The 718 Spyder RS Discussion Thread
#931
Rennlist Member
looks like $H*T ... I wont be trading my Spyder for that regardless of the GT3 engine ... but glad that its finally broken cover ... enjoy!
#932
Rennlist Member
#933
Rennlist Member
#934
Rennlist Member
I'm assuming this is the early engineering solution and doesn't include input from the styling team. The reaction, in this thread, is pretty unanimous, so it seems hard to believe the Porsche designers don't also believe this is ugly.
The following users liked this post:
UncleDude (05-10-2022)
#935
Rennlist Member
#936
The following users liked this post:
mdork (05-10-2022)
#937
What I don't get for the Spyder is why ruin the lines with the top up by removing the sails as I think the sails are a very critical element of the design of the Spyder along with the humps.
The Spyder is a very compromised design when it comes to the RS ethos since it won't have the swan neck rear wing. Because of no swan neck rear wing, it won't have all of the other front aero bits needed to balance the downforce of the car so the aero elements are out of the question.
Then with the convertible, there won't be a way to stylistically incorporate an intake path such as the GT4 RS where it's right next to your ear. In this case, why remove the sails, as a weird looking intake port when they can just use the existing intake that is there now and route the intake path up from there? I know some have said that because the air it hotter from that area, it doesn't provide the lower temp that the engineers desire so that's why it was moved to the rear quarter window on the GT4 RS. I guess on the Spyder RS since it's not going to be able to match the outright performance since it won't have all of the aero bits, I think giving up a little in hp because the intake air is a little warmer then desired will be met with much better enthusiasm vs removing the sails and putting that cow-bell-looking-thing-that's-laying-on-its-side there for the air intake.
Some have said that these prototype have been designed to be ugly on purpose so maybe those that are in the know and reported the Spyder RS being real months ago can go back to your sources and ask about the sails and air intake element.
The Spyder is a very compromised design when it comes to the RS ethos since it won't have the swan neck rear wing. Because of no swan neck rear wing, it won't have all of the other front aero bits needed to balance the downforce of the car so the aero elements are out of the question.
Then with the convertible, there won't be a way to stylistically incorporate an intake path such as the GT4 RS where it's right next to your ear. In this case, why remove the sails, as a weird looking intake port when they can just use the existing intake that is there now and route the intake path up from there? I know some have said that because the air it hotter from that area, it doesn't provide the lower temp that the engineers desire so that's why it was moved to the rear quarter window on the GT4 RS. I guess on the Spyder RS since it's not going to be able to match the outright performance since it won't have all of the aero bits, I think giving up a little in hp because the intake air is a little warmer then desired will be met with much better enthusiasm vs removing the sails and putting that cow-bell-looking-thing-that's-laying-on-its-side there for the air intake.
Some have said that these prototype have been designed to be ugly on purpose so maybe those that are in the know and reported the Spyder RS being real months ago can go back to your sources and ask about the sails and air intake element.
#938
Rennlist Member
I guess we can wait until the official launch to see what they will actually name it ... I'll bet its not "RS" ... but then I have been consistently wrong so it probably will be ...
The following 2 users liked this post by Dyim:
Larry Cable (05-10-2022),
Sharm (05-11-2022)
#940
Rennlist Member
LOL the reactions. I thought Rennlist was full of seasoned Porsche pros? I'm a newbie and know it won't look anything like that on the back end. Here's the 992 GT3 mule...... OMG THE WING THE WING!!!!!, THE BUMPER LOLZ I HATE IT!!!
The following 2 users liked this post by UncleDude:
mdork (05-10-2022),
P-car-Vancouver (05-11-2022)
#941
We will all need to wait and see the final product before final judgment.
If nothing else, it gives us all more reason to be on RL to discuss something that I know I'll never have a chance to get cuz it'll be marked up so much, they might as well have said that all of the body panels have been switched out to unobtainium or vibranium for that matter.
The following users liked this post:
P-car-Vancouver (05-11-2022)
#942
No top please.
#943
^^^^^^Definitely no to that. Sorry but not sorry.
I'll take the Spyder RS without the sails and the cow bell intake design anyday over that abomination.
I'll take the Spyder RS without the sails and the cow bell intake design anyday over that abomination.
The following 2 users liked this post by halfmonkey:
Larry Cable (05-10-2022),
P-car-Vancouver (05-11-2022)
#944
Pro
Glad to see the GT4RS have a convertible counterpart. I will hold off my opinion until I see the final release build. Don’t think 95% of the people here will see this Spyder RS in person. Most will be locked up in collections and never driven most likely.
Plus, it will be easily a $300k+ car if you’re lucky enough to get your hands on 1.
Plus, it will be easily a $300k+ car if you’re lucky enough to get your hands on 1.
Last edited by Unstock; 05-10-2022 at 07:02 PM.
The following users liked this post:
Larry Cable (05-10-2022)
#945
Rennlist Member
Yup, these prototypes are "designed" to be ugly and to hide the actual truth underneath but in seeing what they're hiding on the Spyder RS, it seems they got rid of the sails and that totally changes the look of the car especially from a side profile.
We will all need to wait and see the final product before final judgment.
If nothing else, it gives us all more reason to be on RL to discuss something that I know I'll never have a chance to get cuz it'll be marked up so much, they might as well have said that all of the body panels have been switched out to unobtainium or vibranium for that matter.
We will all need to wait and see the final product before final judgment.
If nothing else, it gives us all more reason to be on RL to discuss something that I know I'll never have a chance to get cuz it'll be marked up so much, they might as well have said that all of the body panels have been switched out to unobtainium or vibranium for that matter.