Rob's GTS engine pull
#181
Three Wheelin'
Not sure whether this link will work (it made me wait for 10 seconds...) but the discussion there is typically obsessive arguing back and forth about the originality (or not) of the broach patterns on the stamp pad of Chevy motors. Some people take their engine serial numbers very seriously, when 'matching numbers' becomes a five figures issue:
http://www.ncrs.org/forums/archive/i...p/t-67588.html
http://www.ncrs.org/forums/archive/i...p/t-67588.html
#182
Rennlist Member
How many pieces you want to cut? I can quickly think of four different things in any 928 block which all must be either exactly right or in correct range for block to pass originality test. Most visible stamped number on top is not only one which needs to be correct for collector car market. Besides its easier to fake S4 block to look like GTS block than to cut GTS block into pieces and attach them to S4 block. At least when block is in car and all additional stuff is mounted in.
cant you cut them back to fit? i know they are pretty long, but is that a possibility?
#183
Rennlist Member
#184
Captain Obvious
Super User
Super User
Even though the engine was fixed in a somewhat unussual way, it is worth more than a S4 replacement. I this was a good financial decision.
#185
Archive Gatekeeper
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
??? My COA contains VIN, engine and transmission serial numbers. Am I missing something here? Thanks!
That's actually a good thing that the COA has them, 'cause for ~$100 you have factory validation of matching numbers if that matters in a given transaction.
#186
Rennlist Member
D'oh! No, _I'm_ missing something- I was knee-jerking based on the fake COA generator template that exists here somewhere. I have to confess that I've never ordered a real COA, so I will somewhat sheepishly retract my statement..... That's actually a good thing that the COA has them, 'cause for ~$100 you have factory validation of matching numbers if that matters in a given transaction.
#187
Archive Gatekeeper
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Compared to what Ferrari charges for Classiche certification, a Porsche COA is a frickin' steal. (though the process is much more involved for classic F-cars, and the stakes are just a little higher...)
http://www.ferrarichat.com/forum/att...mentid=1837743
http://www.ferrarichat.com/forum/att...mentid=1837743
#188
Under the Lift
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Nice to see the recent updates. This thread is getting close to a happy ending. Oh, still much to be done, but it appears all doable after the woeful impressions 6 years ago. Keep those rod nuts in the glovebox.
#189
Rennlist Member
How many pieces you want to cut? I can quickly think of four different things in any 928 block which all must be either exactly right or in correct range for block to pass originality test. Most visible stamped number on top is not only one which needs to be correct for collector car market. Besides its easier to fake S4 block to look like GTS block than to cut GTS block into pieces and attach them to S4 block. At least when block is in car and all additional stuff is mounted in.
Can you describe the differences? I have wondered what it may take to get my S4 motor back up to GTS spec but if I were to go this route eventually it would have to be with a system that worked/resolved the apparent GTS flaws.
Originality is not my concern- more a question of recovering original performance [or better] without compromising anything.
I understand the GTS has some reliefs in the casting to give more clearance from the rotating assembly although exactly where no clue- presumably close to the rod nuts?
Rgds
Fred
#190
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
All design differencees between S4/GT and GTS block have been talked about years ago in few threads. There are pictures of them in archives.
#192
Rennlist Member
Thanks chaps- not particularly interested in the paper work trail as the only person I intend to fool is myself [I am pretty good at that!].
A better way of expressing myself would be "what needs to be done to fit a GTS rotating assembly [or stroker crank] to the S4 block and make it work correctly".
I know there is some difference in the inter bay breathing and this has been challenged as to its effectiveness of operation. Indeed the entire GTS crank design has been challenged and some strokers have a crank more in line with the S4 configuration [or so I understand].
That Porsche tried to stroke their original design and arguably failed as they changed rod design and never got the breather system right suggests that doing so is a major challenge for others like Greg to take this on board and achieve success speaks volumes not to mention what you chaps in Finland have also achieved.
I was following this thread with interest as Rob's mission to get his original motor back to stock form in perfect condition is quite a challenge in itself given the rod that let go and subsequent damage. That fitting a wet sleeve is not viable according to Greg is also interesting- presumably because of the lack of "meat" in the casing design. Clearly a design that was at or near to its limits.
Rgds
Fred
A better way of expressing myself would be "what needs to be done to fit a GTS rotating assembly [or stroker crank] to the S4 block and make it work correctly".
I know there is some difference in the inter bay breathing and this has been challenged as to its effectiveness of operation. Indeed the entire GTS crank design has been challenged and some strokers have a crank more in line with the S4 configuration [or so I understand].
That Porsche tried to stroke their original design and arguably failed as they changed rod design and never got the breather system right suggests that doing so is a major challenge for others like Greg to take this on board and achieve success speaks volumes not to mention what you chaps in Finland have also achieved.
I was following this thread with interest as Rob's mission to get his original motor back to stock form in perfect condition is quite a challenge in itself given the rod that let go and subsequent damage. That fitting a wet sleeve is not viable according to Greg is also interesting- presumably because of the lack of "meat" in the casing design. Clearly a design that was at or near to its limits.
Rgds
Fred
Last edited by FredR; 09-30-2015 at 09:24 AM.
#193
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Mostly in my workshop located in Sweden.
Posts: 2,226
Received 442 Likes
on
244 Posts
Fred, I was going to put a GTS crank into a S4 block but as you remember I sold the crank to Houssam in Saudi Arabia. Now it will be a 3.75" stroker crank with 104mm pistons under some special ported 2V heads. I have not checked very carefully but if there is an interference between the the rotating assembly and the block it cannot be very much, not more than it can be cleaned out using the die grinder.
The major design fault with the 928 engine block is that the oil drains also have to act as pressure equalizer between the crankcase and the heads. Best is to add some chimneys inside the V for the pressure equalization making the oil drains to work as they are intended to do. Check out the Ford Modular engine block which is very well designed in this respect.
Åke
http://www.drivingenthusiast.net/sec-blog/?p=4024
The major design fault with the 928 engine block is that the oil drains also have to act as pressure equalizer between the crankcase and the heads. Best is to add some chimneys inside the V for the pressure equalization making the oil drains to work as they are intended to do. Check out the Ford Modular engine block which is very well designed in this respect.
Åke
http://www.drivingenthusiast.net/sec-blog/?p=4024
#194
Compared to what Ferrari charges for Classiche certification, a Porsche COA is a frickin' steal. (though the process is much more involved for classic F-cars, and the stakes are just a little higher...)
http://www.ferrarichat.com/forum/att...mentid=1837743
http://www.ferrarichat.com/forum/att...mentid=1837743
As an aside and since it was mentioned in this thread, the dirty little secret with the Ferrari Classiche program is that Ferrari really doesn't know the original info in most cases. So the client answers a questionnaire citing all the original info, stampings present and documentation the client may have, and then build a book with the information the client provided in a book that the client is charged for.
On top of that, I know of hard data where a client had a car restored to "factory" through Classiche and showed the car in a reputable concours and didn't even garner a Silver because so much was incorrect. In one specific case that I know personally, the clients spent many hundreds of thousands precisely so he would "ace" the concours test. Disappointed is an understatement.
Rob is doing this the right way for long term value of his GTS, in my opinion. Glad he is preserving most of it and cosmetically it will be indistinguishable.
#195
Rennlist Member
been racing a pretty stock 85 block with it bore out to 104mm and using 968 sized pistons and a much larger stroke crank than the S4 with no issues... I dont know the details of why the GTS has the oiliing issues, but i would think with the S4 block or 85 block, there should be no issues if you use custom pistons and Nicasil or find the coating and make GTS copy pistons. if you have the pistons and rods, i would just bore that out to use 968 pistons and make it a GTS over bore engine.
i think that still would be near 6 liter.
i think that still would be near 6 liter.