NOT a MT vs PDK Debate - Effect on MT driving of tech such as auto-rev-match
#16
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
In the 991.2, the experience is different than in the .1. Not sure where the GT4 falls, would suspect it mirrors the 991.1 since no rotary controller on the wheel.
991.1
Normal - no rev match
sport - no rev match
sport plus - rev match
991.2
Normal - no rev match
Sport - rev match
Sport plus- rev match
I don't drive my .1 in Sport Plus enough to know if rev matching is for me. I will say that it's super smooth and I've never had an issue. It's nice in that you can really modulate the brakes well instead of heel-toeing and having to worry about your right foot changing brake pressure as it rolls onto the gas. I should say that 1. I never knew how to heel toe until last year as I haven't owned a manual car in a long time and 2. At 6'2" and size 13 duck footed feet, my legs are not set up for vertical foot positioning. I sit with my toes canted out at the top, heels in....totally opposite what you want for heel toe. So while I can do it, I'm sure I'm not nearly as smooth as others.
I like the tech, but would be happier if there were a completely independent on / off setting. I'm not sure if this is one of the settings in the .2's individual mode as I've not driven a .2 MT.
I will say it's still more work / engagement / whatever than a PDK car. You still clutch and shift. Whether that's a good thing is up to you, but it's still more of a manual trans experience than closer to the PDK, even the PDK-S. Actually I should say especially the PDK-S because that baby is just SO lightning fast in its shifts it really throws into relief how slow a manual transmission is.
991.1
Normal - no rev match
sport - no rev match
sport plus - rev match
991.2
Normal - no rev match
Sport - rev match
Sport plus- rev match
I don't drive my .1 in Sport Plus enough to know if rev matching is for me. I will say that it's super smooth and I've never had an issue. It's nice in that you can really modulate the brakes well instead of heel-toeing and having to worry about your right foot changing brake pressure as it rolls onto the gas. I should say that 1. I never knew how to heel toe until last year as I haven't owned a manual car in a long time and 2. At 6'2" and size 13 duck footed feet, my legs are not set up for vertical foot positioning. I sit with my toes canted out at the top, heels in....totally opposite what you want for heel toe. So while I can do it, I'm sure I'm not nearly as smooth as others.
I like the tech, but would be happier if there were a completely independent on / off setting. I'm not sure if this is one of the settings in the .2's individual mode as I've not driven a .2 MT.
I will say it's still more work / engagement / whatever than a PDK car. You still clutch and shift. Whether that's a good thing is up to you, but it's still more of a manual trans experience than closer to the PDK, even the PDK-S. Actually I should say especially the PDK-S because that baby is just SO lightning fast in its shifts it really throws into relief how slow a manual transmission is.
#17
Race Car
Maybe it's different in the .2 GT3 - I've not driven one (obviously).
To the OP's question - yes, the rev matching eliminates any need for heel/toe.
#18
Assuming it's the same as the GT4 it renders heel/toe obsolete. It rev matches perfectly every time, I use it and feel it does not dilute the driving experience.
I've never seen anyone manually rev match perfectly every time.
I've never seen anyone manually rev match perfectly every time.
#19
Just a clarification on the GT4 sport mode- "sport" mode does not affect the center radiator per se. All 3 radiators are always active. The thermostat has a heating element in it. For sport mode the element heats up causing the thermostat to effectively operate the cooling system at a lower temp than normal mode. Driving in normal mode aggressively as in track driving will also activate the sport thermostat mode.
#20
Race Director
One thing cool about the Auto-Rev-Matching is that it can help you learn the right rev range/blip to use so you can do it better yourself. So I would think it would be useful to turn it on at the track (or on the street) for a while to understand it better.
#21
In the 991.2, the experience is different than in the .1. Not sure where the GT4 falls, would suspect it mirrors the 991.1 since no rotary controller on the wheel.
991.1
Normal - no rev match
sport - no rev match
sport plus - rev match
991.2
Normal - no rev match
Sport - rev match
Sport plus- rev match
I don't drive my .1 in Sport Plus enough to know if rev matching is for me. I will say that it's super smooth and I've never had an issue. It's nice in that you can really modulate the brakes well instead of heel-toeing and having to worry about your right foot changing brake pressure as it rolls onto the gas. I should say that 1. I never knew how to heel toe until last year as I haven't owned a manual car in a long time and 2. At 6'2" and size 13 duck footed feet, my legs are not set up for vertical foot positioning. I sit with my toes canted out at the top, heels in....totally opposite what you want for heel toe. So while I can do it, I'm sure I'm not nearly as smooth as others.
I like the tech, but would be happier if there were a completely independent on / off setting. I'm not sure if this is one of the settings in the .2's individual mode as I've not driven a .2 MT.
I will say it's still more work / engagement / whatever than a PDK car. You still clutch and shift. Whether that's a good thing is up to you, but it's still more of a manual trans experience than closer to the PDK, even the PDK-S. Actually I should say especially the PDK-S because that baby is just SO lightning fast in its shifts it really throws into relief how slow a manual transmission is.
991.1
Normal - no rev match
sport - no rev match
sport plus - rev match
991.2
Normal - no rev match
Sport - rev match
Sport plus- rev match
I don't drive my .1 in Sport Plus enough to know if rev matching is for me. I will say that it's super smooth and I've never had an issue. It's nice in that you can really modulate the brakes well instead of heel-toeing and having to worry about your right foot changing brake pressure as it rolls onto the gas. I should say that 1. I never knew how to heel toe until last year as I haven't owned a manual car in a long time and 2. At 6'2" and size 13 duck footed feet, my legs are not set up for vertical foot positioning. I sit with my toes canted out at the top, heels in....totally opposite what you want for heel toe. So while I can do it, I'm sure I'm not nearly as smooth as others.
I like the tech, but would be happier if there were a completely independent on / off setting. I'm not sure if this is one of the settings in the .2's individual mode as I've not driven a .2 MT.
I will say it's still more work / engagement / whatever than a PDK car. You still clutch and shift. Whether that's a good thing is up to you, but it's still more of a manual trans experience than closer to the PDK, even the PDK-S. Actually I should say especially the PDK-S because that baby is just SO lightning fast in its shifts it really throws into relief how slow a manual transmission is.
I also believe the accelerator map is changed along with the cooling temp ranges.
#22
One thing that I was wondering about that has not been mentioned here is that the MT gets a mechanical diff and the PDK gets an electronic one.
What is the difference from a performance point of view? Is the electronic diff a continuously variable unit that adjusts the locking ratio depending on grip/wheelspin?
Would this also contribute to the MT being a bit slower on track ?
What is the difference from a performance point of view? Is the electronic diff a continuously variable unit that adjusts the locking ratio depending on grip/wheelspin?
Would this also contribute to the MT being a bit slower on track ?
#23
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
One thing that I was wondering about that has not been mentioned here is that the MT gets a mechanical diff and the PDK gets an electronic one.
What is the difference from a performance point of view? Is the electronic diff a continuously variable unit that adjusts the locking ratio depending on grip/wheelspin?
Would this also contribute to the MT being a bit slower on track ?
What is the difference from a performance point of view? Is the electronic diff a continuously variable unit that adjusts the locking ratio depending on grip/wheelspin?
Would this also contribute to the MT being a bit slower on track ?
#24
Yes. You can turn on/off rev-matching in the GT4, but the damper settings are only Normal and Sport. GT4 experts chime in. I've driven one with and without rev-matching and appreciate both being available. It allows someone who is focusing on honing different aspects of their driving skills to minimize any unsettling of the balance by imperfect rev-matching, for instance on a wet traction circle when you may want to just focus on steering and throttle control.
#25
GT3 player par excellence
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
porsche rev matching is done extremely well in GT4
it can be turned off completely.
everyone can rev match but very very few do it right, and that includes many BIG name pro drivers. but just bc we do it wrong doesnt mean it's not fun.
it can be turned off completely.
everyone can rev match but very very few do it right, and that includes many BIG name pro drivers. but just bc we do it wrong doesnt mean it's not fun.
#26
Rennlist Member
Vivian
#27
Seems like I'm the only one enjoying the GT4's revmatching on the road.
Low speed town driving becomes so much smoother as the engine is always at the correct revs when the clutch is released after a gearchange - no jerks through the drivetrain and chassis.
I'd risk to say that in the very long run it might help with durabilty of the entire drivetrain.
Using it on track is a no brainer if you're after the times - impossible for anyone to heel toe with such precision every time. Just turn it off when you want to hone heel toe skills.
Low speed town driving becomes so much smoother as the engine is always at the correct revs when the clutch is released after a gearchange - no jerks through the drivetrain and chassis.
I'd risk to say that in the very long run it might help with durabilty of the entire drivetrain.
Using it on track is a no brainer if you're after the times - impossible for anyone to heel toe with such precision every time. Just turn it off when you want to hone heel toe skills.
#28
When yiu get to using revmatch, my own opinion would be just to go PDK. I think you are on the wrong side of fooling yourself that it's a manual if you are just dipping your left foot and pulling a lever. Save the foot, and just pull a paddle!
No issues if anyone disagrees obsiously, and as has been said, it can be switched off or on at will. ( Mine's not going on, ever...)
.
#29
Burning Brakes
I think Rev matching is a nice half way point between PDK and full heel toe. For anyone turning up at a track on the odd occasion, there is a lot to get back in sync and do safety / proficiently just for the day. I would envisage you could run a few sessions with it on and when feeling in sync turn it off. But would be nice to have it as separate button.
#30
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member