The 718 Spyder RS Discussion Thread
#5401
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Mid-Atlantic (on land, not in the middle of the ocean)
Posts: 13,372
Received 4,557 Likes
on
2,589 Posts
The following users liked this post:
Jay Cordeiro (08-12-2023)
#5402
Rennlist Member
FYI for those considering sofa's and you plan to sell your SRS eventually, it will probably command a lower price point for having sofas. I've been tracking the 4RS market and the sofa 4RS's move much slower and get discounted much quicker to have to be sold. Most of the 4RS's that have traded in the 220-240k range all had sofa's. Will that translate to the SRS? Who knows but I personally would never consider buying an SRS with sofas.
The following users liked this post:
Manifold (08-12-2023)
#5403
Rennlist Member
I for sure am going to look into this esp since the sofas on configurator aren’t heated or ventilated. If they were it would be missing that plumbing and while expensive buying the buckets would be an easier swap.
#5404
Rennlist Member
FYI for those considering sofa's and you plan to sell your SRS eventually, it will probably command a lower price point for having sofas. I've been tracking the 4RS market and the sofa 4RS's move much slower and get discounted much quicker to have to be sold. Most of the 4RS's that have traded in the 220-240k range all had sofa's. Will that translate to the SRS? Who knows but I personally would never consider buying an SRS with sofas.
I do wonder what the LWB take rate will be for the SRS, because the SRS is not a track focused car like the GT4RS.
I’d ask in the other forum about speedsters and their LWB order rate. It’s likely the closest comparison
#5406
Rennlist Member
<cue indignant dismissal of assessment as “too loud” with attendant dismissal of the reviewer’s relevance / ability>
FWIW, he’s not wrong. But then again, neither are those of you who say it isn’t too loud. Personal preference / use case. It’s objectively loud. Whether it is “too loud” is subjective. If I snag one, I’ll likely keep a nice comfy pair of noise canceling head phones in the car for my SO for tours / trips. (Heck, not a bad idea for my current spyder) And a pair of ear plugs for me, for extended curvy road driving. Price of admission. And that’s okay. Legendary car, and all that.
Of all the press cars, I think I’m liking the GR + WP the best. Would carmine seat inserts clash?
FWIW, he’s not wrong. But then again, neither are those of you who say it isn’t too loud. Personal preference / use case. It’s objectively loud. Whether it is “too loud” is subjective. If I snag one, I’ll likely keep a nice comfy pair of noise canceling head phones in the car for my SO for tours / trips. (Heck, not a bad idea for my current spyder) And a pair of ear plugs for me, for extended curvy road driving. Price of admission. And that’s okay. Legendary car, and all that.
Of all the press cars, I think I’m liking the GR + WP the best. Would carmine seat inserts clash?
Last edited by Adrift; 08-13-2023 at 11:14 AM.
#5407
Rennlist Member
#5408
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Mid-Atlantic (on land, not in the middle of the ocean)
Posts: 13,372
Received 4,557 Likes
on
2,589 Posts
The reviewer notes that, while he greatly enjoyed the SRS on those ideal driving roads, he also can comparably enjoy other cars, like his GT3. I have a bunch of cars spanning a broad price range, and I similarly find that I can greatly enjoy just about all of them, appreciating each for what it is, on the right roads. As long as a car has balanced handling, good steering feel, good torque curve with enough power and good sounds (not too quiet nor too loud), transmission which is matched to the engine, brakes that feel strong enough and easily modulated, and good ergonomics, the car can be plenty fun to drive. Lots of cars meet all those requirements.
So where do the 4RS and SRS add distinct value? I'm still not sure. I'll drive the 4RS again to try to figure that out, but I'm unlikely to get a chance to track one before buying one. For the SRS, yes, it has that engine, but even a base Boxster is plenty fast for public roads, and while the SRS sounds good, I do worry that the loudness of the car will grow old and may damage my hearing over time.
Also, I would NEVER let rain pour into an expensive car like this! For that matter, I wouldn't even do it with an inexpensive car.
#5409
Rennlist Member
For me the review confirmed why I want the SRS. It seems to be the modern Porsche that most resembles my 996 GT3 in rawness and connection to the road, plus it combines the two Porsche brands that I love the most into one car (Boxster + GT3). I imagine it as if my 996 GT3 and my Boxster had a child. Just like my 6gt3, the SRS is not meant to be a comfy daily driver or a long trip car. It's best used as a 30-60min sweaty-palms attack on all your senses after which you need some rest as your adrenaline goes back to normal -- and for that it approaches perfection, missing only the manual.
This is why I also strongly support ordering the LWBS with every SRS unless it's a big mismatch for health or body size reasons.
This is why I also strongly support ordering the LWBS with every SRS unless it's a big mismatch for health or body size reasons.
Last edited by hf1; 08-13-2023 at 11:25 AM.
The following 3 users liked this post by hf1:
#5410
<cue indignant dismissal of assessment as “too loud” with attendant dismissal of the reviewer’s relevance / ability>
FWIW, he’s not wrong. But then again, neither are those of you who say it isn’t too loud. Personal preference / use case. It’s objectively loud. Whether it is “too loud” is subjective. If I snag one, I’ll likely keep a nice comfy pair of noise canceling head phones in the car for my SO for tours / trips. (Heck, not a bad idea for my current spyder) And a pair of ear plugs for me, for extended curvy road driving. Price of admission. And that’s okay. Legendary car, and all that.
Of all the press cars, I think I’m liking the GR + WP the best. Would carmine seat inserts clash?
FWIW, he’s not wrong. But then again, neither are those of you who say it isn’t too loud. Personal preference / use case. It’s objectively loud. Whether it is “too loud” is subjective. If I snag one, I’ll likely keep a nice comfy pair of noise canceling head phones in the car for my SO for tours / trips. (Heck, not a bad idea for my current spyder) And a pair of ear plugs for me, for extended curvy road driving. Price of admission. And that’s okay. Legendary car, and all that.
Of all the press cars, I think I’m liking the GR + WP the best. Would carmine seat inserts clash?
#5411
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Mid-Atlantic (on land, not in the middle of the ocean)
Posts: 13,372
Received 4,557 Likes
on
2,589 Posts
For me the review confirmed why I want the SRS. It seems to be the modern Porsche that most resembles my 996 GT3 in rawness and connection to the road, plus it combines the two Porsche brands that I love the most into one car (Boxster + GT3). I imagine it as if my 996 GT3 and my Boxster had a child. Just like my 6gt3, the SRS is not meant to be a comfy daily driver or a long trip car. It's best used as a 30-60min sweaty-palms attack on all your senses after which you need some rest as your adrenaline goes back to normal -- and for that it approaches perfection, missing only the manual.
This is why I also strongly support ordering the LWBS with every SRS unless it's a big mismatch for health or body size reasons.
This is why I also strongly support ordering the LWBS with every SRS unless it's a big mismatch for health or body size reasons.
#5412
Rennlist Member
Good question. The current combo already satisfies my Porsche needs extremely well. Garage space may require that I let the Boxster go but I'll worry about it when/if it comes to it. Maybe few comparo drives on my backroads will decide which one (if any) will have to go. If SRS gives me what I get from my 6gt3, the 6gt3 may be the one to go, but I doubt it -- many cars have been such pretenders but no cigar so far. Hard to predict now. And this is all assuming I can get a SRS at MSRP. The fact that I'm already a happy camper makes me more determined to be adamant about no ADM. Great position to be in.
#5413
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Mid-Atlantic (on land, not in the middle of the ocean)
Posts: 13,372
Received 4,557 Likes
on
2,589 Posts
Good question. The current combo already satisfies my Porsche needs extremely well. Garage space may require that I let the Boxster go but I'll worry about it when/if it comes to it. Maybe few comparo drives on my backroads will decide which one (if any) will have to go. If SRS gives me what I get from my 6gt3, the 6gt3 may be the one to go, but I doubt it -- many cars have been such pretenders but no cigar so far. Hard to predict now. And this is all assuming I can get a SRS at MSRP. The fact that I'm already a happy camper makes me more determined to be adamant about no ADM. Great position to be in.
#5414
Rennlist Member
I'd be very reluctant to let a 996 GT3 go. Nothing else will give you that experience, and unlike the SRS, it's a manual. Letting the Boxster would be easier, but then SRS is still not manual and sits at a much higher price point and the top is much harder to deal with.
The following users liked this post:
Patrick3000 (08-14-2023)
#5415
Pro
I love the color, it gives this classic retro style the car has mixed with the motorsport parts. My 718 Spyder is GT Silver and I love how it shows the curves.
Disclaimer: I love bold colors, my 992 GT3 is shark blue and my wife’s MacanGTS Miami blue, but in this retro style car I love this classic metallic colors that show the bumps so well
Disclaimer: I love bold colors, my 992 GT3 is shark blue and my wife’s MacanGTS Miami blue, but in this retro style car I love this classic metallic colors that show the bumps so well
The following users liked this post:
Manifold (08-13-2023)