NJRickD

There is a BIG part of me that wants to keep both but it also feels a little ridiculous to have two GT3s sitting in the garage. It would be an easier decision if one was an RS. I love love love my 997.2 so it would really hurt to sell it but I'm not sure I would ever choose to drive the 997 over the 991 once there both in the garage. Dealership offered me 95k (has 15k miles) so I would save a little on taxes if I turn it in but I'm afraid I'll regret it. Other option I'm toying with is trading the 997 for an R8 or possible a 570s. Both would obviously depreciate faster than the 997 (I believe) but would at least offer two completely experiences from the GT3. Always wanted a V10 R8 and the 570 is just badass. Certainly 1st world problems, but need to make a decision soon if I'm going to turn it in. (if it matters, these aren't my DD and I have an oversize 3 car garage that can comfortably hold 4 cars so space is not an issue)

gonefishin'

​​​​​

I've never owned an R8 but have a '17 570 which I bought new (stickered @ $230K) but it's probably a $170K car now given the 5K miles I've driven it.
Yes, they depreciate fast but the contrast you seek will certainly be there.

With regards to your 997.2, is it a 2011? If so, the dealer should be at $115K given the recent wholesale auction below.
2011 PORSCHE 911 2WD 2D COUPE GT3 6/15/18 $113,750 8,084 5.0 6G/6 BLACK REGULAR NORTHEAST PENNSYLVANIA

NJRickD

It is an '11. thanks of the info

gonefishin'

Get your dealer to raise your trade-in from $95K to $115K. Then, it's a fair offer.

FYI...

RennOracle

Trade it for a gt2, seriously, 996 or 997. Or get the r8. The plus holds money well if you get it 2nd hand. The biggest hit is from new.

Buddhamonk

robmypro

Riz

I am in same situation sort of. What is trade in/auction price on 2007 GT3 with 6K miles?

Crazy Canuck

I'm keeping my 996 GT3.

gonefishin'

Sorry not enough data points to make a reasonable estimate. Maybe others in the know can chime in. Maybe $95K? What are you thinking its worth?

Dr.Bill

I'd drive the 991 for a couple months, then decide which to keep.

tasman

997 and 991 different enough IMHO. I would agree with keep both for a bit and the trade for 570 or R8

On the other hand variety is the spice of life. Lol

Good luck. Nice problem
To have

bluehorseshoe

Don't do anything until you've had the opportunity to break-in your new GT3. Then decide.

gonefishin'

Good suggestion however OP might lose out on the immediate benefit of the tax credit. Could be worth $10K in most states.

Sunny_M3

Honestly, I'd just keep both for as long as possible.