Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums

Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums (https://rennlist.com/forums/)
-   991 (https://rennlist.com/forums/991-221/)
-   -   Merc AMG GT vs 991 (https://rennlist.com/forums/991/833202-merc-amg-gt-vs-991-a.html)

k997 09-09-2014 06:01 PM

Merc AMG GT vs 991
 
I suppose being copied is the best form of flattery...

http://www.caranddriver.com/news/201...-and-info-news

IMHO there are very few cars out there that can best the 911. I certainly don't think the new Merc will steal much if any market share from Porsche.

Thoughts?

Cheekymonkeyman 09-09-2014 06:58 PM

More than a passing nod to the 991! The raised light tunnels at the front and an almost identically proportioned rear (try covering the bonnet up and looking at the silhouette from the A pillar backwards)
It also reminds me of the [dare i say] Chrysler crossfire?
I actually think it looks good and more purposeful than many other merc sports cars... And no doubt it will growl with the best.... But i wont spend 20 years wanting one...

eg991 09-09-2014 07:22 PM

Certainly looks very sharp. We'll have to see the reviews on handling and driving dynamics. Will it be a scalpel like the 911 or just a brute hammer like the C63 that goes like stink but doesn't really handle very well?

Noah Fect 09-09-2014 08:07 PM

Looks like a Viper. I don't like cab-rearward design, in general.

ipse dixit 09-09-2014 10:54 PM

Looks like a stretched BMW Z4.

chuck911 09-09-2014 11:03 PM

Butt ugly. Who cares if its a scalpel or a hammer if it looks like a turd?

kosmo 09-10-2014 01:15 AM

I hate long hooded cars on the track. Cant tell where the front end is. The 911 is particularly good at pointing its nose

onapex 09-10-2014 02:30 AM

I definitely think the AMG GT will steal some 911 buyers/owners. The F-Type R already has. In the $100K-$130K price range there was limited options for a 2 seater sports cars. Now there's 2. Both are more distinctive looking (for good or bad) and both sound better (virtual consensus). Overall performance and handling the 911 will still win. But for many buyers the distinctive looks and sound will tip the scale.

draxa 09-10-2014 06:53 AM


Originally Posted by ipse dixit (Post 11637176)
Looks like a stretched BMW Z4.

Yes, I agree; however, it will be an absolute cracker of a car, you can be sure of that.

The big issue will be the car's mass; 991S is around 1400kg and this more than anything will determine how the Mercedes drives (other than in a straight line).

I give you Jaquar's new F-Type which makes much of it's wonderful aluminium construction.....yet tips the scales at over 1600kg (the convertible even more). That car has eaten a lot of pies.......

BlackBeauty 09-10-2014 07:38 AM


Originally Posted by onapex (Post 11637465)
I definitely think the AMG GT will steal some 911 buyers/owners. The F-Type R already has. In the $100K-$130K price range there was limited options for a 2 seater sports cars. Now there's 2. Both are more distinctive looking (for good or bad) and both sound better (virtual consensus). Overall performance and handling the 911 will still win. But for many buyers the distinctive looks and sound will tip the scale.

+1

The 911 will handle better and be a better price point value (as crazy as that sounds), but it's another choice and even if they sell 5,000 cars, it's still going to take numbers away from PAG. However. Repeat however, competition generally does one thing....the future looks bright!!!

Porsche_nuts 09-10-2014 07:46 AM

From this video at least, seems boring --


draxa 09-10-2014 07:59 AM

Rear view is gorgeous - shows jag how to do it!

drcollie 09-10-2014 08:26 AM

The Porsche enthusiast won't look twice at that car. Wait a minute...yes he will....

First Look: "So that's the new Merc sports car?"

Second LooK: "Man, that sure is UGGLIIILEEEEEEEEEE"

991999R 09-10-2014 09:46 AM

very nice lines...i'm not sure how any p-car owner can look at this and say "yuck" seeing as how the rear cab of the vehicle borrows significant design cues from the 911...

mtbscott 09-10-2014 10:34 AM

I like the looks of the car....but the press release I read says base price is $122K for the GT and $142K for the GT-S. I realize you can run up the options on a C2S or C4S to those levels, but you can also get into a 911 starting at $84K. The Merc will really be competing more at the Turbo level of pricing and I think it will sell about as many units as the SLS did (which wasn't too many.)


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 05:13 PM.


© 2019 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands