Pics added --> KKK turbo inspection - shaft play question
#1
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Pics added --> KKK turbo inspection - shaft play question
Inspecting a used turbo.
Should there be any up/down play in the shaft? I understand the end play discussion but really have seen no discussion on up/down play. I can't think it's normal but want to check for sure. (Compressor blades show no sign of housing impact)
On a basic teardown, the shaft looks ok (measures across consistently as well, no scores or high/low points) but there is some sort of problem at what I would expect to be the seal on the hot side. There are some sort of metal rings or something that are in pieces.
Will be able to post pics on Monday but wanted to get first impressions now.
Thanks in advance.
Jeff
Should there be any up/down play in the shaft? I understand the end play discussion but really have seen no discussion on up/down play. I can't think it's normal but want to check for sure. (Compressor blades show no sign of housing impact)
On a basic teardown, the shaft looks ok (measures across consistently as well, no scores or high/low points) but there is some sort of problem at what I would expect to be the seal on the hot side. There are some sort of metal rings or something that are in pieces.
Will be able to post pics on Monday but wanted to get first impressions now.
Thanks in advance.
Jeff
Last edited by Jeff N.; 09-14-2009 at 06:05 PM.
#4
Nordschleife Master
Easy shaft check... roll the shaft on a table and look for the threaded end to wobble back and forth... it will indicate a bent shaft, they can be straightened but it takes some skill...
the seals are split rings, 2 on the turbine end of the shaft, 1 on the collet on the compressor end... these should receive a liberal amount of lithium grease on re-assembly...
as you have torn the turbo down it will need to be rebalanced prior to re-assembly..
excessive radial (side to side play) is a sign of worn bearings (solid bushing type) and can be replaced, there are 2 and they are held in by a pair of snap rings each... the bushing / bearings are brass... and should be a bright brass color... an off color indicates cheap Chinese brass, these wear out faster...
excessive axial (in and out) is usually caused by a worn thrush bearing, or associated part (usually the thrust bearing as it is brass, the other pieces are steel and alloy...) a new thrust bearing should be installed when the turbo is taken apart for rebuild, and is usually included in any rebuild kit...
I rebuilt my turbo... kit was $110 from gpopshop.com ( http://www.gpopshop.com/kkkkits.html )..
and I took the rotating assy to a local shop for balancing ($60) took about an hour... the full rebuild took me about 3 hours of my time, plus balancing... and a few other consumable items (thread locker, lithium grease, assy lube)...
All said and done.. I would pay a shop to do it were I to do it again... difference in cost is roughly $100... but they blast all the pieces clean... a properly rebuilt turbo will look and perform as new... or better (when I had mine balanced, he case hardened the turbine and shaft... I now get boost at 2100RPM, with full boost before 3000 RPM...)
the seals are split rings, 2 on the turbine end of the shaft, 1 on the collet on the compressor end... these should receive a liberal amount of lithium grease on re-assembly...
as you have torn the turbo down it will need to be rebalanced prior to re-assembly..
excessive radial (side to side play) is a sign of worn bearings (solid bushing type) and can be replaced, there are 2 and they are held in by a pair of snap rings each... the bushing / bearings are brass... and should be a bright brass color... an off color indicates cheap Chinese brass, these wear out faster...
excessive axial (in and out) is usually caused by a worn thrush bearing, or associated part (usually the thrust bearing as it is brass, the other pieces are steel and alloy...) a new thrust bearing should be installed when the turbo is taken apart for rebuild, and is usually included in any rebuild kit...
I rebuilt my turbo... kit was $110 from gpopshop.com ( http://www.gpopshop.com/kkkkits.html )..
and I took the rotating assy to a local shop for balancing ($60) took about an hour... the full rebuild took me about 3 hours of my time, plus balancing... and a few other consumable items (thread locker, lithium grease, assy lube)...
All said and done.. I would pay a shop to do it were I to do it again... difference in cost is roughly $100... but they blast all the pieces clean... a properly rebuilt turbo will look and perform as new... or better (when I had mine balanced, he case hardened the turbine and shaft... I now get boost at 2100RPM, with full boost before 3000 RPM...)
#5
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
OK. helpful. I'm out of spec on the radial play but it's not hitting the housing. Next question.
On the cold side, there is a shaft "centering" bushing that goes into the shaft housing. (This does not look like the load bearing). This bushing is a bit loose in the back plate housing and there is bright wear on the housing where it moves.
It looks like part 8 is loose in part 12 in this picture. Part 12 is worn. How serious is that problem?
On the cold side, there is a shaft "centering" bushing that goes into the shaft housing. (This does not look like the load bearing). This bushing is a bit loose in the back plate housing and there is bright wear on the housing where it moves.
It looks like part 8 is loose in part 12 in this picture. Part 12 is worn. How serious is that problem?
#6
Nordschleife Master
OK. helpful. I'm out of spec on the radial play but it's not hitting the housing. Next question.
On the cold side, there is a shaft "centering" bushing that goes into the shaft housing. (This does not look like the load bearing). This bushing is a bit loose in the back plate housing and there is bright wear on the housing where it moves.
It looks like part 8 is loose in part 12 in this picture. Part 12 is worn. How serious is that problem?
On the cold side, there is a shaft "centering" bushing that goes into the shaft housing. (This does not look like the load bearing). This bushing is a bit loose in the back plate housing and there is bright wear on the housing where it moves.
It looks like part 8 is loose in part 12 in this picture. Part 12 is worn. How serious is that problem?
the nut on the end torques the compressor wheel against part 8, which in turn torques against part 7 which in turn torques against part 4 which torques against the turbine shaft...
4 is a washer, 7 is a spacer, 8 is the collet seal on the compressor end...
does that make sense?
no reason to worry about light wear in part #12.. as long as new bushings (part #1) resolve the axial play issues, and the entire assy torques down properly..
Trending Topics
#8
Burning Brakes
All said and done.. I would pay a shop to do it were I to do it again... difference in cost is roughly $100... but they blast all the pieces clean... a properly rebuilt turbo will look and perform as new... or better (when I had mine balanced, he case hardened the turbine and shaft... I now get boost at 2100RPM, with full boost before 3000 RPM...)
also, how exactly do they balance the turbo? is it just a matter of rotating the turbine until it balances out?
#9
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Here's a few pics from the used unit.
Should be a K27/7200 compressor wheel. Look like one? Leading edge of the compressor blades have some impact marks...bad air cleaner?
Backside showing balancing marks and where material has been removed.
Here's the cold side housing. You can see the slight wear in the bushing area. John, after your description, this doesn't seem to be a problem.
The shaft. You can see what's left of the seals hanging on the shaft. There is also some very slight scoring on the shaft. In this area the shaft mics out about .001 under the rest of the shaft. How serious is this do you think? You can see the wear on the coldside but it's smooth.
Should be a K27/7200 compressor wheel. Look like one? Leading edge of the compressor blades have some impact marks...bad air cleaner?
Backside showing balancing marks and where material has been removed.
Here's the cold side housing. You can see the slight wear in the bushing area. John, after your description, this doesn't seem to be a problem.
The shaft. You can see what's left of the seals hanging on the shaft. There is also some very slight scoring on the shaft. In this area the shaft mics out about .001 under the rest of the shaft. How serious is this do you think? You can see the wear on the coldside but it's smooth.
#10
Nordschleife Master
You balance the turbinge first, it gets spun on a turbine balancer at high speed with a strobe light illuminating the imbalance... the operator marks it with different marks (see pics) to keep track, and then grinds off material to make it within the balance spec...
then the same is done to the compressor wheel, mounted on a precision mandrel, then the compressor is mounted to, and torqued onto the turbine shaft... and the entire assy is balanced... then marked to ensure it is CLOSE when re-assembled into the center section...
SOME also balance it after it is mounted into the center section... and grind away the nose of the compressor wheel to ensure the entire thing is balanced...
Yup, that is the marks put on during balancing, and the grind spot is the operators work at balancing the wheel...
The shaft. You can see what's left of the seals hanging on the shaft. There is also some very slight scoring on the shaft. In this area the shaft mics out about .001 under the rest of the shaft. How serious is this do you think? You can see the wear on the coldside but it's smooth.