One Lap of America: Oil Conundrum
#1
Race Car
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Jacksonville, FL Duval County
Posts: 4,220
Likes: 0
Received 33 Likes
on
23 Posts
One Lap of America: Oil Conundrum
Considering the Tire Rack One Lap of America 2018. Based on past routes, we expect 6 tracks and ~3,300 miles, not including the travel to and from north Florida to the first/last event site. My 996 is a great dual-purpose car in that it is only lightly modified, and I've always kept up on maintenance so it's reliable. It's also pretty easy on brakes as the stock cooling is pretty good. I have IMS Solution as well.
If I run DT40, 3,300 street miles is no problem. However, I will overheat the oil on track and cause undue wear.
If I run XP9, the TBN will drop after the first or second day.
Potential solutions:
1. Find some mystery oil (Miller's Nano Drive? Motul 300V?) that can survive the whole duration of the trip.
2. Install an oil cooler and run DT40(not legal for my SCCA autocross class, so it would have to come BACK OFF after One Lap).
3. Bring a small tool/tire trailer full of XP9 and those TBN wipes. Replace XP9 oil every time the TBN drops, say 3-5 times, cost approximately $600-$1000.
4. Just drive my E39 M5 instead. It uses that 10w-60 and the rings fit so loose, it doesn't give a **** you just top it up with a quart every couple days. It however has crap brakes and goes through pads like nobody's business.
If I run DT40, 3,300 street miles is no problem. However, I will overheat the oil on track and cause undue wear.
If I run XP9, the TBN will drop after the first or second day.
Potential solutions:
1. Find some mystery oil (Miller's Nano Drive? Motul 300V?) that can survive the whole duration of the trip.
2. Install an oil cooler and run DT40(not legal for my SCCA autocross class, so it would have to come BACK OFF after One Lap).
3. Bring a small tool/tire trailer full of XP9 and those TBN wipes. Replace XP9 oil every time the TBN drops, say 3-5 times, cost approximately $600-$1000.
4. Just drive my E39 M5 instead. It uses that 10w-60 and the rings fit so loose, it doesn't give a **** you just top it up with a quart every couple days. It however has crap brakes and goes through pads like nobody's business.
#2
Three Wheelin'
Join Date: Jun 2016
Location: Toronto, north of the lake.
Posts: 1,554
Received 202 Likes
on
131 Posts
Maybe try to contact the posters on this thread:
https://rennlist.com/forums/racing-a...f-america.html
https://rennlist.com/forums/racing-a...f-america.html
#5
Race Car
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Jacksonville, FL Duval County
Posts: 4,220
Likes: 0
Received 33 Likes
on
23 Posts
The issue is the shape of the stock caliper M5 pad is rare, so your options are basically Hawk HT10s or Ferodo DS2500 or DS3500. I tried DS2500s and they melted a full 50% through on one testing day at track. I used the HT10s for Targa and while they do have enough temp resistance, they have too much torque for 200 or 300TW street tires AND they are really rough on rotors.
People used to upgrade the brakes with Stoptech calipers that had a wider range of available pads, however now that E39 M5s in driver condition are only worth 10-15k, doesn't make a lot of sense to drop $5k in brakes on one.
I think M5 on HT10s and bring spare rotors is a workable option.
People used to upgrade the brakes with Stoptech calipers that had a wider range of available pads, however now that E39 M5s in driver condition are only worth 10-15k, doesn't make a lot of sense to drop $5k in brakes on one.
I think M5 on HT10s and bring spare rotors is a workable option.
#6
I'd just take the M5 so I could push it on the track & pads are an easy update. If you take the 996, why not just take it easy & not go flat out for more than a few laps? Nearly all of the bad stuff happens once the oil is heat-soaked >230F.
#7
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Cool to see you participating in something like that! M5 seems like a great option with pads (and maybe some ducting to the front brakes). As for oil, I think you'd be fine with any approved fresh oil, especially since (I believe) you only get 3 laps per track don't you?
Good luck!
Good luck!
Trending Topics
#8
Race Car
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Jacksonville, FL Duval County
Posts: 4,220
Likes: 0
Received 33 Likes
on
23 Posts
Well I'm not sure how many laps you get but it's not a lot, so maybe regular oil would be fun.
Not going flat-out is not an option!
Im leaning back to M5; if even the Rennlist crowd thinks so then I say it's the best bet.
Not going flat-out is not an option!
Im leaning back to M5; if even the Rennlist crowd thinks so then I say it's the best bet.
#9
Considering the Tire Rack One Lap of America 2018. Based on past routes, we expect 6 tracks and ~3,300 miles, not including the travel to and from north Florida to the first/last event site. My 996 is a great dual-purpose car in that it is only lightly modified, and I've always kept up on maintenance so it's reliable. It's also pretty easy on brakes as the stock cooling is pretty good. I have IMS Solution as well.
If I run DT40, 3,300 street miles is no problem. However, I will overheat the oil on track and cause undue wear.
If I run XP9, the TBN will drop after the first or second day.
Potential solutions:
1. Find some mystery oil (Miller's Nano Drive? Motul 300V?) that can survive the whole duration of the trip.
2. Install an oil cooler and run DT40(not legal for my SCCA autocross class, so it would have to come BACK OFF after One Lap).
3. Bring a small tool/tire trailer full of XP9 and those TBN wipes. Replace XP9 oil every time the TBN drops, say 3-5 times, cost approximately $600-$1000.
4. Just drive my E39 M5 instead. It uses that 10w-60 and the rings fit so loose, it doesn't give a **** you just top it up with a quart every couple days. It however has crap brakes and goes through pads like nobody's business.
If I run DT40, 3,300 street miles is no problem. However, I will overheat the oil on track and cause undue wear.
If I run XP9, the TBN will drop after the first or second day.
Potential solutions:
1. Find some mystery oil (Miller's Nano Drive? Motul 300V?) that can survive the whole duration of the trip.
2. Install an oil cooler and run DT40(not legal for my SCCA autocross class, so it would have to come BACK OFF after One Lap).
3. Bring a small tool/tire trailer full of XP9 and those TBN wipes. Replace XP9 oil every time the TBN drops, say 3-5 times, cost approximately $600-$1000.
4. Just drive my E39 M5 instead. It uses that 10w-60 and the rings fit so loose, it doesn't give a **** you just top it up with a quart every couple days. It however has crap brakes and goes through pads like nobody's business.
So in your case, I would probably take an extra 10 quarts of oil and change oil at the mid-way point of your trip. Or if you're really only doing a few laps at each track, I might not change it at all.
Sacrilege, I know.
But seriously, if you're talking about spending $1000 on oil to run a few laps in an old car, I feel like it's time to take a step back and re-think the approach, which you are doing, so that's good. A One Lap experience should not involve a $1000 oil budget.
#11
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Ha, I'm with dkraige, it's a car not fine china... Besides, from my personal experience of driving/tracking dozens of cars, running an independent repair shop, being involved with PCA (and many other clubs), instructing, racing etc. if anything I would say that for the most part, you can take forum advice with a grain of salt. It's a popularity contest. Once somebody "respected" says something and it's repeated enough times, it becomes indistinguishable from fact. The only reason I'd do the M5 is I'd rather spend that amount of time on the highways in that car! I don't know how many dozens of track events I've done in lightly modified 996 C2s (and your 40th AE has much better cooling and oiling) without trouble. I wouldn't hesitate to do it in that car, I just think you'll be more fresh when it's all said and done in the e39 M5.
#12
Race Car
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Jacksonville, FL Duval County
Posts: 4,220
Likes: 0
Received 33 Likes
on
23 Posts
Yeah the 55gal drum of xp9 on a trailer was sort of a joke. I agree spending $1000 on oil is a little crazy for a week-long trip.
I think based on comfort, cargo, and the fact that I'm fine with me and a friend driving the dog-**** out of it, we are gonna default to the E39 M5 even though it is (comparatively) a pig on track versus the 911.
I think based on comfort, cargo, and the fact that I'm fine with me and a friend driving the dog-**** out of it, we are gonna default to the E39 M5 even though it is (comparatively) a pig on track versus the 911.
#14
Race Director
why have a 911 if you can't take it on a trip like this?
I'd run a good street oil, DT40 or M1 5w50, maybe bring 10 extra quarts and filter, and do one change.
I'd run a good street oil, DT40 or M1 5w50, maybe bring 10 extra quarts and filter, and do one change.
#15
Rennlist Member
Given how short your track sessions are I would run DT40 for the trip and forget about it. The main issue that requires use of XP9 is the high heat viscosity loss towards the end of a track session on very hot days. Probably not an issue doing 3-6 laps.