Cylinders detached from case... Advice?
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Cylinders detached from case... Advice?
Doing top end, heads came back from Steve Wiener on Friday. I was rotating the engine on the stand when I noticed the cylinders 4-5-6 had come slightly apart from the case (1/4 to 1/8" from one side to the other). I had totally forgot to put a spacer and nut on the stud to hold 'em down.
At the time I didn't think about it and was eager to get going, so just bolted the heads and cam carriers back on. Now I'm waiting for a tool (cam holder) to arrive and so have had a bit more time to think this over... and am now starting to worry that I may get leaks from the base/case join.
However I intentionally didn't want to go any deeper in to pull pistons, as I don't have the special tool for the snap rings on the pistons / conn rods. Seems to me I could either bite the bullet and pull it apart to replace base seals, or keep going on reassembly and start it up to check for leaks before fully reinstalling (although it will be about 90% there).
What would the collective wisdom of the board suggest?
TIA/Brian
At the time I didn't think about it and was eager to get going, so just bolted the heads and cam carriers back on. Now I'm waiting for a tool (cam holder) to arrive and so have had a bit more time to think this over... and am now starting to worry that I may get leaks from the base/case join.
However I intentionally didn't want to go any deeper in to pull pistons, as I don't have the special tool for the snap rings on the pistons / conn rods. Seems to me I could either bite the bullet and pull it apart to replace base seals, or keep going on reassembly and start it up to check for leaks before fully reinstalling (although it will be about 90% there).
What would the collective wisdom of the board suggest?
TIA/Brian
#2
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
I would replace the base gaskets of each cylinder by popping out the circlips and removing each piston/barrel as a unit. The circlip tool is cheap ( Stomski has them http://www.stomskiracing.com/products.php?id=6).
If you don't do this, you know it will leak, its Murphy at work.. :-)
Cheers,
Mike
If you don't do this, you know it will leak, its Murphy at work.. :-)
Cheers,
Mike
#3
Doing top end, heads came back from Steve Wiener on Friday. I was rotating the engine on the stand when I noticed the cylinders 4-5-6 had come slightly apart from the case (1/4 to 1/8" from one side to the other). I had totally forgot to put a spacer and nut on the stud to hold 'em down.
At the time I didn't think about it and was eager to get going, so just bolted the heads and cam carriers back on. Now I'm waiting for a tool (cam holder) to arrive and so have had a bit more time to think this over... and am now starting to worry that I may get leaks from the base/case join.
However I intentionally didn't want to go any deeper in to pull pistons, as I don't have the special tool for the snap rings on the pistons / conn rods. Seems to me I could either bite the bullet and pull it apart to replace base seals, or keep going on reassembly and start it up to check for leaks before fully reinstalling (although it will be about 90% there).
What would the collective wisdom of the board suggest?
TIA/Brian
At the time I didn't think about it and was eager to get going, so just bolted the heads and cam carriers back on. Now I'm waiting for a tool (cam holder) to arrive and so have had a bit more time to think this over... and am now starting to worry that I may get leaks from the base/case join.
However I intentionally didn't want to go any deeper in to pull pistons, as I don't have the special tool for the snap rings on the pistons / conn rods. Seems to me I could either bite the bullet and pull it apart to replace base seals, or keep going on reassembly and start it up to check for leaks before fully reinstalling (although it will be about 90% there).
What would the collective wisdom of the board suggest?
TIA/Brian
Thanks,
Ken
#4
Seared
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I would replace the base gaskets of each cylinder by popping out the circlips and removing each piston/barrel as a unit. The circlip tool is cheap ( Stomski has them http://www.stomskiracing.com/products.php?id=6).
If you don't do this, you know it will leak, its Murphy at work.
If you don't do this, you know it will leak, its Murphy at work.
Andreas
#5
Seared
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
#7
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
(Sigh) yeah I know you're right, I knew that's what I had to do the minute I actually thought about... But needed someone to tell me not to be a lazy esso bee and just do it.
Mike, thx for the tip on where to find the tool, now that I know what it's called I see it lots of places. I was getting nada looking for Porsche special tool 9500/2. So I'll buy the tool and pull the P&C's as a unit and put in new base seals with a smidge of curil-t for good measure. Any idea what diameter I need (96 varioram), or do I have to measure before ordering?
Also, do you think I can get away with re-using the cam carrier bolts and/or cylinder head gaskets, or do I need to replace one or both? I ended up ordering an extra set of head gaskets by mistake so am inclined to do them again, but am hoping I can re-use the bolts, they were $$ if I recall.
Btw pcarworshop has been a major source of guidance for this project, I literally don't think I could have worked up the nerve to do this (or actually complete it, though the jury's still out on that one). Since I couldn't make your annual bbq I'll have to figure out another way to buy you a beer in gratitude.
Thx again
Cheers/bc
Mike, thx for the tip on where to find the tool, now that I know what it's called I see it lots of places. I was getting nada looking for Porsche special tool 9500/2. So I'll buy the tool and pull the P&C's as a unit and put in new base seals with a smidge of curil-t for good measure. Any idea what diameter I need (96 varioram), or do I have to measure before ordering?
Also, do you think I can get away with re-using the cam carrier bolts and/or cylinder head gaskets, or do I need to replace one or both? I ended up ordering an extra set of head gaskets by mistake so am inclined to do them again, but am hoping I can re-use the bolts, they were $$ if I recall.
Btw pcarworshop has been a major source of guidance for this project, I literally don't think I could have worked up the nerve to do this (or actually complete it, though the jury's still out on that one). Since I couldn't make your annual bbq I'll have to figure out another way to buy you a beer in gratitude.
Thx again
Cheers/bc
Trending Topics
#8
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Cheers/bc
#9
Banned
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: En La Boca Del Raton
Posts: 1,341
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I would replace the base gaskets of each cylinder by popping out the circlips and removing each piston/barrel as a unit. The circlip tool is cheap ( Stomski has them http://www.stomskiracing.com/products.php?id=6).
If you don't do this, you know it will leak, its Murphy at work.. :-)
Cheers,
Mike
If you don't do this, you know it will leak, its Murphy at work.. :-)
Cheers,
Mike
sonny1.
#11
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
So I'll buy the tool and pull the P&C's as a unit and put in new base seals with a smidge of curil-t for good measure. Any idea what diameter I need (96 varioram), or do I have to measure before ordering?
Also, do you think I can get away with re-using the cam carrier bolts and/or cylinder head gaskets, or do I need to replace one or both?
Also, do you think I can get away with re-using the cam carrier bolts and/or cylinder head gaskets, or do I need to replace one or both?
Not sure which bolts you are referring to - the ones that hold the cam carrier to the heads? You can reuse most of the bolts on the engine. Definitely replace the head gasket rings on each tightening, they are compressed and deformed on each tightening.
Of course, I should be have been more explicit, replace the circlips that you remove to take off the barrels/pistons. Obviously, keep the wrist pins and cylinders matched to the correct position on the engine. It will give you a good opportunity to check the condition of wrist pin bushings as well. Remember to be generous on the assembly lube when putting the wrist pins back in, and use a cloth around all the open holes when the clips are being inserted - its a total pain in the butt if you drop a clip into the engine...
I lubed the base gaskets with Dow Corning 111, and then used Curil-t right next to base gasket as well .. has not leaked yet.
Cheers
Mike
#12
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Believe it or not this started out as a suspension refresh (M030 springs & ARBs, Koni FSDs). Also needed a new clutch soon, and had been throwing CEL / SAI error intermittently. So I figure, might as well do all that "while I'm in there" so I don't pay for a 4 wheel alignment twice...
the engine drop
the lump
the "upgraded" clutch fork shaft (with about 60K miles)!
#13
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
the leaking RMS
one dirty engine (looking at this I'm thinking my cylinder bases were leaking already...)
the cam sprocket, soon to be backdated to 964 style
one dirty engine (looking at this I'm thinking my cylinder bases were leaking already...)
the cam sprocket, soon to be backdated to 964 style
#15
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
head / valves - before (I forgot to get an "after" pic but they're real purty)
pistons before - alla carbonara
there were pistons under all that!
pistons before - alla carbonara
there were pistons under all that!