Should I buy this 987.1 Cayman S or not?
#1
Instructor
Thread Starter
Should I buy this 987.1 Cayman S or not?
Hi
Looked at this one:
https://www.autoscout24.ch/de/d/porsche-cayman-coupe-2008-occasion?vehid=5757497&eh=58a98e52b741933c64c8050d0cc347b37c67f6e775eb59 904e198c9886b5aa86&utm_source=as24-systemmail&utm_medium=email&utm_term=vehicle&utm_content=de&utm_campaign =SearchJobNotification
Negotiated it down to CHF 23'000, PPI would be next if I pursue. I'm worried about the condition of the car, especially the corrosion. What do you think?
Looked at this one:
https://www.autoscout24.ch/de/d/porsche-cayman-coupe-2008-occasion?vehid=5757497&eh=58a98e52b741933c64c8050d0cc347b37c67f6e775eb59 904e198c9886b5aa86&utm_source=as24-systemmail&utm_medium=email&utm_term=vehicle&utm_content=de&utm_campaign =SearchJobNotification
Negotiated it down to CHF 23'000, PPI would be next if I pursue. I'm worried about the condition of the car, especially the corrosion. What do you think?
#2
If you can afford to spend a little bit more, I would consider that you continue looking. I just bought a 2006 Cayman S for $31,500 which I thought was too expensive but the fact that the car was in mint condition with 23k miles on it made it worth it to me. When I look at your photos with chips in the paint, rusty bolts, and corosion on the wheels, I compare to my situation and I believe it would cost more to fix those items than the premium price I paid. In addition, there may be issues that you haven't noticed. It looks to me like that car spent time at the coast or somewhere where rust occurs easily.
Just my $0.02
Just my $0.02
#5
Drifting
But also considers the context that in Europe, a lot of people don't drive, and if they do is a little 3-door hatch. Switzerland is one of the most expensive countries in Europe and any used Cayman is rare to find compare to North America.
#6
In the US where these cars are easy to find, this would be a hard sell in its condition. The car has 78,000 miles (had to convert) and priced at about 23,000 USD. For a car in good shape a fair price in the US might be 27K or so. Given the climate, I don't know what the roads and weather do to cars there. If surface corrosion on the undercarriage and paint/wheel chips are part of the environment, then the car might be worthwhile with a good PPI and service records. Most of the flaws pictured can be remedied with some serious detailing and touchups. If this is not typical wear, the I would be concerned about the level of maintenance on the car and would pass.
#7
Rennlist Member
Yep, like I said I don't know the market, but would shy away from this in the US.
Trending Topics
#8
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Looks to me like the prior owner drove the car the way it was intended to be driven. Kudos to the prior owner, he/she is much tougher than me. I am too much of a wuss to let my Cayman get wet or dirty.
#9
Rennlist Member
Drove it that way, maybe, but did not care for it to compensate. Looks like some winter (salty) miles. That requires some serious cleaning.
#10
Do they have service records to go along with the vehicle? Was the oil changed diligently every 5K or so miles? While I agree that the car has been "driven", and look at that as a positive sign, I also have a thought that maybe this person just drove it and did not think about maintenance. Some of the issues you point out would not be on a car that's owned by an enthusiast. Rusty lug nuts? An enthusiast would purchase new ones, or paint the current ones. I'd be willing to bet that there's a maintenance backlog that has to be completed. However, if the maintenance is up to date, and oil changes were done within a timely interval. don't worry about the cosmetics and just enjoy the car.
#11
Race Director
Unless you are one of those guys that need a pristine car, this looks fine to me. As long as it was maintained, the dirt and little surface rust is no biggie. The bulk of that will easily clean up and then you'll have a great car.
#12
Burning Brakes
The cosmetic flaws in the pics are not expensive to deal with.
I would not dismiss the car and get a PPI. If that reveals no issues, then you have an example that can be enjoyed with peace of mind. And if the cosmetics bother you, get them taken care of.
This car was possibly enjoyed in winter weather, leading to the surface rust.
I would not dismiss the car and get a PPI. If that reveals no issues, then you have an example that can be enjoyed with peace of mind. And if the cosmetics bother you, get them taken care of.
This car was possibly enjoyed in winter weather, leading to the surface rust.
#13
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Do they have service records to go along with the vehicle? Was the oil changed diligently every 5K or so miles? While I agree that the car has been "driven", and look at that as a positive sign, I also have a thought that maybe this person just drove it and did not think about maintenance. Some of the issues you point out would not be on a car that's owned by an enthusiast. Rusty lug nuts? An enthusiast would purchase new ones, or paint the current ones. I'd be willing to bet that there's a maintenance backlog that has to be completed. However, if the maintenance is up to date, and oil changes were done within a timely interval. don't worry about the cosmetics and just enjoy the car.
Wait, does a Cayman have lug nuts? An real enthusiast would know that.