Center lock wheel vs 5 lug your choice and safety in design
#1
Center lock wheel vs 5 lug your choice and safety in design
Wondering what most guys and or gals like for their wheel attachment. I went with the center lock wheel over the 5 lug. Why? I like the unique look mainly. I know both do the job, but does anyone know which design is actually stronger or safer in design? I have no fears either way, but am curious!
On the point of mounting or dismounting, I know some will say well its hard to get the center lock wheel off and on and if you have a tire change on the road, you are hosed. My thought is the car doesn't carry a full size spare to change it out on the road anyways. Either use a fill kit, have the tools, are haul it lol
I know there is a bit of expense in the torque wrench and wheel alinement pin if you want to protect your rotors, if you are going to to take a wheel off with a center lock design. I ordered one from ED on the forum and its very nicely priced and very nicely made.
On the strength and safety issue point, I was just curious as to the good and bad in both designs. I know some will say you have other lugs holding the wheel as opposed to one etc. And then some will say all the lug holes weaken a wheel and exotic race cars run center locks. This will be a good one lol
On the point of mounting or dismounting, I know some will say well its hard to get the center lock wheel off and on and if you have a tire change on the road, you are hosed. My thought is the car doesn't carry a full size spare to change it out on the road anyways. Either use a fill kit, have the tools, are haul it lol
I know there is a bit of expense in the torque wrench and wheel alinement pin if you want to protect your rotors, if you are going to to take a wheel off with a center lock design. I ordered one from ED on the forum and its very nicely priced and very nicely made.
On the strength and safety issue point, I was just curious as to the good and bad in both designs. I know some will say you have other lugs holding the wheel as opposed to one etc. And then some will say all the lug holes weaken a wheel and exotic race cars run center locks. This will be a good one lol
Last edited by stratocaster69; 08-28-2015 at 02:29 PM. Reason: Typos
#2
Race Car
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Fairfax County, Virginia
Posts: 4,025
Received 3,879 Likes
on
1,359 Posts
I am quite sure that the Porsche engineers have done all the strength and durability testing, and since they use centerlocks on their race cars, you can rest assured that they will take anything you can throw at them. Porsche is really good about sharing the technical information about such things as well, perhaps contact them to see is there are technical papers on it.
The 5-lug system has an advantage if you ever want to put aftermarket wheels on, you have lots more choices (especially in pre-owned wheels), but other than that - you get what puts a smile on your face.
The 5-lug system has an advantage if you ever want to put aftermarket wheels on, you have lots more choices (especially in pre-owned wheels), but other than that - you get what puts a smile on your face.
#3
I am quite sure that the Porsche engineers have done all the strength and durability testing, and since they use centerlocks on their race cars, you can rest assured that they will take anything you can throw at them. Porsche is really good about sharing the technical information about such things as well, perhaps contact them to see is there are technical papers on it.
The 5-lug system has an advantage if you ever want to put aftermarket wheels on, you have lots more choices (especially in pre-owned wheels), but other than that - you get what puts a smile on your face.
The 5-lug system has an advantage if you ever want to put aftermarket wheels on, you have lots more choices (especially in pre-owned wheels), but other than that - you get what puts a smile on your face.
Never even thought about the 5 lug and all the wheel choices. Good Point! Thats why I posted this. So I can learn more!
#4
Rennlist Member
I am quite sure that the Porsche engineers have done all the strength and durability testing, and since they use centerlocks on their race cars, you can rest assured that they will take anything you can throw at them. Porsche is really good about sharing the technical information about such things as well, perhaps contact them to see is there are technical papers on it.
The 5-lug system has an advantage if you ever want to put aftermarket wheels on, you have lots more choices (especially in pre-owned wheels), but other than that - you get what puts a smile on your face.
The 5-lug system has an advantage if you ever want to put aftermarket wheels on, you have lots more choices (especially in pre-owned wheels), but other than that - you get what puts a smile on your face.
#5
Rennlist Member
#6
#7
Rennlist Member
Trending Topics
#8
Thanks again Larry. You are a very informative enthusiast. And I did just see somewhere a few days ago a hub maintenance guideline. Basically so a person knows what the heck they are doing. Its not just taking them on and off. I thought myself that was the deal, but than noticed the many things to look for.
Appreciated!
Appreciated!
#9
Rennlist Member
Thanks again Larry. You are a very informative enthusiast. And I did just see somewhere a few days ago a hub maintenance guideline. Basically so a person knows what the heck they are doing. Its not just taking them on and off. I thought myself that was the deal, but than noticed the many things to look for.
Appreciated!
Appreciated!
there are a couple of things to note; there is a specific set of 'protocols' you need to follow with CL wheels both for take off/install, but there is also some
inspection that you need to do of the system itself, *and* there is a maintenance schedule you need to follow this especially for track usage.
#10
Rennlist Member
all that said, I have CL's on my GT3 and my GTS...
#14
Rennlist Member
My guess is that in competitive race application, the centerlock is way faster for wheel changes. I would assume it's just cool race car tech trickled down to the consumer.
They def have a cleaner look
They def have a cleaner look