Picking up the 50th today. Quick question for those w/ manuals before I do.
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Picking up the 50th today. Quick question for those w/ manuals before I do.
Are you happy with the 7 speed manual? Just read a few blurbs this morning about people being less than enthused with the manual box in the 991. I have not driven a manual in this car yet. Just wanted to see if owners of the manual are generally happy with the transmission? In other words, I have no doubt I want a manual, but I'm just wondering if the manual is frustrating to the point of disrupting the experience? I saw one reference to it being one of the 10 worst manual transmissions? Manual owners, would you keep the transmission if you could do it over? This is my paranoid 23rd hour vetting to make sure I'm not making a mistake post.
#2
Banned
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: Chicagoland Area
Posts: 26,142
Likes: 0
Received 5,388 Likes
on
2,509 Posts
Go get your new car. You'll love it!
#5
991 manual is excellent. I'm sure the PDK is great for the track, but if you love rowing your own gears, you will really enjoy the mechanical nature of the manual.
For now, tho, ignore 7th gear. Just concentrate on driving in gears 2-5. They are very tall gears, and you'll have lots of opportunity to keep the rev range just where you want it to maximize the use of the engine performance and overall fun factor.
For now, tho, ignore 7th gear. Just concentrate on driving in gears 2-5. They are very tall gears, and you'll have lots of opportunity to keep the rev range just where you want it to maximize the use of the engine performance and overall fun factor.
#6
Burning Brakes
The manual transmission is fantastic. I can't see how anyone can call it "frustrating" or "one of the 10 worst". It's smooth, quick, and the gear spacing is just right.
#7
Rennlist Member
Trending Topics
#9
Burning Brakes
I don't understand the negative comments (usually hearsay) about the 991's 7MT. It's not the "best" I've ever had, but certainly good. It seems a little notchy until the engine/tranny get up to operating temperature but once warmed up it's very snick-snick.
1st and 2nd are pretty low, 3rd-5th more closely spaced, 6th and 7th for cruising. I use 7th pretty much anytime I'm over 65mph for the gas mileage improvement. I've seen as high as 29mpg cruising at 85 with a bike on the roofrack, pretty amazing I'd say.
1st and 2nd are pretty low, 3rd-5th more closely spaced, 6th and 7th for cruising. I use 7th pretty much anytime I'm over 65mph for the gas mileage improvement. I've seen as high as 29mpg cruising at 85 with a bike on the roofrack, pretty amazing I'd say.
Last edited by mtbscott; 03-14-2014 at 03:36 PM.
#10
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Dec 2013
Location: canada
Posts: 674
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Are you happy with the 7 speed manual? Just read a few blurbs this morning about people being less than enthused with the manual box in the 991. I have not driven a manual in this car yet. Just wanted to see if owners of the manual are generally happy with the transmission? In other words, I have no doubt I want a manual, but I'm just wondering if the manual is frustrating to the point of disrupting the experience? I saw one reference to it being one of the 10 worst manual transmissions? Manual owners, would you keep the transmission if you could do it over? This is my paranoid 23rd hour vetting to make sure I'm not making a mistake post.
#11
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I've driven the 996 6MT quite a bit, and briefly the 991 7MT. Both were fine, with the 991 being better.
That said, it was not the best, nor smoothest ones I've driven. But it wasn't the worst. For German cars, I think they were both pretty good.
Best I've ever had was the Civic Si and the S2K (or really any Honda), with a close second being the Audi S4.
That said, it was not the best, nor smoothest ones I've driven. But it wasn't the worst. For German cars, I think they were both pretty good.
Best I've ever had was the Civic Si and the S2K (or really any Honda), with a close second being the Audi S4.
#12
Three Wheelin'
10 worst manuals? Crazy. The 991 manual is the best I've driven. Better than the Honda sourced manuals that I've had (Acura TL Type-S and RSX) and runs laps around BMW's six speed. Enjoy your new car and post pics!
#13
Hi Ceepe,
You will adore your new baby!
Can't wait til you share your excitement with us all here and we need pictures!
When you are driving your baby home and shifting through your sweet gears you will be thinking why did I ask this question?
You with be ear to ear in love with her
Have a blast!
BeeBalm
You will adore your new baby!
Can't wait til you share your excitement with us all here and we need pictures!
When you are driving your baby home and shifting through your sweet gears you will be thinking why did I ask this question?
You with be ear to ear in love with her
Have a blast!
BeeBalm
#14
Burning Brakes
Myself, I find the 991 manual to be an absolute joy. One drive with the 991 manual was all it took for me, she came home a few days later and my brand new 2013 Audi S5 Prestige Cab got traded in (lol).
The gear you must be in to get to 7th is 5th, and it's an easy up-and-up over to 7th anytime - and from 7th to anywhere else, 2nd, 3rd, whatever. Driven for 12K + miles now, really love it. Here are just a few youtube vids driving the manual, if you'll notice I just go to 3rd, 5th, and 7th on an entrance ramp.
Bessy was born before October 2012 so she doesn't have rev-matching.
The gear you must be in to get to 7th is 5th, and it's an easy up-and-up over to 7th anytime - and from 7th to anywhere else, 2nd, 3rd, whatever. Driven for 12K + miles now, really love it. Here are just a few youtube vids driving the manual, if you'll notice I just go to 3rd, 5th, and 7th on an entrance ramp.
Bessy was born before October 2012 so she doesn't have rev-matching.
Last edited by Nicoli35; 03-14-2014 at 05:56 PM.