Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums

Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums (https://rennlist.com/forums/)
-   991 GT3, GT3RS, GT2RS and 911R (https://rennlist.com/forums/991-gt3-gt3rs-gt2rs-and-911r-229/)
-   -   .2GT3RS driving impressions vs .1GT3RS (https://rennlist.com/forums/991-gt3-gt3rs-gt2rs-and-911r/1089858-2gt3rs-driving-impressions-vs-1gt3rs.html)

Waxer 08-12-2018 02:24 AM

.2GT3RS driving impressions vs .1GT3RS
 
Those who have seat time in both please tell us what you think.

fxz 08-12-2018 02:41 AM

at 8 minutes .2 GT3RS seat time compare
from Hanry Catchpole
https://youtu.be/w0d_AZbSLwQ

mooty 08-12-2018 02:50 AM

AC-Satco should be reporting soon

FerchoPorsche 08-12-2018 01:49 PM

while we wait for the GT3 RS comparison....
Anybody with seating experience on 991.* GT3 and 991.2 GT3RS ?
In the video in post #2, Henry sort of mentions that there is not much difference the GT3 and RS -at least engine wise-, and he seems to "prefer" the GT3...I believe that in that video, or another one, he said he likes better the steering feel on the GT3.

Those who took the .2RS to the track, any feedback ? How do you compare it vs other you've driven under similar conditions ?
On the street, does the new firmer suspension make it too hard/harsh ?

TRAKCAR 08-12-2018 01:56 PM

:corn:

fxz 08-12-2018 02:04 PM


Originally Posted by FerchoPorsche (Post 15210054)
while we wait for the GT3 RS comparison....
Anybody with seating experience on 991.* GT3 and 991.2 GT3RS ?
In the video in post #2, Henry sort of mentions that there is not much difference the GT3 and RS -at least engine wise-, and he seems to "prefer" the GT3...I believe that in that video, or another one, he said he likes better the steering feel on the GT3.

Those who took the .2RS to the track, any feedback ? How do you compare it vs other you've driven under similar conditions ?
On the street, does the new firmer suspension make it too hard/harsh ?

In the video Hanry talks about .2GT3 and. 2GT3RS
and yes he prefers, despite somehow embarrassed for that, the . 2GT3 over the .2 GT3RS!
no real power difference,
the steering is more planted (the .2 3RS lighter maybe bc track camber)
he didn t like the .1GT3 though

in summary from A real pro driver
.2GT3>.2GT3RS>.1GT3RS
sorry Waxer...
but i am sure that wing will impress everyone at Car n Coffee ...:D

FerchoPorsche 08-12-2018 02:12 PM


Originally Posted by fxz (Post 15210086)
In the video Hanry talks about .2GT3 and. 2GT3RS
and yes he prefers, despite somehow embarrassed for that, the . 2GT3 over the .2 GT3RS!
no real power difference,
the steering is more planted (the .2 3RS lighter maybe bc track camber)
he didn t like the .1GT3 though

in summary from A real pro driver
.2GT3>.2GT3RS>.1GT3RS
.....

Yes, that seems to be his conclusion, did any other owner share the sentiment ?

Waxer 08-12-2018 03:21 PM


Originally Posted by fxz (Post 15210086)
In the video Hanry talks about .2GT3 and. 2GT3RS
and yes he prefers, despite somehow embarrassed for that, the . 2GT3 over the .2 GT3RS!
no real power difference,
the steering is more planted (the .2 3RS lighter maybe bc track camber)
he didn t like the .1GT3 though

in summary from A real pro driver
.2GT3>.2GT3RS>.1GT3RS
sorry Waxer...
but i am sure that wing will impress everyone at Car n Coffee ...:D

Oh, my. I just can't win.....:surr:

All this time and effort to score an RS at msrp and spec it the way I like it and now it's its....I don't know. this is just not fair!!!!. I'm done! Anyone want my .2 GT3RS? If not it goes out with the recyclables immediately. :crying:

This is soooo frustrating. :mad:

Alas, that 6:56 seconds at the Ring now means nothing. :crying:

Jrtaylor9 08-12-2018 03:33 PM

Yeah, I think I'll give back my RS allocation now and troll for a used gt3.

FerchoPorsche 08-12-2018 03:56 PM

Are the engines exactly same spec ? (GT3 vs RS in the .2)
Where is the performance gain coming from ?, the extra 20HP... engine mapping or some mechanical ?
Is PDK exactly same as GT3 ?

Suspension stiffer, more downforce, wider body, wider tires (on RS)
Are brakes same wrt GT3 ? (The cooling is not)
Weight I think is same also. (The wider chassis got compensated with magnesium roof, plus some carbon fiber ?)

Any other difference ?

Waxer 08-12-2018 04:35 PM


Originally Posted by Jrtaylor9 (Post 15210269)
Yeah, I think I'll give back my RS allocation now and troll for a used gt3.

Jr: No, no, no. It's worth something for scrap I would think. Right???


reidry 08-12-2018 04:41 PM


Originally Posted by Waxer (Post 15210376)
Jr: No, no, no. It's worth something for scrap I would think. Right???

I'll give you scrap value, I'll wire the money right now :burnout: Wouldn't want you to be stuck with that worthless thing.

Ryan

reidry 08-12-2018 04:43 PM


Originally Posted by FerchoPorsche (Post 15210103)
Yes, that seems to be his conclusion, did any other owner share the sentiment ?

Do people really buy and sell cars because some Journalist says he likes one over the other? Ugh, what is happening to independent thought and will?

Ryan

fxz 08-12-2018 05:00 PM


Originally Posted by Waxer (Post 15210255)
Oh, my. I just can't win.....:surr:

All this time and effort to score an RS at msrp and spec it the way I like it and now it's its....I don't know. this is just not fair!!!!. I'm done! Anyone want my .2 GT3RS? If not it goes out with the recyclables immediately. :crying:

This is soooo frustrating. :mad:

Alas, that 6:56 seconds at the Ring now means nothing. :crying:

6 56 means something sure

IF only ppl would track their RS but majority
will pretend DD, Broads and Car n Coffee
and i agree with Hanry
. 2 GT3>.2 GT3RS unless you live on the ring

GrantG 08-12-2018 05:20 PM


Originally Posted by FerchoPorsche (Post 15210306)
Are the engines exactly same spec ? (GT3 vs RS in the .2)
Where is the performance gain coming from ?, the extra 20HP... engine mapping or some mechanical ?
Is PDK exactly same as GT3 ?

I believe Porsche that there is a 20hp advantage for the RS (they don't play games with this spec, unlike some others). But, this is 4% (and only at a small band of revs), so very difficult to notice the difference.

The last RS had 25 hp extra (5.3%) compared to GT3, but it also had 200cc more (5.3% also), so the advantage was there from idle to redline (not anymore).

While some people have posted evidence that there are many RS-specific part numbers, I have not been convinced that there is any internal difference between the engines (GT3 and RS). Seems purely a matter of side intakes rather than decklid intakes, BMC air filters (which also fit GT3), a Titanium muffler (don't know if simply lighter or better flow also), and a different ECU tune.

The PDK vs. Manual issue is not relevant for the way Porsche rates these motors (on an engine dyno outside the car), though in practice PDK does output less of its power to the wheels (more internal friction with wet clutches). And the ram-air effect is not relevant either (no wind on an engine dyno).


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 11:18 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands