Is the 991.1 GT3 really not fast enough on track?
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Mid-Atlantic (on land, not in the middle of the ocean)
Posts: 12,438
Received 3,791 Likes
on
2,193 Posts
Is the 991.1 GT3 really not fast enough on track?
We have a lot of threads comparing the lap times of these cars, and I understand the attraction to ever faster cars. But having my GT3 at the track this past weekend reminded me that the car is pretty damn fast, and will be among the faster cars out there for years to come, even if sometimes not the absolute fastest (the faster cars I encounter are nearly always on slicks).
Given that it's not a race car, do any of you really feel that the 991.1 GT3 isn't fast enough? To the extent that going even faster is a strong motivation to replace it? Are we just addicts searching for a new high?
Given that it's not a race car, do any of you really feel that the 991.1 GT3 isn't fast enough? To the extent that going even faster is a strong motivation to replace it? Are we just addicts searching for a new high?
#2
Burning Brakes
Agree, fantastic car. This past Sat. at Sebring with Chin Open Track Day, my '14 crossed 20,000 miles with 7,000 track miles; E series engine is running like a top. Plan to run every month until the '18 arrives in Dec.
Great thread Manifold.
Great thread Manifold.
#6
Very fast, faster than my full bolt-on R35 GT-R on the track (but I also think I became a better driver).
But I've always said this of the car, an extra 25hp and this car will be a beast. Well, that's why I have a 991.2 on order!
But I've always said this of the car, an extra 25hp and this car will be a beast. Well, that's why I have a 991.2 on order!
#7
For street use the car has more than enough power. Any additional power would just be overkill and not utilizable.
For track use the car is very capable for the skillful and brave drivers. But for those less accomplished and timid like myself (despite many track days under my belt) we could use a little more power for overtaking on the straights. It's hard for driver's like me to pass 600 hp+ cars even if we can be faster than them on the bends. So another 50 hp would be handy on the straights to over take. So I will order the .2 gt3RS when it is launched if priced appropriately. Or perhaps I should just invest in driving lessons instead and start to take more risks on track.
And yes it is hard to keep up with the race cars on slicks.
For track use the car is very capable for the skillful and brave drivers. But for those less accomplished and timid like myself (despite many track days under my belt) we could use a little more power for overtaking on the straights. It's hard for driver's like me to pass 600 hp+ cars even if we can be faster than them on the bends. So another 50 hp would be handy on the straights to over take. So I will order the .2 gt3RS when it is launched if priced appropriately. Or perhaps I should just invest in driving lessons instead and start to take more risks on track.
And yes it is hard to keep up with the race cars on slicks.
Trending Topics
#9
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Mid-Atlantic (on land, not in the middle of the ocean)
Posts: 12,438
Received 3,791 Likes
on
2,193 Posts
I've instructed numerous drivers in this car, and frankly I don't think it's a good choice for a first track car. Just too much car for a newer driver, and the car doesn't really come alive until driven pretty hard.
#10
Burning Brakes
i was faster in my '15 GT3 vs. '16 RS at thermal. GT3 felt way more tossable and controllable at the limit; very confidence inspiring; was able to keep pushing and pushing. RS was more of a knifes edge that would bite hard and left me too tense to have confidence to keep pushing. IMO, 991.1 GT3 has just the right amount of controllable power with predictable handling.
Separately, I wish Porsche made rear-steer an option vs. standard on these cars. I don't like it; GT3 had it; but was much less intrusive and aggressive vs. the RS. none of porsche's racing cars have it. it makes handling at limit too dynamic and unpredictable. I would rather car be loose and predictable vs. tight and unpredictable. at least with no rear steer; there is no confusing rear kicking out with steering.
Separately, I wish Porsche made rear-steer an option vs. standard on these cars. I don't like it; GT3 had it; but was much less intrusive and aggressive vs. the RS. none of porsche's racing cars have it. it makes handling at limit too dynamic and unpredictable. I would rather car be loose and predictable vs. tight and unpredictable. at least with no rear steer; there is no confusing rear kicking out with steering.
Last edited by Laguna_Dude; 07-19-2017 at 03:03 AM.
#12
Three Wheelin'
For street use the car has more than enough power. Any additional power would just be overkill and not utilizable.
For track use the car is very capable for the skillful and brave drivers. But for those less accomplished and timid like myself (despite many track days under my belt) we could use a little more power for overtaking on the straights. It's hard for driver's like me to pass 600 hp+ cars even if we can be faster than them on the bends. So another 50 hp would be handy on the straights to over take. So I will order the .2 gt3RS when it is launched if priced appropriately. Or perhaps I should just invest in driving lessons instead and start to take more risks on track.
And yes it is hard to keep up with the race cars on slicks.
For track use the car is very capable for the skillful and brave drivers. But for those less accomplished and timid like myself (despite many track days under my belt) we could use a little more power for overtaking on the straights. It's hard for driver's like me to pass 600 hp+ cars even if we can be faster than them on the bends. So another 50 hp would be handy on the straights to over take. So I will order the .2 gt3RS when it is launched if priced appropriately. Or perhaps I should just invest in driving lessons instead and start to take more risks on track.
And yes it is hard to keep up with the race cars on slicks.
#14
At the end of the day, the car is only as fast as the driver and fast drivers have a lot of seat time and additional coaching.
Its always great to operate fine tools (and the 991.1 GT3 is a fine tool in most respects) - however, "miles makes champions" or "the driver makes the car rather than the car makes the driver".
The truth is, probably, the GT3 is way more capable than 99% of the owners and smart owners would/should be well aware of this. If they're smart they will seek out track time and coaching and build pace in relation to experience. However, there is always the point that you may get to where you go beyond the feathering limit of the tires and bin the car.
Understanding this limit and being able to feel it in ALL conditions means you have reached the limit of your abilities, which may or may not match that of the car
On another note, the problem with fast cars is, if you do track them a lot, you get very speed desensitised - so in that regard fast cars are like a drug (if you use them regularly as fast cars), what is particularly addictive is high corner Vmin (e.g loads of lateral grip) and the punch in the 80kmh - 240kmh range. The cars that deliver this in spades are the ultimate drug of choice.
What I personally find odd, are the buyers who never use the car for its intended purpose. I have a very good friend who has a beautiful white 991GT3RS - it has been to the track once - he called it an "unnerving experience". His whole reason for buying the GT3RS was because he thought it was a beautiful design - when he told me that, I was little surprised but ultimately got his perspective. Because it is design and beauty in motion. Each to their own
Its always great to operate fine tools (and the 991.1 GT3 is a fine tool in most respects) - however, "miles makes champions" or "the driver makes the car rather than the car makes the driver".
The truth is, probably, the GT3 is way more capable than 99% of the owners and smart owners would/should be well aware of this. If they're smart they will seek out track time and coaching and build pace in relation to experience. However, there is always the point that you may get to where you go beyond the feathering limit of the tires and bin the car.
Understanding this limit and being able to feel it in ALL conditions means you have reached the limit of your abilities, which may or may not match that of the car
On another note, the problem with fast cars is, if you do track them a lot, you get very speed desensitised - so in that regard fast cars are like a drug (if you use them regularly as fast cars), what is particularly addictive is high corner Vmin (e.g loads of lateral grip) and the punch in the 80kmh - 240kmh range. The cars that deliver this in spades are the ultimate drug of choice.
What I personally find odd, are the buyers who never use the car for its intended purpose. I have a very good friend who has a beautiful white 991GT3RS - it has been to the track once - he called it an "unnerving experience". His whole reason for buying the GT3RS was because he thought it was a beautiful design - when he told me that, I was little surprised but ultimately got his perspective. Because it is design and beauty in motion. Each to their own
Last edited by randr; 07-18-2017 at 10:45 PM.