Bob Z.

If it were me I would disregard the resale aspect and buy the one you like the most; however, if there are any doubts about either I would keep looking.

But if you asking, I vote for the 2-tone interior.

2016mwk4sporsche

I bought a black 911 4S from a guy in San Diego a few months ago, two tone interior and I love everything about the car. Everything, I live in Nor Cal but the 4S is an awesome car, lots of speed and control and its so much fun to drive. To each his own but the 4 S did it for me. and the two tone is great, not too hot in the summer and I have not had any problems keeping it clean. The all wheel drive is probably not necessary anywhere in CA but it is so much fun to drive. And 16K is nothing on these cars..... Good luck on your search....

Penn4S

It's really up to you. Both cars seem to check the right boxes for you. I assume you drove both and they are both to your liking. My opinion would be to look just a little more as the 2014's are coming out of warranty now and you should be able to find one with a fresh CPO. Always good to have 2 more years of warranty. If you don't find one you still have these 2 to pick from. Might also find one with less miles.

saeyedoc

2014 with CPO or other extended warranty. Two tone interior also means deviated stitching (at least in my car) which is really nice. Do they both have the same seats?

2007 9114s