Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums

Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums (https://rennlist.com/forums/)
-   924/931/944/951/968 Forum (https://rennlist.com/forums/924-931-944-951-968-forum-70/)
-   -   For those running a square setup, how do you like it? (https://rennlist.com/forums/924-931-944-951-968-forum/1128852-for-those-running-a-square-setup-how-do-you-like-it.html)

AkechiMotors 02-12-2019 05:01 AM

For those running a square setup, how do you like it?
 
I'm thinking about going 8" all around, and was wondering what to expect. I've read that going square helps address the car's tendency to understeer - is that others' experience? After going to a square setup, are you happy, or are you thinking about going back to a staggered configuration?

951and944S 02-12-2019 08:22 AM


Originally Posted by AkechiMotors (Post 15633058)
I'm thinking about going 8" all around, and was wondering what to expect. I've read that going square helps address the car's tendency to understeer - is that others' experience? After going to a square setup, are you happy, or are you thinking about going back to a staggered configuration?

What you read would be logical, a wider tire up front or narrower tire in rear would combat understeer...., wouldn't be my 1st line of defense but yes, it would.

Early on, we used to run the forged 944TS wheels for their strength and lightness but it didn't take long to switch back to the phone dials.

Being able to rotate tires front to back gives you the ability to move the most abused tire around the car, giving us at least 1.5-2 times peak performance, not to mention more predictable handling, which lessens at track tuning and compensation adjustments. Other than for track bumpiness/smoothness, we never make a handling change at the track with exception to tire pressure.

Unless you have enough power to break the rear end loose (with lsd) on throttle exit to the point that it's slowing you down, 4 x the same wheel/tire is the way to go.
All above comments are on 8V 944 NA SP2 race car,
On the 968, we run same philosophy, but 9.5" wheels with 275/17 on all 4 corners.

T




odonnell 02-12-2019 09:35 AM

I have 7J square setup on my street NA. If anything I get oversteer more than anything due to my sway bar setup and coilover settings. It's definitely nice being able to rotate the tires. And I can cheaply find decent tires to suit.

lamrith 02-12-2019 09:41 AM


Originally Posted by 951and944S (Post 15633151)
What you read would be logical, a wider tire up front or narrower tire in rear would combat understeer...., wouldn't be my 1st line of defense but yes, it would.

Early on, we used to run the forged 944TS wheels for their strength and lightness but it didn't take long to switch back to the phone dials.

Being able to rotate tires front to back gives you the ability to move the most abused tire around the car, giving us at least 1.5-2 times peak performance, not to mention more predictable handling, which lessens at track tuning and compensation adjustments. Other than for track bumpiness/smoothness, we never make a handling change at the track with exception to tire pressure.

Unless you have enough power to break the rear end loose (with lsd) on throttle exit to the point that it's slowing you down, 4 x the same wheel/tire is the way to go.
All above comments are on 8V 944 NA SP2 race car,
On the 968, we run same philosophy, but 9.5" wheels with 275/17 on all 4 corners.

T

Good info! SO a follow up, are those stock body cars, or widebody? 275 is quite a bit of rubber and about where I am hoping to go with my car, just did not intend/want to do a widebody kit.

968to986 02-12-2019 09:45 AM

I recently went to a square setup with 17x8.5 Boxster rear wheels at all corners with 255/40 R compound tires. I’ve done one time attack and several mountain road drives so far and the car feels great with excellent turn in and lots of grip. Of course I’ve done a multitude of changes over the past year so it’s not like I can speak much to that single change, but I think it’s worth doing, especially if you’re driving skill allows you to push the car really hard. That said, I’m still looking forward to getting a larger adjustable rear sway bar to get the car to rotate even more.

951and944S 02-12-2019 11:44 AM


Originally Posted by lamrith (Post 15633248)
Good info! SO a follow up, are those stock body cars, or widebody? 275 is quite a bit of rubber and about where I am hoping to go with my car, just did not intend/want to do a widebody kit.

1992 968 stock body. They barely clear so we are checking for clearance before racing in this configuration for 1st time week after next.

We have new 275 Z214 C51 Hankook set as well as slightly narrower wheel with new 245 R7 Hoosier mounted to trial and test.

On an NA 8v 944, anything over 245/16 is overkill and probably slower over a lap.

T

Dan Martinic 02-12-2019 01:40 PM

What might be the reason Porsche went with the staggered setup? Was it a marketing thing?

T&T Racing 02-12-2019 01:49 PM


Originally Posted by Dan Martinic (Post 15633832)
What might be the reason Porsche went with the staggered setup? Was it a marketing thing?

Stagger is more appropriate with turbo engine and a soft rear sway bar to avoid oversteer from apex to corner exit

AkechiMotors 02-12-2019 02:12 PM

Great responses so far - thanks!

951and944S 02-12-2019 03:50 PM

BTW - I probably have 2 complete sets (7.5 + 9) of the forged Trubo S clubsports in track wheel shape, (painted or powder coated black) if anybody looking for those.

T

lamrith 02-12-2019 03:50 PM


Originally Posted by T&T Racing (Post 15633862)
Stagger is more appropriate with turbo engine and a soft rear sway bar to avoid oversteer from apex to corner exit

Is it strictly because of the extra power of the turbo, or how the power comes on?

I am building a high horsepower car and want to get a good setup. I like the idea of square for rotation and longevity as this will be a street car. But I also want it to perform and handle as it is being built as a twisty mtn road car.

MAGK944 02-12-2019 05:29 PM


Originally Posted by lamrith (Post 15634136)
Is it strictly because of the extra power of the turbo, or how the power comes on?

I am building a high horsepower car and want to get a good setup. I like the idea of square for rotation and longevity as this will be a street car. But I also want it to perform and handle as it is being built as a twisty mtn road car.

I don’t think staggered wheels is a “power” dependent thing as Porsche also fitted staggered Fuchs wheels on the 944 2.5 na.

Imo you should look at your suspension “setup” taking all aspects into consideration rather than isolating the wheels, there are better ways of inducing under/over steer than fitting wider or narrower wheels. If swapping tires on axles is important to you then you’re stuck with square anyway.

rlets 02-15-2019 01:47 AM

Love it! 17x9 with 255/40 NT-01 all around for several years now.

Jay Wellwood 02-15-2019 08:51 AM

While not an apples to apples comparison, keep in mind Porsche ran a square wheel setup on the 924GTP Lemans, but slightly different tire sizes-

https://www.porsche.com/uk/accessori...p-restoration/

Wheels: BBS rims front and rear: 11.75 x 16
Dunlop Racing, front: 275/600 x16
Dunlop Racing, rear: 300/825 x 16

Not advocating one way or another. Just a data point for consideration.

944crazy 02-15-2019 08:53 AM

Imho the 50/50 weight distribution really lends itself to a square tyre setup. If you are building a high power car then get yourself at least 9" wide wheels all round. Personally I run 265/35r18 semi slicks all round and really like it.... enough rear grip for putting the power down out of corners, and enough front grip to put the big reds to good use while braking. Thinking of moving to some 17 inch slicks for track work this year though.


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 01:09 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands