Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums

Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums (https://rennlist.com/forums/)
-   991 GT3, GT3RS, GT2RS and 911R (https://rennlist.com/forums/991-gt3-gt3rs-gt2rs-and-911r-229/)
-   -   New GT3/GT2RS Leads With/Without ADM (https://rennlist.com/forums/991-gt3-gt3rs-gt2rs-and-911r/1032001-new-gt3-gt2rs-leads-with-without-adm.html)

audipwr1 02-04-2018 10:47 PM


Originally Posted by evilfij
In the US there is nothing prohibiting dealers from ordering GT cars for stock.

And why should consumers make the money - the dealers should it's a consumer good not an investment

bluehorseshoe 02-04-2018 10:49 PM

Pure Art
 
https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/rennlis...37682fcb3.jpeg
This picture is perfection.

Dr. Ferdinand 02-05-2018 12:42 AM


Originally Posted by Whoopsy (Post 14777468)
So they are going to have THREE!!! GT3s sitting in the showroom asking ADM.

A Dealer is NOT SUPPOSE to have even a single one sitting there as 'stock' car, all GT cars are suppose to be 'sold' customer cars. Each GT car is built to a customer, not a dealer.

Basically this dealer withhold their allocations from customers, entered bogus customer informations on them to get Porsche to build them 3 'stock' cars.

Another example of dealers, not VIPs are the evil entity.

This being Braman, just par for the course, sadly no shocker...

Whoopsy 02-05-2018 12:42 AM


Originally Posted by evilfij (Post 14777708)
In the US there is nothing prohibiting dealers from ordering GT cars for stock.

There is in the agreement between PCNA and the dealer.

Why do you think dealers had to resort to entering bogus information? If they enter a GT car in the system as a 'stock' car, that order will be deleted from the system.

Porsche required every single GT car made is a 'sold' customer order.

Most of the customers don't event know their name and information was stolen by the dealers to order cars. Only in very rare cases that PCNA catches those and contact the customer directly to ask about it.

A dealer once pulled this trick and ordered a 911R using a 918 VIP's information. The customer was too high profile hence PCNA caught it that time.

evilfij 02-05-2018 12:45 AM

I have seen two GT3 build sheets that say stock or demo or something like that so that can’t be right.

I agree using a VIP’s allocation (without permission) would be a serious issue.

ipse dixit 02-05-2018 12:52 AM


Originally Posted by Whoopsy (Post 14777890)
There is in the agreement between PCNA and the dealer.

Why do you think dealers had to resort to entering bogus information? If they enter a GT car in the system as a 'stock' car, that order will be deleted from the system.

Porsche required every single GT car made is a 'sold' customer order.

Most of the customers don't event know their name and information was stolen by the dealers to order cars. Only in very rare cases that PCNA catches those and contact the customer directly to ask about it.

A dealer once pulled this trick and ordered a 911R using a 918 VIP's information. The customer was too high profile hence PCNA caught it that time.

This is not correct. At least not in the U.S.

ChicagoWhale 02-05-2018 02:05 AM


Originally Posted by Whoopsy (Post 14777890)
There is in the agreement between PCNA and the dealer.

Why do you think dealers had to resort to entering bogus information? If they enter a GT car in the system as a 'stock' car, that order will be deleted from the system.

Porsche required every single GT car made is a 'sold' customer order.

Most of the customers don't event know their name and information was stolen by the dealers to order cars. Only in very rare cases that PCNA catches those and contact the customer directly to ask about it.

A dealer once pulled this trick and ordered a 911R using a 918 VIP's information. The customer was too high profile hence PCNA caught it that time.

This is completely and totally false. Every bit of it.

usctrojanGT3 02-05-2018 04:07 AM


Originally Posted by Whoopsy (Post 14777890)
There is in the agreement between PCNA and the dealer.

Why do you think dealers had to resort to entering bogus information? If they enter a GT car in the system as a 'stock' car, that order will be deleted from the system.

Porsche required every single GT car made is a 'sold' customer order.

Most of the customers don't event know their name and information was stolen by the dealers to order cars. Only in very rare cases that PCNA catches those and contact the customer directly to ask about it.

A dealer once pulled this trick and ordered a 911R using a 918 VIP's information. The customer was too high profile hence PCNA caught it that time.

Was this at a US dealer? Did PCNA punish the dealer for doing this? If I were the VIP, I would have sued the dealer.

Whoopsy 02-05-2018 12:07 PM


Originally Posted by usctrojanGT3 (Post 14778085)
Was this at a US dealer? Did PCNA punish the dealer for doing this? If I were the VIP, I would have sued the dealer.

Yes.

The customer moved the VIP allocation to another dealer.

PCNA also penalized the dealer.

There was also a settlement in there somewhere.

neurotic 02-05-2018 12:30 PM


Originally Posted by ChicagoWhale (Post 14777998)
This is completely and totally false. Every bit of it.


not sure who to believe. interesting story nonetheless

ChicagoWhale 02-05-2018 12:50 PM

This is totally false, as was your entire previous comment.

Dealers do not initiate the order for 918 VIP’s. If a 918 VIP wants to sit with the dealer to configure the car or make changes to his configuration, the dealer can do that. But dealers to not initiate the order. The scenario Whoopsy described is impossible.

918 VIP’s are sent an email directly from PCNA asking them if they want an allocation. If the 918 VIP says yes to PCNA, then PCNA puts a very specific allocation into the Electronic Handling Board (EHB) of that dealer. That allocation is specifically tagged as a 918 VIP order for that particular client — it originates directly from PCNA. The dealer then receives an email from PCNA that an allocation was just placed into the EHB for that client.

Dealers do not go to PCNA and tell them a 918 VIP wants a car, and then order a bogus car under that VIP name; that's not how the process originates.

While I understand you are a 918 VIP, I do not think you understand the internal mechanics of how the dealer is given your allocation.

Spreading false information does not help anyone here.

shapiroeric 02-05-2018 01:04 PM

All interesting stories but ChicagoWhale's seems to be a very legit explanation.....

Whoopsy 02-05-2018 01:45 PM


Originally Posted by ChicagoWhale (Post 14778774)
This is totally false, as was your entire previous comment.

Dealers do not initiate the order for 918 VIP’s. If a 918 VIP wants to sit with the dealer to configure the car or make changes to his configuration, the dealer can do that. But dealers to not initiate the order. The scenario Whoopsy described is impossible.

918 VIP’s are sent an email directly from PCNA asking them if they want an allocation. If the 918 VIP says yes to PCNA, then PCNA puts a very specific allocation into the Electronic Handling Board (EHB) of that dealer. That allocation is specifically tagged as a 918 VIP order for that particular client — it originates directly from PCNA. The dealer then receives an email from PCNA that an allocation was just placed into the EHB for that client.

Dealers do not go to PCNA and tell them a 918 VIP wants a car, and then order a bogus car under that VIP name; that's not how the process originates.

While I understand you are a 918 VIP, I do not think you understand the internal mechanics of how the dealer is given your allocation.

Spreading false information does not help anyone here.

:corn:

Keep going.

It's a Cali dealer is all I can say. And the customer is a well known figure. Actually quite a few on Rennlist knows about it too, it is quite well known among the 918 owners about this incident.

C.J. Ichiban 02-05-2018 02:06 PM

The car was a PTS RS ordered by a Bay Area Dealer. The VIP is CEO of a huge tech company. They race big boats. Dealer ordered a green car. It ended up at CNC. VIP did not know about the order and it was a big issue. Pcna issued a "you're kicked out" letter. VIP was flabbergasted.

VIP emails are sent to the VIP from David Donohue and to the Dealer GM. If the VIP does not respond, the dealer can try and work slimy ways to get it anyway. It's hard but dealers have done weirder stuff.

I could not get our VIP to accept the turbo S exclusive. He is getting a GT2RS however.

neurotic 02-05-2018 02:14 PM

del


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 01:14 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands