I even have a chance lol.

Thanks :)

powdrhound 08-06-2014 08:34 PM


Originally Posted by B Fett (Post 11559198)
Alright so before I buy a brand new set...

Does anyone have a set of Nitto NT-01's in 245/40/18 and 315/30/18 new sitting around they can sell ME?

A used set in either 235/40/18, 245/40/18, 305/30/18 or 315/30/18 would work too, just so I can try these out and see how I like them.

Please PM ME, as if you post here the vultures will swoop in to buy before I even have a chance lol.

Thanks :)

check ebay. I think there are a few pair of 235/40/18s floating around. Don't know about the 315s. 305s are readily available right now.

mooty 08-07-2014 03:06 AM


Originally Posted by rbahr (Post 11554122)
WRT to 'N' rated tires.

There is a difference - but it is not well understood. Porsche does not advertise WHY they are better, or HOW they are better - just that they are different and better suited for the Porsche in question. I suspect that it is a bit more than marketing hype, and at the same time, I don't think the car explode if you run the non N tire - But behavior may be different at the limits...


One source is: http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tirete....jsp?techid=26

which does not help answer anything, but...

powdrhound: wrt the tire sizes, the ONLY thing I can think of that makes any sense is that you car sits low enough that when you strap on a set of the 315's and loose another .5" of height, you end up on a portion of the camber curve that makes your car not play nice, the additional height from the 305's may actually make the car a little better. If you were bored and had nothing to do and a lot of money to waste, I would suggest putting the 315's on and raising the rear ~.5" (and setting all of the other parameters as well) and see how that configuration works out...

In any case, it sounds like you know what works on your car, which is really the important bit of information...

Ray

sometimes physics and paper calc dont work. you have to get the tire on YOUR car with YOU driving it.

some ppl are really fast on R6. i can match MY R6 time (after 3 hc) with my nt01 time. maybe just ME who doesn't like how R6 feels? i am 4 seconds slower with mpsc over RA1 or no-01. i just cant drive that tire. i can produce same lap time with 235 vs 245 nt-01 fronts.....

way too many variables...


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 12:24 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands