View Poll Results: 5-Lug or Center-lock
5-Lug Wheels - no cost option
141
79.21%
Center-lock Wheels - no cost option
37
20.79%
Voters: 178. You may not vote on this poll
5-Lug vs Center-lock Poll
#61
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: West Vancouver and San Francisco
Posts: 4,186
Received 1,150 Likes
on
568 Posts
So tire shops won't be able to change the tires for you? I go through a couple sets a year.. So you have to take it to the dealer and buy the tires from them? I guess that means only the Porsche-approved tires? This just occurred to me as a major issue, anyone with any insight? Thx
#62
Rennlist Member
So tire shops won't be able to change the tires for you? I go through a couple sets a year.. So you have to take it to the dealer and buy the tires from them? I guess that means only the Porsche-approved tires? This just occurred to me as a major issue, anyone with any insight? Thx
i) Go to your Porsche dealer
ii) Learn the proper factory procedure, buy all the necessary tools including 4' torque wrench and huge breaker bar and prepare to get dirty... You pull them off at home, get tyre shop to fit tyres and then go home to re-install...
A word of warning: although virtually all tyre shops won't have the tools needed, if they do, they won't be familiar with the procedure so unless you're hoping to make a million hits on youtube for A lost wheels vid, DON'T let anyone touch them if they aren't intimately familiar with the procedure! Most guys with 997 CLs either get their dealer/independent race shop to do it or they do it themselves!
#63
Any tyre shop can fit tyres for you but you generally have two options for getting them off/on the car:
i) Go to your Porsche dealer
ii) Learn the proper factory procedure, buy all the necessary tools including 4' torque wrench and huge breaker bar and prepare to get dirty... You pull them off at home, get tyre shop to fit tyres and then go home to re-install...
A word of warning: although virtually all tyre shops won't have the tools needed, if they do, they won't be familiar with the procedure so unless you're hoping to make a million hits on youtube for A lost wheels vid, DON'T let anyone touch them if they aren't intimately familiar with the procedure! Most guys with 997 CLs either get their dealer/independent race shop to do it or they do it themselves!
i) Go to your Porsche dealer
ii) Learn the proper factory procedure, buy all the necessary tools including 4' torque wrench and huge breaker bar and prepare to get dirty... You pull them off at home, get tyre shop to fit tyres and then go home to re-install...
A word of warning: although virtually all tyre shops won't have the tools needed, if they do, they won't be familiar with the procedure so unless you're hoping to make a million hits on youtube for A lost wheels vid, DON'T let anyone touch them if they aren't intimately familiar with the procedure! Most guys with 997 CLs either get their dealer/independent race shop to do it or they do it themselves!
#64
Rennlist Member
You're right to some degree, they certainly were far from perfect in the early days... If one's car is being looked after by the motorsport techs, they should be right. For all their fk ups in the early days, most dealers have had enough exposure to CLs to get it right now... And if they don't, they have to warranty their work
I use the motorsport team for all work on my car at my local dealership. Only they or I remove wheels on my car. They've never let me down to date in this regard...
I use the motorsport team for all work on my car at my local dealership. Only they or I remove wheels on my car. They've never let me down to date in this regard...
#65
Rennlist Member
I know for a fact that people are taking their lives in their hands with centerlocks - and having been present at a Centerlock failure it's not a trivial issue - it endangered the drivers, a passenger and all the other cars on the track as the projectile (the former wheel) left the track and struck out on it's own to find it's bliss…it was pure luck there was no other damage.
Let's List the CL Pro's vs. Con's
Pro:
damm attractive - best looking wheels in the industry
Porsche says they are fine (unless used on track - in which case change them more frequently than your fluids)
Con:
list is too long and would exceed my monthly data quota to upload…
Let's List the CL Pro's vs. Con's
Pro:
damm attractive - best looking wheels in the industry
Porsche says they are fine (unless used on track - in which case change them more frequently than your fluids)
Con:
list is too long and would exceed my monthly data quota to upload…
#66
Rennlist Member
My dealer claims to match the best price on tires. So cost is not an issue.
Despite a post claiming otherwise, Porsche dealers know the proper procedure for CL wheels. The TTS has CL as well. I would prefer to trust the dealer on this important issue even if I have to pay a little more.
Despite a post claiming otherwise, Porsche dealers know the proper procedure for CL wheels. The TTS has CL as well. I would prefer to trust the dealer on this important issue even if I have to pay a little more.
#67
Rennlist Member
Last I checked the 5 drive pins are the same spacing as the 5 lug nuts. Can't one just remove the drive pins and use a regular 5 bolt wheel?
On the 996 GT3, the center CL bolt, which is just an extension of the hub nut, can be replaced with a regular hub nut and that is about it - converted to 5 lug.
Several years back I designed a CL wheel for my 996, used the GT3 CL nuts and done - CL on 996.
It was cool idea at the time (so I thought) and I was testing the design for my 962 street car project and hence after design, static load tests and then real world testing on the 996, needed to prove the wheel.
On the 996 GT3, the center CL bolt, which is just an extension of the hub nut, can be replaced with a regular hub nut and that is about it - converted to 5 lug.
Several years back I designed a CL wheel for my 996, used the GT3 CL nuts and done - CL on 996.
It was cool idea at the time (so I thought) and I was testing the design for my 962 street car project and hence after design, static load tests and then real world testing on the 996, needed to prove the wheel.
Last edited by CarManDSL; 06-08-2013 at 10:00 PM. Reason: smaller photos
#68
Rennlist Member
Correct myself.
Going from GT3 to 5 bolt also requires a hub flange change. This is needed to accommodate the threads of the 5 lugs. Still, a lot less $ than getting new CL wheels.
Going from GT3 to 5 bolt also requires a hub flange change. This is needed to accommodate the threads of the 5 lugs. Still, a lot less $ than getting new CL wheels.
#70
My dealer claims to match the best price on tires. So cost is not an issue.
Despite a post claiming otherwise, Porsche dealers know the proper procedure for CL wheels. The TTS has CL as well. I would prefer to trust the dealer on this important issue even if I have to pay a little more.
Despite a post claiming otherwise, Porsche dealers know the proper procedure for CL wheels. The TTS has CL as well. I would prefer to trust the dealer on this important issue even if I have to pay a little more.
Last edited by ShakeNBake; 06-14-2013 at 10:59 AM.
#71
Rennlist Member
gotta admit, that the centerlock issue is giving me pause regarding my GT3 on order for next year.
I definitely want to track it 5-6 times a year, and I would want to use R compound tires for my track days.
Looks like either I buy a bunch of tools and try to do it myself (having never done it before) or take a chance on my dealership doing it correctly each time and paying them hundreds to switch out my tires during the track season.
Definitely makes me reconsider just buying a 911 with powerkit or base 911 turbo, for which I can order the 5 lug wheels
I definitely want to track it 5-6 times a year, and I would want to use R compound tires for my track days.
Looks like either I buy a bunch of tools and try to do it myself (having never done it before) or take a chance on my dealership doing it correctly each time and paying them hundreds to switch out my tires during the track season.
Definitely makes me reconsider just buying a 911 with powerkit or base 911 turbo, for which I can order the 5 lug wheels
#72
Burning Brakes
Not having any experience at all with these I have no room to talk. But having watched some videos there seems to be just one tool to take them off and on. Either a long cheater bar or some of these torque multiplying tools seems to be all that is used. Procedure seems to be the key in that the locking mechanism correctly pops out and the nut is torqued correctly. Am I missing something?
#73
Burning Brakes
gotta admit, that the centerlock issue is giving me pause regarding my GT3 on order for next year. I definitely want to track it 5-6 times a year, and I would want to use R compound tires for my track days. Looks like either I buy a bunch of tools and try to do it myself (having never done it before) or take a chance on my dealership doing it correctly each time and paying them hundreds to switch out my tires during the track season. Definitely makes me reconsider just buying a 911 with powerkit or base 911 turbo, for which I can order the 5 lug wheels
#74
Rennlist Member
gotta admit, that the centerlock issue is giving me pause regarding my GT3 on order for next year.
I definitely want to track it 5-6 times a year, and I would want to use R compound tires for my track days.
Looks like either I buy a bunch of tools and try to do it myself (having never done it before) or take a chance on my dealership doing it correctly each time and paying them hundreds to switch out my tires during the track season.
Definitely makes me reconsider just buying a 911 with powerkit or base 911 turbo, for which I can order the 5 lug wheels
I definitely want to track it 5-6 times a year, and I would want to use R compound tires for my track days.
Looks like either I buy a bunch of tools and try to do it myself (having never done it before) or take a chance on my dealership doing it correctly each time and paying them hundreds to switch out my tires during the track season.
Definitely makes me reconsider just buying a 911 with powerkit or base 911 turbo, for which I can order the 5 lug wheels
You just need a means to lift the car, a breaker bar, torque wrench, gloves and optimoly grease from your dealer... Most importantly, just be meticulous in following the set procedure...
Most guys who track here do it themselves and there haven't been any issues here to my knowledge...
#75
I switched from a center-lock-equipped 997 GT3 to a center-lock-equipped 996 Cup car.
Oh boy, it is like 20 times easier and faster to switch wheels on the Cup (even without taking into account the fact I have airjacks now), and I only use a wheel gun to loosen, not to tighten!
Oh boy, it is like 20 times easier and faster to switch wheels on the Cup (even without taking into account the fact I have airjacks now), and I only use a wheel gun to loosen, not to tighten!