Owner's Review: 911R vs. 991.2 GT3 (Manual)
#226
Drifting
Thread Starter
OMG! How did you know I had a Civic back in the days? You're absolutely correct, I am just a pretender who takes pictures at owner's house. Please Mr. Brian, tell me how I can afford the Touring? How much down payment did you put down on your car so I can be just like just you and park it in a spacious two car garage?
I think this is a troll ... someone who take pics at owners house as sent a pic with a 918 so has access to the cars ... seems to know some cars details well ( maybe from YouTube ) but most stuff he makes up ... he definitely has not been behind wheel of the cars by his comments which are direct cut and pastes ... seems young Golf or Civic
#227
Burning Brakes
OMG! How did you know I had a Civic back in the days? You're absolutely correct, I am just a pretender who takes pictures at owner's house. Please Mr. Brian, tell me how I can afford the Touring? How much down payment did you put down on your car so I can be just like just you and park it in a spacious two car garage?
#228
Drifting
Thread Starter
I can't help it, I have so much to learn from Mr. Brian. I need to learn from him just how much monthly payment I need to save in order to afford a Touring like him.
Speaking of ACH, I'm planning to be there in the early AM to run with a few guys.
Speaking of ACH, I'm planning to be there in the early AM to run with a few guys.
#230
Drifting
Thread Starter
It depends on how long you will hold onto the car. If you plan on keeping the car a long time (eg. over 7-10 years), then the R value will appreciate whereas the Touring will stay relatively flat or depreciate. If you are just looking to keep it for a year or two, then it makes more sense financially to get the Touring, assuming you get it at MSRP.
I'd still take a 911R over a Touring. If i was worried about the track or track times, i'd get a winged GT3 or better yet an RS. Having said that - i wouldn't pay significantly extra to get an R (maybe 30K max).
So given that R's arent going to be down to $220 any time soon - my plan is to get a Touring.. when i have some time to drive it.
I'm not sure I'd try and make my touring look like an R though (No stripes or decals for me) . Just teasing.
So given that R's arent going to be down to $220 any time soon - my plan is to get a Touring.. when i have some time to drive it.
I'm not sure I'd try and make my touring look like an R though (No stripes or decals for me) . Just teasing.
#231
Smart
Last edited by Brian Himmelman; 05-18-2019 at 07:49 PM.
#232
Can make up all the BS subjective ... light feel here or slight rattle sound there but GT3T is simple the superior car period on a highly technical track ... it is not .25 sec in difference it is 2.5 plus secs ... I will take my car a true successor the 1967 race car
It depends on how long you will hold onto the car. If you plan on keeping the car a long time (eg. over 7-10 years), then the R value will appreciate whereas the Touring will stay relatively flat or depreciate. If you are just looking to keep it for a year or two, then it makes more sense financially to get the Touring, assuming you get it at MSRP.
buy the Touring
#233
I think this is a troll ... someone who take pics at owners house as sent a pic with a 918 so has access to the cars ... seems to know some cars details well ( maybe from YouTube ) but most stuff he makes up ... he definitely has not been behind wheel of the cars by his comments which are direct cut and pastes ... seems young Golf or Civic
#234
Micheal you are having too much fun!! This kind of stuff from Mr Brian is the exact reason I haven't been on the forums in a long time and don't participate in these RL discussions. Better things to do with my time. But could not resist on this, making assumptions about someone from an internet posting is just ridiculous. I do own a Porsche, but I also have a Toyota. Hopefully that doesn't put me in bad standing.
Last edited by Brian Himmelman; 05-18-2019 at 07:48 PM. Reason: .
#235
Race Director
Originally Posted by unotaz
I can't help it, I have so much to learn from Mr. Brian. I need to learn from him just how much monthly payment I need to save in order to afford a Touring like him.
Speaking of ACH, I'm planning to be there in the early AM to run with a few guys.
Speaking of ACH, I'm planning to be there in the early AM to run with a few guys.
#236
#237
With so many opinions, you should start a Porsche newsletter on design and values. You could be the next Alex Jones of print media.
#238
Drifting
The R and Touring are both great cars. Very similar but with substantial differences (if that makes any oxymoronic sense). Kind of like the Karate Kid: "Different but same." The R has the exclusivity factor. The Touring has the better engine. The R has the lightweight bits - hood, roof, door pulls, sticker badge, etc. The Touring has the no lift shift, if you are into that kind of thing. The R hits 200 mph. The Touring hits 198 but has the faster lap time. The R has (by all accounts, from what I have read) a street and B-roads focused suspension. The Touring's suspension is more track-focused. The R has the optional single mass flywheel. The Touring only comes with the dual mass flywheel. The R has the 991.1 exterior and interior. The Touring has the 991.2 upgrades (Apple CarPlay, aesthetically improved door handles, tweaked front and rear lights). The Touring has the Gurney flap (which I read somewhere that AP said it was a "lesson learned" from the 911 R).
I was fortunate to get a PTS Touring allocation (for a $10k ADM) which, to me, is worth more than someone else's throwback GT silver R for who knows what price over sticker? To be able to create a dream car to my exact specs is priceless. I will be the first to admit that I emulated (some would say "copied") the 911 R - light ivory (which was one of the colors of the original R), houndstooth seat inserts, 911 R carbon shifter - but I did so not because I want to have an R but because I appreciate the understated interior and exterior subtleties of the R and I wanted that for my car. As I have said in the past, if I could have an R or a Touring at sticker or at $10k ADM, I would take the R. Why? Because I am not a track rat and I would prefer a more street-focused car. But, although it is hypothetical, I wonder if perhaps I would be less likely to drive an R than a Touring, given its exclusivity? I fully plan on keeping the Touring forever and driving it until MY wheels fall off. At the end of the day, those of us who are lucky enough to have an R or a Touring are very lucky indeed.
I was fortunate to get a PTS Touring allocation (for a $10k ADM) which, to me, is worth more than someone else's throwback GT silver R for who knows what price over sticker? To be able to create a dream car to my exact specs is priceless. I will be the first to admit that I emulated (some would say "copied") the 911 R - light ivory (which was one of the colors of the original R), houndstooth seat inserts, 911 R carbon shifter - but I did so not because I want to have an R but because I appreciate the understated interior and exterior subtleties of the R and I wanted that for my car. As I have said in the past, if I could have an R or a Touring at sticker or at $10k ADM, I would take the R. Why? Because I am not a track rat and I would prefer a more street-focused car. But, although it is hypothetical, I wonder if perhaps I would be less likely to drive an R than a Touring, given its exclusivity? I fully plan on keeping the Touring forever and driving it until MY wheels fall off. At the end of the day, those of us who are lucky enough to have an R or a Touring are very lucky indeed.
#239
#240
Drifting
Thread Starter
Eating too much McLobster is bad for your health Mr. Brian
Not so hard on Michael please ... his back handed comments of only a double garage or financing payment or downpayment to buy a Touring were laughable and only in good fun ... he has no issues with insecurity over materialism “a few toys” lol ... he simply wants the world to know that his car is better than others ; ) Welcome back to discussion and enjoy your time well spent